- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Advantages and disadvantages of a joint stock company
Explain the advantages of the company form, such as large capital, limited liability, liquidity and economies of scale, and its disadvantages, such as costly formation, oligarchy and weak labour relations, as the Tamil Nadu textbook lists them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain eight advantages of the company form.
- Explain seven disadvantages of the company form.
- Compare how risk is spread in a company and in a partnership.
The company form has helped build railways, power plants and the factories that make our phones and vehicles. But separating ownership from management also creates new problems: shareholders may have little say, and managers spending other people's money may not care as an owner would. A balanced answer needs both sides.
Advantages
- Large capital: a company can raise far more capital than a sole trader or partnership, which large-scale business needs.
- Limited liability: a shareholder's liability is limited (in a company limited by guarantee, to the amount he guaranteed on winding up), so people are willing to invest.
- Transferability of shares: shares can be sold easily, giving liquidity of investment.
- Perpetual succession: continuity lets the company make long-term investments.
- Promotion of saving and investment: even a small saver can buy a single share.
- Risk-bearing capacity: losses are spread over many shareholders, so each bears little.
- Economies of large-scale operation: large production brings cost efficiency.
- Economic development: companies drive growth of industry and trade, create jobs, promote balanced regional development and pay substantial taxes.
Disadvantages
- Costly and difficult to form: many legal formalities cost promoters time and money.
- Scope for dishonest management: directors, working through paid officers, may misuse power for personal gain.
- Management oligarchy: a few rich persons may control the company (oligarchy means control by a small group).
- Speculation: a few individuals may corner shares to gain control.
- Lack of interest: paid officers may lack incentive, initiative and willingness to take risks.
- Lack of good labour relations: owners and workers rarely meet, so there is more scope for industrial disputes.
- High taxation: the textbook says companies pay tax at higher rates than other forms.
Company form: the balance
-
Strengths
- Large capital
- Limited liability
- Liquidity
- Continuity
- Spread of risk
- Economies of scale
-
Weaknesses
- Costly formation
- Possible dishonest directors
- Control by a few
- Speculation
- Weak personal interest
- Labour disputes
- Higher taxes (as the textbook says)
The company's strength is the separation of ownership from management (capital from many, management by experts); its weakness is the same separation (owners far from control, managers without personal stake).
Worked example 1: spreading a loss
A made-up company with 50,000 equal shares loses ₹10,00,000 in a year; a made-up partnership of 4 equal partners loses the same amount. Working: company: loss per share = 10,00,000 ÷ 50,000 = ₹20, so a holder of 100 shares bears 100 × 20 = ₹2,000 (and only through a fall in the value of his investment, since his liability is limited). Partnership: each partner bears 10,00,000 ÷ 4 = ₹2,50,000, and could lose personal property too. This is the risk-bearing capacity the textbook describes.
Worked example 2: spotting the disadvantage
Name the disadvantage in each (made-up) case: (a) two wealthy families quietly buy up shares until they control the board; (b) the managing staff of a company refuse a promising new product because 'it is not our money'; (c) workers in a large plant strike over a grievance the owners never heard about. Reasoning: (a) speculation leading to management oligarchy; (b) lack of interest; (c) lack of good labour relations due to no personal contact.
Key takeaways: a company can raise large capital, offers limited liability, liquid shares and continuity, encourages saving, spreads risk, enjoys economies of scale and aids economic development; but it is costly to form, may suffer dishonest or oligarchic management and speculation, its officers may lack interest, labour relations may be weak, and the textbook notes higher taxation.
Check your understanding
-
1. Liquidity of investment in a company comes from:
- perpetual succession
- transferability of shares
- the common seal
- high taxation
Show answer
Answer: B. Since shares can be sold easily, a shareholder can convert his investment into money: that is liquidity.
-
2. Control of a company's affairs by a few rich persons is called:
- management oligarchy
- perpetual succession
- mutual agency
- limited liability
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook calls control by a small group management oligarchy.
-
3. A company with 20,000 equal shares loses ₹4,00,000. The loss per share is:
- ₹200
- ₹2
- ₹50
- ₹20
Show answer
Answer: D. 4,00,000 ÷ 20,000 = ₹20 per share. Spreading the loss over many shareholders is the company's risk-bearing capacity.
-
4. Which is a disadvantage of the company form given in the textbook?
- Promotion of saving
- Economies of large-scale operation
- Costly and difficult formation
- Large capital
Show answer
Answer: C. Many legal formalities make formation costly and time-consuming. The other three are advantages.
-
5. Why may there be more industrial disputes in a company than in a sole trading business?
- Companies have unlimited liability
- Shares are freely transferable
- Companies pay lower taxes
- There is little personal contact between owners and workers
Show answer
Answer: D. In a sole trading business personal supervision is possible; in a company owners and workers rarely meet, so grievances can grow into disputes.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.