- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Advantages and disadvantages of cooperatives
Explain the advantages of cooperative societies, such as democracy, limited liability, government support and freedom from moneylenders, and their disadvantages, such as limited funds, government control and benefit to the rural rich, as the Tamil Nadu textbook lists them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the main advantages of cooperative societies.
- Explain the main disadvantages of cooperative societies.
- Evaluate why some cooperatives fail.
Cooperatives have done a great deal for farmers, weavers and workers in India, especially in freeing villagers from moneylenders. Yet many have also failed through poor management or misuse of funds. The textbook lists twelve advantages and twelve disadvantages; this lesson explains them in groups so they are easier to remember.
Advantages
| Advantage | Explanation (as in the textbook) |
|---|---|
| Voluntary organisation | Open to all with a common interest; low membership fee; no entry or exit barriers |
| Easy formation | Easier than a company; the textbook says any 25 adult members can form one with simple formalities |
| Democracy | One member, one vote; money power cannot buy control |
| Equal distribution of surplus | Surplus shared equitably; the textbook says up to 10% may be used for the welfare of the locality |
| Limited liability | Members' liability limited to their capital contribution |
| Separate legal entity | Unaffected by death, insanity or insolvency of members; perpetual existence |
| Each for all, all for each | Based on self-help and mutual help |
| Greater identity of interest | Works in a limited area; members know and cooperate with each other |
| Government support | Cheap loans, subsidies and other help |
| Elimination of middlemen | Deals directly with producers and consumers, saving middlemen's profit |
| Tax concessions | Exemptions and concessions as a non-profit enterprise, as the textbook states |
| Rural credit | Cheaper loans have helped free villagers from moneylenders' high interest |
Disadvantages
- Limited funds: members are often from weaker sections, fees are low, and one member one vote with limited dividends reduces enthusiasm, so growth is limited.
- Over-reliance on Government funds: uncertain Government funding makes planning difficult.
- Imposed by Government: the textbook says that in Western countries cooperatives were started voluntarily by the weaker sections, but in India the movement was initiated by the Government, so wide participation is lacking.
- Benefit to the rural rich: rich farmers capture managing committees and, having surplus produce, gain most from processing, grading and fair prices.
- Inadequate rural credit: loans only for productive purposes leave the poor dependent on moneylenders for marriage, medical and social expenses.
- Lack of managerial skills: elected committees may lack skill, and low pay cannot attract talent.
- Government intervention: heavy regulation reduces autonomy and flexibility.
- Misuse of funds: corrupt committee members may swindle funds; many societies have closed for this reason.
- Inefficiency leading to losses: without talent, technology or modern methods, losses follow.
- Lack of secrecy: all members know the affairs, and reports go to the Registrar of Cooperative Societies.
- Conflicts among members: internal politics and quarrels disrupt work.
- Limited scope: unsuitable for industries needing large investment.
Cooperatives: strengths and weaknesses
-
Strengths
- Democratic control
- Limited liability, perpetual existence
- No middlemen
- Government support and tax concessions
- Cheap rural credit
-
Weaknesses
- Limited funds and scope
- Dependence on and interference by Government
- Weak management, misuse of funds
- Rich members gain most
- No secrecy, member conflicts
Most cooperative failures come from people, not the idea: mismanagement, misuse of funds and conflicts among members.
Worked example 1: saving through cheap credit
A made-up farmer needs ₹20,000 for one year. A moneylender charges 36% a year; a cooperative credit society charges 9% a year (illustrative rates). Working: moneylender interest = 20,000 × 36 ÷ 100 = ₹7,200; cooperative interest = 20,000 × 9 ÷ 100 = ₹1,800. Saving = 7,200 - 1,800 = ₹5,400. This is the rural credit advantage. But if the farmer needs the money for a daughter's wedding, the textbook notes that a cooperative lending only for productive purposes may refuse, and he may still go to the moneylender.
Worked example 2: diagnosing a failing society
A made-up village marketing society has shrinking sales: its committee is controlled by three big landowners, its manager is untrained, and two committee members were found taking cash from the till. Reasoning: the disadvantages at work are benefit to the rural rich, lack of managerial skills and misuse of funds. Remedies follow from the principles: wider democratic participation, education and training, and honest management.
Key takeaways: cooperatives are voluntary, easy to form, democratic, share surplus equitably, have limited liability and a separate legal entity, enjoy Government support and tax concessions, remove middlemen and provide cheap rural credit; they suffer from limited funds and scope, dependence on and interference by Government, capture by the rural rich, weak management, misuse of funds, losses, lack of secrecy and member conflicts.
Check your understanding
-
1. A cooperative most often fails because of:
- unlimited membership
- cash trading
- mismanagement
- too many members voting
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook's disadvantages point to lack of managerial skill, misuse of funds and inefficiency; mismanagement is the main cause of failure.
-
2. Members with money power cannot dominate a cooperative because:
- it follows one member, one vote
- it has unlimited liability
- it pays no taxes
- it is a chartered body
Show answer
Answer: A. Under democracy, each member has one vote, so buying more shares does not buy more control.
-
3. According to the textbook, why do cooperatives in India lack wide participation?
- Because membership is closed
- Because they were started voluntarily by the weaker sections
- Because they have no legal entity
- Because the movement was initiated and established by the Government
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook contrasts Western cooperatives, started voluntarily by the weaker sections, with India, where the Government initiated the movement.
-
4. A cooperative's reports and accounts must be submitted to the Registrar of Cooperative Societies. This leads to which disadvantage?
- Lack of secrecy
- Limited liability
- Elimination of middlemen
- Rural credit
Show answer
Answer: A. Since members know the affairs and reports go to the Registrar, business information becomes public knowledge.
-
5. A farmer borrows ₹10,000 for a year at 8% from a cooperative instead of 30% from a moneylender (illustrative rates). How much interest does he save?
- ₹800
- ₹3,000
- ₹2,200
- ₹3,800
Show answer
Answer: C. Moneylender: 10,000 × 30 ÷ 100 = ₹3,000; cooperative: 10,000 × 8 ÷ 100 = ₹800. Saving = 3,000 - 800 = ₹2,200.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.