- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Disadvantages of MNCs
Explain the nine disadvantages of MNCs listed in the Tamil Nadu textbook, from danger to domestic industries to careless use of natural resources and promotion of alien culture.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List and explain the disadvantages of MNCs given in the textbook.
- Group them into economic, social and political dangers.
- Recognise the predatory pricing strategy the book describes.
The same size and power that let MNCs bring capital and technology can also harm a host country. The textbook therefore gives a matching list of nine disadvantages. Read them as risks a host country must watch for, not as facts about any particular company.
Economic dangers
- Danger to domestic industries: with their vast economic power, MNCs threaten domestic industries that are still developing. Such industries may be unable to face the challenge and may have to wind up, which sets back the economic growth of the host country.
- Transfer of outdated technology: if an MNC brings technology that is already out of date, the host country gains nothing from it.
- Misuse of mighty status: because they are so powerful, MNCs can bear losses for a long time, hoping to earn huge profits once local competition is gone and they hold a monopoly. The textbook calls this a possible 'dirty marketing strategy' to wipe out local competitors.
- Careless exploitation of natural resources: MNCs may use the host country's natural resources carelessly and rapidly deplete non-renewable ones, causing permanent damage to its economic development.
- Neglect of the home country: since investment in host countries may be more profitable, MNCs may neglect the industrial and economic development of their own home country.
Social dangers
- No benefit to poor people: MNCs tend to produce things used by the rich, so the poor of host countries generally get little benefit.
- Deprivation of job opportunities: MNCs may not generate job opportunities for local people.
- Selfish promotion of alien culture: to sell their products MNCs may promote foreign culture and make people forget their own cultural heritage. The textbook's Indian example is the taste MNCs created for synthetic food and soft drinks, which it says is also injurious to health.
Political danger
Danger to independence: the textbook warns that MNCs may first help the government of the host country in several ways and then gradually begin to interfere in its political affairs, creating a long-run danger to the host country's independence.
Disadvantages of MNCs
-
Economic
- Danger to domestic industries
- Outdated technology
- Misuse of mighty status
- Careless use of natural resources
- Neglect of home country
-
Social
- No benefit to the poor
- Fewer jobs for local people
- Promotion of alien culture
-
Political
- Danger to independence
An MNC's strength is also its danger: power to invest is also power to crush local firms, deplete resources and influence policy.
Worked example 1: the predatory pricing strategy
Made-up figures: a local biscuit maker sells a packet for ₹20 at a cost of ₹18. An MNC enters and sells a similar packet for ₹15 although its cost is also ₹18. Working: the MNC loses ₹18 − ₹15 = ₹3 per packet; on 10 lakh packets that is ₹30 lakh, a loss it can bear for years. The local firm cannot sell at ₹15 without losing ₹3 a packet, and it closes. With the rival gone, the MNC raises its price to, say, ₹25 and earns ₹25 − ₹18 = ₹7 per packet. This is the 'misuse of mighty status' the textbook describes.
Worked example 2: classify the problem
Situations (made up): (a) a foreign firm's mine exhausts a mineral deposit in a decade; (b) a firm's ads persuade children to drop traditional snacks for packaged drinks; (c) a firm installs machines that its home country has already scrapped. Answers: (a) careless exploitation of natural resources; (b) selfish promotion of alien culture; (c) transfer of outdated technology.
Key takeaways: MNCs can threaten infant domestic industries, bring outdated technology, ignore the poor, deny local jobs, misuse their power through loss-making prices, deplete natural resources, spread alien culture, neglect their home country and, in the long run, endanger the host country's independence.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why can domestic industries in a host country be endangered by MNCs?
- MNCs are not allowed to compete
- Domestic industries pay no taxes
- MNCs have vast economic power that developing domestic industries cannot match
- MNCs always charge higher prices
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says that because of their vast economic power, MNCs pose a danger to domestic industries still in the process of development, some of which wind up.
-
2. An MNC sells below cost for years until local rivals close, and then raises prices. The textbook calls this:
- misuse of mighty status
- managerial development
- end of local monopolies
- proper use of idle resources
Show answer
Answer: A. Bearing losses for a long time to wipe out local competitors and then earning monopoly profits is the 'misuse of mighty status', which the book calls a dirty marketing strategy.
-
3. The textbook's Indian example of 'selfish promotion of alien culture' is:
- the spread of ISO-9000 certificates
- the growth of exports
- the rise of R&D systems
- a taste for synthetic food and soft drinks
Show answer
Answer: D. The book says MNCs created a taste for synthetic food and soft drinks in India, which it also calls injurious to health.
-
4. 'No benefit to poor people' arises because MNCs:
- give away their products free
- mostly produce things used by the rich
- produce only food grains
- do not sell in host countries
Show answer
Answer: B. MNCs tend to produce goods used by the rich, so the poor of host countries generally do not benefit.
-
5. Made-up figures: an MNC sells at ₹12 an item that costs it ₹16. How much does it lose on 50,000 items?
- ₹2,00,000
- ₹6,00,000
- ₹8,00,000
- ₹80,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Loss per item = ₹16 − ₹12 = ₹4. For 50,000 items: 50,000 × ₹4 = ₹2,00,000. A powerful MNC can bear such losses to drive rivals out.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.