- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Contributions of Indian economic thinkers
Summarise the economic ideas of Thiruvalluvar, Mahatma Gandhi, Jawaharlal Nehru, B.R. Ambedkar, J.C. Kumarappa, V.K.R.V. Rao and Amartya Sen as presented in the textbook.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State Thiruvalluvar's ideas on agriculture, public finance, wealth and the welfare state.
- Explain the main features of Gandhian economic thought and Kumarappa's role.
- Describe Nehru's and Ambedkar's economic ideas.
- Summarise V.K.R.V. Rao's and Amartya Sen's contributions.
Long before modern textbooks, Indian thinkers wrote about wealth, work and welfare. The Tamil Nadu textbook introduces seven of them. Their ideas are described here as the textbook presents them; you need not agree with every view, but you should be able to explain each.
Thiruvalluvar
Thiruvalluvar's economic ideas are found in the Thirukkural, mainly in its second part, the Porutpal, which deals with wealth. The textbook places him in the Sangam age, around the third century CE, while noting that scholars differ on his date.
- Rain is the basis of life and of agriculture, the most fundamental economic activity.
- He refers to the factors of production: good harvests, able people and lasting wealth as parts of an economy.
- Agriculture is superior to all other occupations; the ploughman supports everyone else.
- Public finance: creation, collection and management of revenue, and public expenditure, with a preference for a balanced budget and spending kept within revenue.
- Main items of public spending: defence, public works and social services.
- He opposed seeking external assistance, favouring self-sufficiency.
- Poverty is the root of other evils; freedom from hunger is a basic freedom.
- Wealth is a means, not an end; it should be earned by honest means; hoarding is condemned.
- A welfare state: health, abundant wealth, good crops, happiness and security for all.
Mahatma Gandhi
Gandhian economics rests on ethical foundations: Gandhi held that economics which harms moral well-being is wrong. The textbook lists these features:
| Idea | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Village republics and village sarvodaya | Real India lives in villages; develop self-sufficient, self-dependent villages |
| Machinery and industrialism | He was strongly critical of large-scale machinery and industrialism, which he linked to exploitation |
| Decentralisation | Small-scale production at many places, even in homes |
| Bread labour | Dignity of manual labour: each person should earn bread by physical work |
| Trusteeship | The wealthy hold property as trustees for society, a way to move to an egalitarian order |
| Food controls | Opposed, as they create artificial scarcity |
| Population | Favoured self-control rather than contraceptives |
| Prohibition | Advocated total prohibition of liquor |
J.C. Kumarappa, born in Thanjavur, Tamil Nadu, in 1892, developed these ideas into a school he called Gandhian Economics. He promoted village industries, founded the All India Village Industries Association in 1935, wrote Economy of Permanence during imprisonment in the Quit India movement, and is called 'the Green Gandhian' by the historian Ramachandra Guha for his early environmental thinking.
Jawaharlal Nehru
India's first Prime Minister (until his death in 1964) believed in parliamentary democracy and secularism (equal respect for all religions). He introduced planning, which he saw as finding the best way to use all resources of manpower and money, linked to industrialisation and self-reliance. Many IITs and research institutions were set up in his time, and he stressed a scientific temper. His goal was a socialistic pattern of society through democratic socialism.
B.R. Ambedkar
Ambedkar (1891-1956), architect of the Indian Constitution, also earned doctorates in economics. His thesis The Problem of the Rupee won him a D.Sc. from the London School of Economics in 1923. The textbook groups his ideas under four heads:
- Financial economics: he traced the evolution of provincial finance in British India in three stages: budget by assignment, by assigned revenue and by shared revenues.
- Agricultural economics: his 1918 paper on small holdings distinguished consolidation of holdings from enlargement of holdings.
- Economics of caste: caste blocked social mobility and free choice of occupation, causing social tension and an absence of social democracy.
- State socialism: nationalisation of key industries, state ownership of land with collective farming, and state-run, compulsory insurance.
V.K.R.V. Rao
A pupil of J.M. Keynes, Rao is remembered for pioneering work on estimating India's national income and adapting national income concepts to developing countries. His 1952 study of the interrelation of investment, income and the multiplier in an underdeveloped economy was his main contribution to macroeconomics. In a 1938 pamphlet he blamed low per capita income on uneconomic holdings, poor irrigation, too many people on the land, lack of capital and lack of monetary autonomy. He proposed village clusters as units of rural development, worked on international food aid, and founded the Delhi School of Economics, the Institute of Economic Growth and the Institute for Social and Economic Change, Bangalore.
Amartya Sen
Sen received the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1998 for work on social choice, welfare and development economics.
Amartya Sen's main ideas
-
Poverty and famines (1981)
- Famines studied as entitlement failures
- Absolute and relative deprivation
-
Poverty and inequality
- Count how income is shared among the poor themselves
-
Capability
- Well-being = ability to turn goods into a good life
-
Entitlement
- Food, health, employment, security of food supply
-
Choice of technique
- In a labour-surplus economy, capital-intensive methods do not raise employment at first
Worked example: whose idea is it?
Match each statement. (a) 'Famines happen when people lose the ability to obtain food, even if food exists': Sen (entitlement). (b) 'A cluster of villages should be the unit of rural development': V.K.R.V. Rao. (c) 'The rich should hold wealth as trustees of society': Gandhi (trusteeship). (d) 'Spend within revenue; avoid deficits': Thiruvalluvar. (e) 'Caste blocks free choice of occupation': Ambedkar.
Thiruvalluvar: agriculture and balanced budgets. Gandhi: villages, bread labour, trusteeship. Nehru: planning and democratic socialism. Ambedkar: rupee, holdings, caste, state socialism. Rao: national income. Sen: entitlement and capability.
Key takeaways: Indian economic thought ranges from Thiruvalluvar's ethics of wealth, through Gandhi's and Kumarappa's village economy, Nehru's planning and Ambedkar's state socialism, to Rao's national income estimates and Sen's work on famines, capability and entitlement.
Check your understanding
-
1. Thiruvalluvar's economic ideas are mainly found in which part of the Thirukkural?
- Arathupal
- Inbathupal
- Porutpal
- Purananuru
Show answer
Answer: C. The second part of the Thirukkural, the Porutpal, deals with wealth and contains most of his economic ideas.
-
2. Who propagated Gandhian economic thinking and founded the All India Village Industries Association?
- J.C. Kumarappa
- V.K.R.V. Rao
- Amartya Sen
- Jawaharlal Nehru
Show answer
Answer: A. J.C. Kumarappa developed Gandhian Economics and founded the association in 1935.
-
3. Amartya Sen received the Nobel Prize in Economics in:
- 2008
- 2000
- 1990
- 1998
Show answer
Answer: D. Sen was awarded the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1998.
-
4. Ambedkar's 1918 paper on small holdings distinguished between:
- consolidation and enlargement of holdings
- rent and quasi-rent
- growth and development
- public and private sectors
Show answer
Answer: A. In that paper he separated consolidation of holdings (bringing scattered plots together) from enlargement of holdings (increasing their size).
-
5. V.K.R.V. Rao was a pupil of:
- Adam Smith
- J.M. Keynes
- Alfred Marshall
- Karl Marx
Show answer
Answer: B. Rao studied under J.M. Keynes and also worked with Colin Clark; H.W. Singer called him the best equipped of Keynes' pupils.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.