- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Geography, other disciplines and the two approaches
Explain how geography links with the physical and social sciences, compare the systematic and regional approaches, and describe Berry's geographical data matrix.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Name the branch of geography formed by its meeting with each related science.
- Compare the systematic (nomothetic) and regional (ideographic) approaches.
- Explain how a geographical data matrix arranges information.
Many subjects study one kind of phenomenon: rocks, plants, prices or past events. Geography studies several kinds together and asks how they vary over the earth's surface. That is why it overlaps with so many disciplines, and why new branches of geography appear wherever it meets another science.
Links with the physical sciences
- Astronomy, mathematics and computer science: astronomy studies celestial bodies; mathematics measures their location, motion, form and size; together with computer science they have produced modern cartography and GIS.
- Geology: studies rocks, minerals and petroleum. Geography looks at the distribution of exposed rocks, their interaction with climate and people, and the economic prospects of minerals. Their meeting produced geomorphology, the study of landforms.
- Physics and chemistry: the physics of the atmosphere is studied in climatology and of the hydrosphere in oceanography; geographers also care about the chemical content of rocks, soil, water and air.
- Botany and zoology: these classify and describe species; geography studies where plants and animals are found in relation to climate and relief, giving biogeography.
Links with the social sciences
| Discipline | What it studies | Shared branch |
|---|---|---|
| Economics | How needs and wants are met with available resources | Economic geography: resource endowment and use, agriculture, industry, trade, transport |
| Sociology | Institutions and behaviour of society | Social geography: social phenomena in a spatial context, rural-urban movement |
| Anthropology | Human races and their classification | Anthropogeography: human groups in relation to habitat and culture |
| History | Events arranged in time and place | Historical geography: thematic maps of past events; time and space studied together |
Where geography meets other sciences
-
Physical sciences
- Geology to geomorphology
- Physics to climatology and oceanography
- Botany and zoology to biogeography
- Mathematics and computers to cartography and GIS
-
Social sciences
- Economics to economic geography
- Sociology to social geography
- Anthropology to anthropogeography
- History to historical geography
Two approaches to studying geography
Early geographers mainly described. Later the subject became analytical, and today it describes, analyses and predicts. Two distinct approaches are used.
Systematic (nomothetic) approach. Introduced by the German geographer Alexander von Humboldt (1769-1859). One phenomenon, natural or human, is taken up and studied in detail across the earth to see the spatial patterns it produces. Systematic geography has four main branches: physical geography (atmosphere, hydrosphere, lithosphere, biosphere); biogeography including environmental geography (forests, grasslands, flora and fauna, quality of the living environment); human geography (culture, population, socio-economic and political aspects); and geographical methods and techniques (field, quantitative, qualitative and cartographic analysis).
Regional (ideographic) approach. Developed by Carl Ritter (1779-1859), a contemporary of Humboldt. Here a region is studied as a whole. A region may be based on one factor (relief, rainfall, vegetation, per capita income), on several factors together, or on administrative units such as states, districts and taluks. Its sub-branches are regional studies, regional analysis, regional development and regional planning.
Systematic = one topic, many places (Humboldt). Regional = one place, many topics (Ritter).
The geographical data matrix
A matrix arranges information in rows and columns. Brian J. L. Berry borrowed the idea from anthropology. In his matrix, rows hold the variables, which stand for the systematic or topical branches, and columns hold the regions. Reading along a row is a systematic study; reading down a column is a regional study. Stacking matrices for successive time periods, like slices of a three-dimensional cake, adds a third dimension: time, so change can be examined.
Worked example 1: reading a small matrix
| Variable | District P | District Q | District R |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rainfall (mm a year) | 900 | 1300 | 700 |
| Main crop | Millets | Paddy | Cotton |
| Share of urban people (%) | 30 | 45 | 20 |
Question: which reading is systematic and which regional? Step 1: comparing rainfall across P, Q and R means reading one row, one topic over many places, so it is systematic. Step 2: describing District Q by its rainfall, crop and urban share means reading one column, many topics in one place, so it is regional. Adding the same table for a later year would let us study change over time.
Worked example 2: which branch?
A researcher maps where a rare frog lives in relation to altitude and rainfall. Reasoning: the distribution of an animal in relation to climate and relief is where geography meets zoology. Answer: biogeography (more precisely, zoogeography).
Key takeaways: geography draws on physical and social sciences and forms branches such as geomorphology, climatology, biogeography, economic and social geography; the systematic approach (Humboldt) studies one phenomenon widely, the regional approach (Ritter) studies one region fully; Berry's data matrix puts variables in rows, regions in columns and time as a third dimension.
Check your understanding
-
1. The interaction of geology and geography gave rise to:
- biogeography
- geomorphology
- climatology
- anthropogeography
Show answer
Answer: B. Geology supplies knowledge of rocks; geography studies their distribution as landforms. Their meeting is geomorphology, the study of landforms.
-
2. The systematic approach to geography was introduced by:
- Alexander von Humboldt
- Carl Ritter
- Brian J. L. Berry
- William D. Pattison
Show answer
Answer: A. Humboldt introduced the systematic (nomothetic) approach. Ritter developed the regional approach and Berry the data matrix.
-
3. In Berry's geographical data matrix, the columns stand for:
- variables or topics
- time periods
- map scales
- regions
Show answer
Answer: D. Rows hold variables (the systematic branches) and columns hold regions. Time is added as a third dimension by stacking matrices.
-
4. Which of these is a sub-branch of regional geography?
- Regional planning
- Oceanography
- Cartography
- Meteorology
Show answer
Answer: A. The sub-branches of regional geography are regional studies, regional analysis, regional development and regional planning.
-
5. A study of all aspects of one district - relief, crops, population and industry - follows which approach?
- Systematic approach
- Regional approach
- Quantitative revolution
- Earth science tradition
Show answer
Answer: B. Studying many topics within one region is the regional (ideographic) approach. Studying one topic across many places would be systematic.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.