- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Approaching the period; the Arabs in Sind and Mahmud of Ghazni
Explain the different ways historians interpret the Sultanate period and its sources, the Arab conquest of Sind, and the rise of the Ghaznavids, Mahmud's raids and how historians read them, and the work of Al-Beruni.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe three ways historians have interpreted the Delhi Sultanate and name its main written sources.
- Explain the background, course and limited results of the Arab conquest of Sind.
- Describe Mahmud of Ghazni's rise and raids, the debate on their motives, and Al-Beruni's contribution.
Unit 10 of the Tamil Nadu textbook covers the arrival of Islamic institutions and culture in India and the Delhi Sultanate (1206-1526 CE). The book sets itself two aims: to give a conventional account of rulers and events, and to encourage students to examine it critically and ask new questions. This course follows both aims.
How historians see the period
Three approaches to the Sultanate (as the textbook summarises them)
-
Conventional
- Judges the regimes by the achievements and failures of individual Sultans
- Personality-centred history
-
Cultural-material
- Critiques personality-centred history
- Sees the Sultanate as adding to material and cultural development
- Stresses the growth of a composite culture
-
Class relations
- Sees the medieval state as the agent of the ruling class
- Judges Sultanate institutions as less developed than the Mughals'
The book concludes that there is no consensus on the true nature of the Sultanate. It also warns against calling it simply the 'Muslim period': its rulers were Arabs, Turks, Persians and Central Asians of many ethnicities. The Sultanate itself had five dynasties: Slave (1206-1290), Khalji (1290-1320), Tughlaq (1320-1414), Sayyid (1414-1451) and Lodi (1451-1526).
| Author | Work |
|---|---|
| Al-Beruni | Kitab-ul-Hind (also called Tarikh-al-Hind): Indian philosophy and religion, in Arabic |
| Minhaj-us-Siraj | Tabaqat-i-Nasiri (c. 1260) |
| Ziauddin Barani | Tarikh-i-Firoz Shahi (1357): history up to Firuz Tughlaq |
| Amir Khusrau | Miftah-ul-Futuh (victories of Jalal-ud-din Khalji); Khazain-ul-Futuh (victories of Ala-ud-din Khalji); Tughlaq Nama |
| Shams-i-Siraj Afif | Tarikh-i-Firuz Shahi, continuing Barani |
| Yahya bin Ahmad Sirhindi | Tarikh-i-Mubarak Shahi (under the Sayyid Mubarak Shah) |
| Ferishta | History of Muslim rule in India (Persian) |
The book quotes the historian Sunil Kumar's warning that Persian chronicles describe the Sultanate in exaggerated terms, and that modern scholars have sometimes accepted their views uncritically. Keep that in mind whenever a chronicle gives huge numbers.
Arabs and India before conquest
Arabia's position favoured trade with India. Even before Islam, Arab seafarers traded with both coasts, and some settled in Malabar and on the Coromandel coast; Arabs who married Malabar women and settled on the west coast were called Mappillais ('sons-in-law'). The military expedition of 712 and the later Ghaznavid and Ghurid raids, the book says, created instead a relationship of conqueror and conquered.
The Arab conquest of Sind (712)
Hajjaj bin Yusuf, the Arab governor of Iraq, claiming to act against pirates, sent two expeditions against Dahar, ruler of Sind, one by land and one by sea; both failed and their commanders were killed. With the Caliph's permission he then sent a full army, with 6,000 cavalry and a large camel corps, under his 17-year-old son-in-law Muhammad bin Qasim. Qasim stormed the port of Debal, which was plundered for three days, and then defeated Dahar and took Brahmanabad. (The textbook narrates Brahmanabad before Debal; most accounts place Debal first.) The book explains Dahar's weakness: his wazir betrayed him, part of his army deserted, and his Brahmin dynasty, which had taken power from an earlier Buddhist dynasty, had filled the high offices, leaving many discontented. Qasim promised the people of Sind protection for their faith if they surrendered, sent the customary one-fifth of the plunder to the Caliph and shared the rest with his soldiers.
Historians have called the conquest a 'triumph without results': it touched only a fringe of the country, and India then had about three centuries free of such invasions.
The Ghaznavids and Mahmud
As the Arab empire in Central Asia broke up, the Samanid kingdom emerged and itself split. In 963 Alaptigin, a Turkic slave who had been a Samanid governor in Khurasan, seized Ghazni in eastern Afghanistan. After him the nobles chose Sabuktigin, who began expansion southwards, defeated the Shahi ruler Jayapala and made his eldest son Mahmud governor. When Sabuktigin died in 997, the younger son Ismail had been named heir, but Mahmud, aged 27, defeated him and took the throne; the Caliph recognised him with a robe of investiture and the title Yamin-ud-Daulah ('right hand of the empire').
Mahmud ruled for 32 years and led 17 campaigns into India. He targeted temples that held vast treasure; after defeating the Shahi king Anandapala he went deep into the Ganga plain, raiding Mathura and Kanauj, and in 1025 attacked Somnath in Gujarat. The book notes that the raids involved slaughter and the destruction of places of worship, but that there is little evidence of large-scale conversion, and many who converted to save themselves later returned to their faith.
Why did Mahmud raid? The historians' debate
- Economic: the raids refilled the treasury to pay a permanent, professional army built around slave mounted archers, paid in cash from booty taken from Hindu kingdoms in India and Muslim kingdoms in Iran alike (he plundered the Iranian city of Ray in 1029).
- Political: many scholars, the book says, see the raids as more political and economic than religious; desecrating an enemy's temples was a common way of asserting authority in medieval India.
- Religious display: Ghaznavid soldiers also saw temple destruction as proof of the power of their god.
- Evidence: Romila Thapar points out that Hindu and Jain sources on Somnath are curiously silent and do not support the details in the Arab-Persian chronicles, whose figures (such as twenty million dinars from Somnath) are probably exaggerated.
The book adds that memories of these raids were later used, by both British and nationalist writers, in ways that deepened a communal divide. It also notes that 'Hind' and 'Hindu' were at first Arab and Iranian geographical words for India and Indians; later 'Hindu' came to mean Indians who were not Muslims.
Al-Beruni
Al-Beruni, mathematician, philosopher, astronomer and historian, came to India with Mahmud. He learned Sanskrit and studied Indian religious and philosophical texts before writing his Kitab-ul-Hind. The book says he translated Euclid into Sanskrit and carried knowledge of Aryabhata's work (including the idea that the earth's rotation causes day and night) to the West, calling him an 'inter-civilisational' link.
712: Muhammad bin Qasim conquers Sind - 'a triumph without results'. 997-1030: Mahmud of Ghazni's 17 raids, motivated, many scholars argue, more by wealth and power than by religion.
Worked example 1: testing a chronicle's number
Question: A chronicle says Somnath yielded twenty million dinars. How should a historian treat this? Working: (1) Sunil Kumar warns that Persian chronicles exaggerate. (2) The same kind of source gives very large figures for Ray too, suggesting a habit of boasting. (3) Romila Thapar notes that Indian sources do not corroborate the details. Answer: accept that Somnath was plundered and that the booty was large, but treat the exact figure as a claim, not a measurement.
Worked example 2: how long was the 'respite'?
Question: The book says India had a respite of about three centuries after 712. Does that fit Mahmud's dates? Working: Mahmud took the throne in 997 (after Sabuktigin's death) and raided India over the next three decades. 997 - 712 = 285 years, about three centuries. Answer: yes; the next major invasions came under Sabuktigin and Mahmud, close to three centuries later.
Key takeaways: historians read the Sultanate in conventional, cultural-material and class terms and have reached no consensus; Persian chronicles exaggerate. Arabs traded and settled peacefully on both coasts long before 712, when Muhammad bin Qasim conquered Sind, a 'triumph without results'. Alaptigin and Sabuktigin founded Ghaznavid power; Mahmud ruled 32 years and made 17 raids, including Somnath (1025), which many historians interpret as mainly political and economic. Al-Beruni learned Sanskrit and linked Indian and Islamic learning.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who was the ruler of Sind when the Arabs conquered it in 712?
- Jayapala
- Dahar
- Hajjaj bin Yusuf
- Anandapala
Show answer
Answer: B. Dahar ruled Sind; Hajjaj was the Arab governor of Iraq who sent the expedition; Jayapala and Anandapala were Shahi kings defeated by the Ghaznavids.
-
2. Why has the Arab conquest of Sind been called 'a triumph without results'?
- The Arabs lost every battle
- It touched only a fringe of India, and no major invasion followed for about three centuries
- Sind immediately became independent again
- The Caliph refused the plunder
Show answer
Answer: B. The conquest affected only a fringe of the country, after which India had a respite from invasions for about three centuries.
-
3. How many military campaigns did Mahmud of Ghazni lead into India?
- 15
- 19
- 12
- 17
Show answer
Answer: D. The book says Mahmud ruled for 32 years and conducted as many as 17 campaigns into India.
-
4. Which argument does Romila Thapar make about the Somnath raid, according to the textbook?
- Hindu and Jain sources are curiously silent and do not corroborate the Arab-Persian chronicles
- The raid never happened
- Mahmud converted the whole of Gujarat
- Somnath was a Buddhist site
Show answer
Answer: A. She notes the silence of those who suffered: Hindu and Jain sources on Somnath do not corroborate the details or viewpoints of the Arab chronicles.
-
5. Al-Beruni is remembered for:
- leading Mahmud's army at Somnath
- founding the Slave dynasty
- learning Sanskrit and writing Kitab-ul-Hind on Indian thought
- building the Qutb Minar
Show answer
Answer: C. Al-Beruni, who came with Mahmud, learned Sanskrit, studied Indian texts and wrote Kitab-ul-Hind; the book also credits him with carrying Aryabhata's ideas to the West.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.