- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Bhakti, Jainism and Buddhism in the south: conflict, influence and Ramanuja
Describe, as the textbook presents it, the conflicts between the bhakti saints and the Jains and Buddhists, how the traditions influenced each other, and Ramanuja's philosophy of Vishistadvaita.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the early conflicts in the Pallava and Pandya kingdoms recorded in bhakti tradition.
- Explain how the textbook accounts for the decline of Buddhism and Jainism in the Tamil country.
- List the ways in which the heterodox religions shaped Saivism and Vaishnavism.
- Explain the difference between Sankara's Advaita and Ramanuja's Vishistadvaita.
Religious history is often a story of argument as well as devotion. The Tamil Nadu textbook describes a period of sharp competition between the bhakti traditions and the sramanic religions, Jainism and Buddhism, and then shows that each side also left its mark on the other. As you read, notice where the book relies on tradition and hagiography and where it cites inscriptions; historians weigh these kinds of evidence differently.
Early conflicts, as the sources describe them
The book says the earliest conflicts came in the Pallava period. Mahendravarma Pallava I, a Jain at the time, is said to have persecuted followers of other faiths. Appar, known as Dharmasena while a Jain, turned to Saivism under the influence of his sister. According to the account, the king, advised by Jain teachers, tried to win him back first by persuasion and then by persecution, but in the end the king himself became a Saivite.
In the Pandya kingdom, tradition says that Sambandar defeated the Jains in a theological debate and that his opponents were then impaled. Maravarman Arikesari, known as Koon Pandyan, is said to have been brought back to Saivism under Sambandar's influence, and a Saivite legend speaks of a massacre of Jains at Samantham in Madurai district. The book adds that inscriptions indicate that the conflict did involve violence, including the impaling of monks. (In Unit 11 the book also notes that the numbers in tradition are questioned, while the persecution itself is not in doubt.)
The debate was also intellectual. Saiva Siddhanta texts contain long refutations of Buddhist and Jain philosophy; some, such as Sivagnana Sithiyar, have a separate section called parapakkam devoted to answering their arguments.
Why did Buddhism and Jainism decline in the Tamil country?
The book's judgement is that, despite all the philosophical debate, it was the popular nature of the bhakti movement and the royal patronage it received that led to the decline of Buddhism and Jainism. By the eleventh century both had lost their earlier position. Buddhism disappeared from the Tamil country, as from much of India, while Tamil-speaking Jain communities survive in pockets of Tamil Nadu to this day. Many shrines were destroyed or abandoned and many objects lost through neglect and vandalism; damaged images of the Buddha and of Jain tirthankaras can still be seen in many places.
How the traditions shaped each other
Marks left by the encounter (as listed in the textbook)
-
Ideas taken in
- renunciation, central to Buddhism and Jainism, adopted by Saivites and Vaishnavites
- high value on vegetarian food and on not killing animals
-
Responses and contrasts
- bhakti celebrated life with festivals and rituals, against heterodox simplicity and life-denial
- Tamil given supremacy, while the heterodox faiths used northern Prakrits
- devotion to Siva or Vishnu could overcome fate, unlike the fatalism the book attributes to them
The book concludes that Vedic Hinduism was itself transformed by the encounter with Buddhism and Jainism. This is the syncretism of the unit title: even rivals left a lasting influence on each other.
Ramanuja and Vishistadvaita
When the southern bhakti movement was at its height, Vaishnava scholars explained it philosophically. Ramanuja (Ramanujar) taught Vishistadvaita, qualified monism. Sankara's Advaita holds that the supreme reality and the individual souls are absolutely one; Ramanuja qualified this, teaching that souls are real and distinct while wholly dependent on the supreme god, so that loving devotion between the soul and god is meaningful. His school, the book says, took a reformist approach, and its influence later reached the north through teachers such as Ramananda (lesson 4).
Advaita and Vishistadvaita
-
Advaita (Adi Sankara)
- absolute monism
- the supreme and the souls are one
- the book says it remained at the intellectual level
-
Vishistadvaita (Ramanuja)
- qualified monism
- souls real but dependent on god
- gave bhakti a philosophical base
Worked example 1: weighing the evidence
Question: A hagiography says a saint's victory in debate was followed by the execution of thousands of his opponents. How should a historian treat this? Working: (1) note the type of source: a hagiography written to glorify the saint, so numbers and miracles may be exaggerated; (2) look for independent evidence: the book says inscriptions do indicate violence, including impaling of monks; (3) conclude carefully: the event of persecution is supported, while the scale given in tradition is uncertain. Answer: accept what is confirmed by independent sources and treat the rest as tradition.
Worked example 2: an influence chain
Question: Give one example from the book of a practice in bhakti Hinduism that may reflect Jain or Buddhist influence, and one that arose as a contrast. Working: influence: the high value placed on vegetarian food and the ban on killing animals; contrast: the joyful festivals and rituals of bhakti, set against the simplicity and life-denial of the heterodox sects. Answer: vegetarianism (influence); temple festivals (contrast).
The textbook's judgement: popular devotion plus royal patronage, not debate alone, led to the decline of Buddhism and Jainism in the Tamil country, and the encounter transformed Vedic Hinduism itself.
Key takeaways: bhakti tradition records conflicts in the Pallava and Pandya kingdoms, involving Appar, Mahendravarma I, Sambandar and Koon Pandyan; inscriptions show that violence occurred. Saiva Siddhanta texts argued against Jain and Buddhist philosophy. The book credits popular devotion and royal patronage for the decline of the heterodox faiths by the 11th century, while Jain communities survive in Tamil Nadu. Renunciation, vegetarianism and the stress on Tamil show the traditions' mutual influence. Ramanuja's Vishistadvaita qualified Sankara's Advaita and gave bhakti a philosophy.
Check your understanding
-
1. What was Appar's name when he was a Jain?
- Harisena
- Sivagnana Sithiyar
- Dharmasena
- Sekkizhar
Show answer
Answer: C. The book says Appar was called Dharmasena in his early life as a Jain and turned to Saivism under his sister's influence.
-
2. Parapakkam is:
- a section of some Saiva Siddhanta texts refuting Buddhist and Jain arguments
- a Jain monastery
- a Vaishnava festival
- a Pallava inscription
Show answer
Answer: A. Some Saiva Siddhanta texts, such as Sivagnana Sithiyar, have a section called parapakkam that refutes Buddhist and Jain theological arguments.
-
3. What does the textbook give as the main reason for the decline of Buddhism and Jainism in the Tamil country?
- foreign invasions from the north
- the popular nature of the bhakti movement and the royal patronage it received
- a ban by the Delhi Sultanate
- the arrival of European missionaries
Show answer
Answer: B. The book says that, despite sophisticated debate, it was the nature of the bhakti movement and its royal patronage that ultimately led to their downfall by the eleventh century.
-
4. Which of these does the book list as an idea adopted by Saivites and Vaishnavites from the heterodox religions?
- the use of northern Prakrits
- fatalism
- the rejection of all festivals
- renunciation
Show answer
Answer: D. The book says renunciation, central to Buddhism and Jainism, was adopted by Saivites and Vaishnavites. Bhakti stressed Tamil rather than Prakrit and taught that devotion could overcome fate.
-
5. Ramanuja's philosophy is known as:
- Advaita, absolute monism
- Vishistadvaita, qualified monism
- Dvaita, dualism
- Pushtimarga, the way of grace
Show answer
Answer: B. Ramanuja taught Vishistadvaita, which qualified Sankara's absolute monism. Dvaita is linked with Madhvacharya and Pushtimarga with Vallabhacharya.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.