Revision notes

Unit 13 Cultural Syncretism: Bhakti Movement in India: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What bhakti means and how the movement began in the Tamil country

Bhakti: loving, devotional surrender to a supreme god as the way to salvation (moksha).

The journey of the bhakti movement (as outlined in the textbook)

  1. Idea of bhakti-marga Found in texts such as the Bhagavad Gita.
  2. 7th–10th centuries: Tamil country Nayanmars and Azhwars make it a popular movement.
  3. 11th century: philosophy Ramanuja's Vishistadvaita gives it a system.
  4. From the 14th–15th centuries: all India Poet-saints of the north, such as Kabir, Nanak and Mirabai.
Main sources for the bhakti movement in the Tamil country
SourceWhat it contains
Thevaramhymns of three Nayanmars: Appar (Thirunavukkarasar), Sambandar (Thirugnanasambandar) and Sundarar; they make up seven of the twelve Saiva Thirumurais
Eighth Thirumuraithe hymns of Manickavasakar
Periyapuranam (Sekkizhar)the stories of the sixty-three Nayanmars
Nalayira Divya Prabandhamthe collected hymns of the Vaishnava Azhwars
Inscriptions and iconographydated records and images that add to the literary evidence

Key takeaways: the book presents Indian religion as a tradition shaped by interaction, from Harappan elements in Vedic religion to the challenge of Buddhism and Jainism. Bhakti means devotional surrender to a supreme god. It became a movement in the Tamil country between the 7th and 10th centuries through the Nayanmars and Azhwars, with royal support, among landholding groups, and in competition with Buddhism and Jainism for patronage. Its sources are the Thevaram and Thirumurai, the Periyapuranam, the Divya Prabandham, inscriptions and images.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Bhakti, Jainism and Buddhism in the south: conflict, influence and Ramanuja

Marks left by the encounter (as listed in the textbook)

  • Ideas taken in
    • renunciation, central to Buddhism and Jainism, adopted by Saivites and Vaishnavites
    • high value on vegetarian food and on not killing animals
  • Responses and contrasts
    • bhakti celebrated life with festivals and rituals, against heterodox simplicity and life-denial
    • Tamil given supremacy, while the heterodox faiths used northern Prakrits
    • devotion to Siva or Vishnu could overcome fate, unlike the fatalism the book attributes to them

Advaita and Vishistadvaita

  • Advaita (Adi Sankara)
    • absolute monism
    • the supreme and the souls are one
    • the book says it remained at the intellectual level
  • Vishistadvaita (Ramanuja)
    • qualified monism
    • souls real but dependent on god
    • gave bhakti a philosophical base

The textbook's judgement: popular devotion plus royal patronage, not debate alone, led to the decline of Buddhism and Jainism in the Tamil country, and the encounter transformed Vedic Hinduism itself.

Key takeaways: bhakti tradition records conflicts in the Pallava and Pandya kingdoms, involving Appar, Mahendravarma I, Sambandar and Koon Pandyan; inscriptions show that violence occurred. Saiva Siddhanta texts argued against Jain and Buddhist philosophy. The book credits popular devotion and royal patronage for the decline of the heterodox faiths by the 11th century, while Jain communities survive in Tamil Nadu. Renunciation, vegetarianism and the stress on Tamil show the traditions' mutual influence. Ramanuja's Vishistadvaita qualified Sankara's Advaita and gave bhakti a philosophy.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Bhakti in north India, the impact of Sufism and the salient features of the movement

Two trends of bhakti in the north

  • Monotheistic / syncretic trend
    • one God beyond all creeds
    • independent of both dominant religions
    • criticised caste, idol worship and ritual
    • Kabir, Ravidas, Guru Nanak
  • Vaishnava trend
    • devotion to Krishna or Rama
    • worked within Hinduism
    • ecstatic singing and personal love of god
    • Chaitanya, Mirabai, Sur Das

Sufi orders: Chishti, Suhrawardi, Qadiri, Naqshbandi. Sufism: God the beloved (Mashuq), the Sufi the lover (Ashiq).

Key takeaways: the textbook links the northern bhakti outburst of the 15th century to social divisions and to the challenge and influence of Islam. Two trends emerged: a monotheistic, syncretic one and a Vaishnava one. Sufism, the mystical side of Islam, organised in silsilahs, promoted love of God and Hindu–Muslim harmony. The salient features of bhakti include monotheism, devotion and self-surrender, the guru, universal brotherhood, rejection of caste and ritual, and the use of people's languages.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Kabir, Ravidas, Guru Nanak and Ramananda: the reformers

The Guru Granth Sahib: voices it brings together (as named in the textbook)

  • The Sikh Gurus
    • teachings of Guru Nanak (the Adi Granth)
    • teachings of the later Gurus
  • Bhakti poets
    • Ramananda
    • Namadeva
    • Kabir
    • Ravidas
  • Sufi saints
    • Sheikh Farid

Ramananda (first to preach in Hindi; disciples Kabir, Ravidas) → Kabir (weaver; against idolatry, caste and formalism) → Guru Nanak (one God, strict morality; Sikhism).

Key takeaways: Ramananda carried Ramanuja's school north, preached Rama bhakti and equality in Hindi, and had disciples including Kabir and Ravidas. Kabir, probably a weaver, rejected idolatry, caste and formalism in both religions and sought to unite Hindus and Muslims. Ravidas, probably from a tanner family, spoke against caste and gender divisions; his songs are in the Sikh scripture. Guru Nanak founded Sikhism, which grew under ten Gurus; after Guru Gobind Singh, the Granth Sahib became the Guru.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Chaitanya, Namadeva, Mirabai, Sur Das, Tukaram and the impact of bhakti

Kabir and Chaitanya, as compared in the textbook

  • Kabir
    • one God beyond all creeds
    • syncretic: drew Hindus and Muslims together
    • criticised idol worship and ritual
    • aimed to reform
  • Chaitanya
    • Krishna exalted above all deities
    • revivalist: return to Vishnu worship
    • group singing and ecstatic dancing
    • did not try to reform Hinduism
Five saints at a glance
SaintRegionDeity / focusLanguage or works
ChaitanyaBengal, OrissaKrishnagroup singing and dancing
NamadevaMaharashtra, PunjabVithala of Pandharpurabhangs in Marathi and Hindi
MirabaiRajasthanKrishnabhajans
Sur DasAgra, BrajKrishnaHindi: Sur Sagar, Sur Saravali, Sahitya Lahari
TukaramMaharashtraVithoba of Pandharpurabhangas in Marathi

What the bhakti movement changed

  • Religion
    • salvation open to all, not only the first three orders
    • philosophies from Dvaita to Advaita
  • Society
    • an inclusive path for women and the lower strata
    • challenge to caste in the reformers' teaching
  • Culture
    • devotional literature in regional languages
    • community singing, chanting of names, festivals and pilgrimages that survive today

Chaitanya: revivalist (Krishna above all deities). Kabir: syncretic (one God beyond creeds). Impact: salvation open to all, regional literatures, lasting forms of community worship.

Key takeaways: Chaitanya led a revivalist Krishna movement with ecstatic group singing in Bengal and Orissa. Namadeva and Tukaram sang abhangs to Vithoba of Pandharpur; Namadeva's verses entered the Guru Granth Sahib. Mirabai taught that God's grace is denied to no one, and Sur Das sang of Krishna in Sur Sagar. The movement opened salvation to all, gave women and the lower strata a path, enriched regional languages and left practices that continue today.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery