• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Great Rebellion of 1857 and the Queen's Proclamation

Explain how historians have interpreted 1857, its causes and the main centres of revolt, and the changes brought by the Queen's Proclamation of 1858.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Compare 'mutiny' and 'war of independence' views of 1857 as the book presents them.
  • Explain the political, economic, social, religious and military causes of the rebellion.
  • Trace the main centres and leaders of the revolt and the terms of the Queen's Proclamation of 1858.

The rising of 1857 shook British rule across north and central India and ended the East India Company's government. The book begins with the debate over what to call it.

Mutiny, rebellion or war of independence?

British imperialist historians called it a mutiny, a soldiers' outbreak. Indian historians asked two questions they say the imperial view cannot answer: why did people in some places rise before the sepoys there mutinied, and why did the British need to fine and hang civilians for complicity? The book cites Colonel Malleson's remark that a military mutiny soon became a national insurrection, the historian Keene's view that many grievances were set alight by the cartridge, and Edward John Thompson's description of it as largely a real war of independence. V. D. Savarkar's The War of Indian Independence (1909) compared it with the American War of Independence, and nationalist historians called it the First War of Indian Independence, though, as the book notes, the English-educated middle class took no part.

Causes

Causes of the 1857 rebellion (as grouped in the textbook)

  • Territorial aggrandisement
    • Annexation of Oudh and Jhansi
    • Treatment of Nana Sahib
    • Inam Commission (1852): rent-free estates confiscated
    • Oudh's talukdars, courtiers and craftsmen ruined
  • Land revenue
    • Revenue treated as rent, taken whether or not land was cultivated
    • Falling crop prices with no relief
  • Muslim aristocracy and intelligentsia
    • Loss of high posts
    • Persian removed from the courts; jobs by examination
  • Religious sentiment
    • Laws on sati, widow remarriage and infanticide seen as interference
    • Lex Loci Act (1850): converts keep inheritance
    • The 1856 enlistment act offended caste rules
  • Trigger
    • Rumour that cartridges for the Enfield rifle were greased with cow and pig fat

The book says Dalhousie annexed Oudh and Jhansi 'employing the Doctrine of Lapse'; strictly, Jhansi was taken under the doctrine while Oudh (1856) was annexed on the ground of misgovernment. Oudh mattered greatly because it was the nursery of the Bengal army: sepoys from its peasant families felt the talukdars' and peasants' grievances and complained of low pay and difficult leave.

Course of the revolt

The first outbreak came at Barrackpore, near Calcutta, where Mangal Pandey attacked his officers (the book says January 1857; the incident is generally dated 29 March 1857). At Meerut, of 90 sepoys ordered to take the cartridges only five obeyed; on 10 May 1857 three regiments rose, killed officers and freed prisoners, and the next day reached Delhi and proclaimed Bahadur Shah II emperor. By June the revolt had spread to Rohilkhand (Khan Bahadur Khan), Bundelkhand and the Doab.

Main centres of the rebellion
CentreLeader(s) of the risingBritish commander(s) named in the book
DelhiBahadur Shah II proclaimed emperorJohn Nicholson; Delhi retaken in September 1857 (the book says July)
KanpurNana Sahib; later Tantia TopiHavelock; Neill; Campbell
Lucknow (Awadh)Begum Hazrat Mahal, with talukdars and peasantsHenry Lawrence defended the Residency; city recaptured March 1858
Jhansi and GwaliorRani Lakshmi Bai; Tantia TopiHugh Rose
RohilkhandKhan Bahadur Khan-

At Kanpur, after British women and children were killed, Havelock defeated Nana Sahib, and Neill took terrible revenge. In Awadh, Begum Hazrat Mahal, wife of Wajid Ali Shah, declared her son Birjis Qadr ruler, and resistance lasted until Lucknow was taken in March 1858. Rani Lakshmi Bai of Jhansi seized Gwalior and died fighting Hugh Rose, who called her the bravest of the rebel leaders. Delhi fell; Bahadur Shah II, captured in September 1857, was exiled to Rangoon, where he died in 1862, ending the Mughal dynasty. Tantia Topi was captured and executed in April 1859. The book adds that the statue of Neill on Mount Road in Madras was removed to the Madras Museum by Rajaji's ministry of 1937-39.

The Queen's Proclamation (1858)

Lord Canning, last Governor-General and first Viceroy, read Queen Victoria's proclamation at a durbar in Allahabad on 1 November 1858.

  • India to be governed by and in the name of the British monarch through a Secretary of State, helped by a Council of India of 15 members; the Court of Directors and Board of Control abolished; the Company's army merged with the Crown's.
  • Treaties with Indian princes endorsed; their rights, dignity and honour respected; no further extension of British possessions.
  • The Doctrine of Lapse and annexation given up; a general amnesty except for those directly involved in killing British subjects.
  • From 1861 the legislative council was to include Indian nominees.
  • Education and public works (roads, railways, telegraph, irrigation) pushed ahead, partly because of their value for moving troops.

The book concludes that hopes of reviving the old order faded, traditional society began to change, and a Western-educated middle class with a stronger sense of nationalism emerged.

Worked example 1: testing the 'mutiny' label

Question: use the book's two questions to argue against calling 1857 only a mutiny. Working: (1) in some places civilians rose before the local sepoys did, which a purely military outbreak cannot explain; (2) the British fined and hanged civilians for complicity, so they themselves treated the people as participants. Answer: both facts show popular involvement beyond the army.

Worked example 2: a date check

Question: how long did Bahadur Shah II live after being captured, and how old was he at capture if he died in November 1862 aged 87? Working: September 1857 to November 1862 is about 5 years 2 months; 87 − 5 = about 82. Answer: he was about 82 when captured and lived about five more years in exile in Rangoon.

1857: Meerut 10 May; Delhi 11 May; Bahadur Shah II proclaimed emperor. Queen's Proclamation, Allahabad, 1 November 1858: rule by the Crown through a Secretary of State and a Council of 15; Doctrine of Lapse ended; amnesty.

Key takeaways: the book presents 1857 as more than a mutiny, citing popular participation. Annexations, revenue burdens, loss of Muslim elites' positions and fears for religion built up grievances that the greased cartridge ignited. The revolt centred on Delhi, Kanpur, Lucknow, Jhansi and Rohilkhand, and was crushed by 1858-59. The Queen's Proclamation ended Company rule, gave up annexation and promised to respect the princes.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the textbook, which question do Indian historians say the 'mutiny' view cannot answer?

    1. Why the British won
    2. Why people revolted in some places even before the local sepoys mutinied
    3. Why the cartridges were greased
    4. Why Delhi was chosen as the centre
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Indian historians asked how a purely military outbreak explains civilians rising before the sepoys at their stations, and why civilians were punished for complicity.

  2. 2. Why was Oudh important to the rebellion of 1857?

    1. It was the nursery of the Bengal army, and its sepoys shared peasants' grievances
    2. It was the Company's capital
    3. It had the largest European population
    4. It was ruled by the Marathas
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Most Bengal army sepoys came from Oudh's peasant families, so the grievances of talukdars and peasants after annexation affected them directly.

  3. 3. Who declared her son Birjis Qadr ruler of Oudh in 1857?

    1. Rani Lakshmi Bai
    2. Velu Nachiyar
    3. Begum Hazrat Mahal
    4. Queen Victoria
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Begum Hazrat Mahal, wife of Nawab Wajid Ali Shah, led the resistance in Lucknow and declared her son Birjis Qadr ruler.

  4. 4. The Queen's Proclamation was read by Canning at a durbar held at:

    1. Delhi
    2. Calcutta
    3. Madras
    4. Allahabad
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Royal Durbar was held at Allahabad on 1 November 1858, where Canning read Queen Victoria's proclamation.

  5. 5. Which change was made by the Queen's Proclamation of 1858?

    1. The Doctrine of Lapse was given up
    2. The Company's Court of Directors was given more power
    3. All princely states were annexed
    4. Bahadur Shah II was restored
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Proclamation gave up the Doctrine of Lapse and annexation, abolished the Court of Directors and Board of Control, and placed India under the Crown through a Secretary of State.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery