- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The Aryan question and Rig Vedic polity
Explain how the textbook treats the Aryan question and the migration debate, and describe Rig Vedic geography, the Dasas and Dasyus, clan conflicts such as the Battle of Ten Kings, kingship, assemblies and officials.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why the textbook says 'Aryan' is a language term, not a race, and summarise the evidence it gives in the migration debate.
- Describe Rig Vedic geography and the conflicts with the Dasas, Dasyus and among Aryan clans.
- Describe the rajan, the assemblies and the officials of the Rig Vedic polity.
Archaeology shows pots, metals and houses; the Vedas, the book notes, throw light on the ethnic and cultural identities of people. That is why the Aryan question is one of the important and debated issues of early Indian history. This lesson presents the debate as the Tamil Nadu textbook does and then looks at how Rig Vedic people were organised politically.
Who were the Aryans? The textbook's account
The book explains that the idea of 'Aryans' was developed by European scholars in the colonial period, when race was widely used to classify people; some views reflected colonial racist ideas, linking Aryans to a 'blue-eyed white race', and the Nazis later misused the concept, leading to the Holocaust. The book states that recent studies have established that 'Aryan' does not denote a race; it refers only to the original speakers of Indo-Aryan languages.
From the Vedas, Indo-Aryan speakers used domesticated horses and chariots with spoked wheels, bows and arrows; they farmed and herded, buried and cremated their dead, and had a cult of fire and the soma drink. The Rig Veda is in Sanskrit, yet about 300 words of Munda and Dravidian origin have been identified in it, suggesting a cultural mix with earlier inhabitants.
The original home of Indo-Europeans and Indo-Aryans is, in the book's words, still a matter of debate. Many scholars hold that the Aryans came as migrants from Central Asia, perhaps in several waves; one accepted area of origin is Eastern Europe-Central Asia, north of the Black Sea. The book lists the evidence used for this view, shown below. It also states, as the textbook's summary, that the Aryans migrated to India around 1500 BCE.
- Spread of culture: Aryan cultural traits are found across Eastern Europe and Central Asia, linked by land to India, West Asia and Europe; the Bactria-Margiana Archaeological Complex (1900-1500 BCE in the book) is closely related to Aryan culture.
- Inscriptions outside India: Anatolian, Kassite (Iraq), Mitanni (Syria) and Boghazkoi inscriptions of the second millennium BCE, the last naming gods similar to Vedic ones, show Indo-European features; the book notes that no such inscriptions are found in India.
- Words and animals: asva (horse) occurs 215 times in the Rig Veda and vrishabha (bull) 170 times; tropical animals such as the tiger and rhinoceros are not mentioned; there is no trace of urban life.
- Not Harappan: because Harappan sites show no evidence of the horse, the book says the identity of the Aryans is not correlated with the Harappan culture.
- Genetics: DNA studies are now used; a genetic marker called M17 is said to have been found among speakers of Indo-European languages.
Rig Vedic geography and peoples
The Early Vedic culture is placed between 1500 and 1000 BCE. The early Aryans lived in eastern Afghanistan, Pakistan, Punjab and the fringes of western Uttar Pradesh. Moving in, they came into conflict with people they called Dasas or Dasyus, whom the hymns describe as dark and as having different practices, and from whom the Aryans sought to keep themselves distinct. Other groups such as the Simyu and Kikata are grouped with the Dasyus. Sambara, son of Kulitara, is a chief with 90 forts or settlements; the Rig Veda mentions his defeat by Divodasa of the Bharata clan. Indra is called Purandara, destroyer of settlements, which were perhaps fenced or planned townships.
Clans, conflict and the Battle of Ten Kings
Units of habitation named in the Rig Veda include jana, vis, gana, grama and kula. Battles were fought mostly for cattle and material wealth, and booty was shared; Aryans fought non-Aryans and also each other, invoking the gods' support. The Bharatas and Tritsus were ruling clans, supported by the priest Vasishta; India came to be called Bharata Varsha after the Bharatas. Ten chiefs, five of them Aryan, opposed the Bharatas in the Battle of Ten Kings on the river Paurushni (Ravi). Sudas won, and the Bharatas became dominant. The defeated Purus later allied with the Bharatas to form the Kuru clan, and the Kurus with the Panchalas came to control the Upper Ganga valley.
From clan war to the Kuru-Panchala
- Battle of Ten Kings On the Paurushni (Ravi); Sudas of the Bharatas wins.
- Bharatas dominant India called Bharata Varsha after them.
- Bharatas + Purus Former enemies ally and form the Kuru clan.
- Kurus + Panchalas Control the Upper Ganga valley.
Kingship, assemblies and officials
The Rig Vedic polity was that of a tribal society. The chief, the rajan, was hereditary but perhaps elected by the assembly called the samiti. His main duty was to protect the tribe: he guarded wealth, fought wars and offered prayers. He was also called gopa or gopati, chief of cattle. Kings gave cattle, chariots, horse ornaments and gold to priests, and redistributed tributes and booty. The society was militaristic, with bows, daggers, axes and lances.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Sabha | Assembly of elders or elites (women attended) |
| Samiti | Assembly of the people; may have elected the king |
| Vidhata | Assembly of the tribe (women attended) |
| Purohita | Priest who advised and inspired the king |
| Senani | Chief of the army |
| Vrajapati | Officer who controlled the territory |
| Gramini | Head of the village and of a fighting unit |
| Bali | Contribution to the king: voluntary, though some scholars call it an imposed tax |
The book adds that there is no evidence of tax-collecting officers and no reference to the administration of justice, and that the exact nature of the assemblies is debated because our picture depends on interpreting Vedic terms whose original meaning can be hard to recover.
Rig Vedic polity: a tribal chief (rajan) protecting the tribe, perhaps elected by the samiti, advised by the purohita, with sabha, samiti and vidhata as assemblies and bali as contribution.
Worked example 1: presenting a debate fairly
Question: write two sentences on the Aryans' original home in the way the textbook does. Working: state the open question, then attribute the main view and its evidence. Answer: 'The textbook says the original home of the Indo-Aryans is still debated. Many scholars, it reports, think they migrated from Central Asia in several waves, pointing to inscriptions in West Asia, the frequent mention of the horse in the Rig Veda and its absence at Harappan sites.' Notice the words 'the textbook says' and 'many scholars think' - a debated point is reported, not asserted.
Worked example 2: matching officials
Question: which pair is wrong - senani: army chief; gramini: village head; bali: voluntary contribution; purohita: governor? Working: check each against the table. Senani, gramini and bali match. The purohita was the priest who advised the king, not a governor. Answer: purohita - governor is the incorrect pair.
Key takeaways: the book says 'Aryan' means Indo-Aryan speakers, not a race, and that their home is debated, with many scholars favouring migration from Central Asia. Rig Vedic people lived in the north-west, fought the Dasas and Dasyus and each other; Sudas won the Battle of Ten Kings on the Ravi. The rajan protected a tribe, aided by assemblies (sabha, samiti, vidhata) and officials such as the purohita, senani and gramini.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the textbook, what does the word 'Aryan' refer to?
- A race with particular physical features
- The original speakers of Indo-Aryan languages
- The rulers of the Harappan cities
- A religious order of priests
Show answer
Answer: B. The book says recent studies have established that 'Aryan' does not denote race but only refers to the original speakers of Indo-Aryan languages; the racial idea came from colonial thinking.
-
2. The Battle of Ten Kings was fought on the banks of the Paurushni, which is identified with the:
- Ravi
- Yamuna
- Ganga
- Saraswati
Show answer
Answer: A. The book identifies the Paurushni with the Ravi; there Sudas of the Bharata clan defeated a confederacy of ten chiefs.
-
3. Which of these is presented in the textbook as evidence used by scholars who hold that the Aryans migrated into India?
- The Rig Veda describes tigers and rhinoceroses often
- Harappan seals show horse-drawn chariots
- Inscriptions with Indo-European features are found in West Asia but not in India
- The Rig Veda describes large brick cities
Show answer
Answer: C. The book lists Anatolian, Kassite, Mitanni and Boghazkoi inscriptions with Indo-European features and notes none are found in India. It also says tigers and rhinos are not mentioned, the horse is absent at Harappan sites and there is no urban life in the Rig Veda.
-
4. In the Rig Vedic polity, the samiti was:
- the chief of the army
- a contribution paid to the king
- the head of the village
- an assembly of the people that perhaps elected the king
Show answer
Answer: D. The samiti was an assembly of people; the book says the hereditary rajan was perhaps elected by it. The senani led the army, bali was the contribution and the gramini headed the village.
-
5. Why was the god Indra called Purandara?
- Because he was the destroyer of settlements, perhaps fenced or planned townships
- Because he was the god of water
- Because he was the god of plants
- Because he removed darkness
Show answer
Answer: A. Purandara means destroyer of settlements; the book suggests these were perhaps fenced or planned townships. Varuna was the water god, Soma the plant god and Surya removed darkness.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.