- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Thinai, polity, society and economy in the Sangam Age
Describe the five thinai eco-zones, the three levels of rulers, the debate on whether Sangam polities were states or chiefdoms, how the Vendar rose, and Sangam society, crafts and trade.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the five thinai and their ways of life.
- Explain the Kizhar-Velir-Vendar hierarchy and set out both sides of the state-or-chiefdom debate.
- Describe Sangam society, crafts, merchants and trade, including Roman contacts.
Sangam poems are love and war poetry, but they also describe landscapes and the people who lived in them. The Tamil Nadu textbook uses them, with archaeology, to show how society and political power were organised, and presents a scholarly debate on whether the three kingdoms were full states.
The five thinai (Ainthinai)
According to the thinai concept, Tamilagam was divided into five landscapes or eco-regions, each with its own presiding deity, people and cultural life suited to its environment.
| Thinai | Landscape | Way of life |
|---|---|---|
| Kurinji | Hilly region | Hunting and gathering |
| Mullai | Forested region | Pastoralism with shifting cultivation |
| Marutham | Riverine tract | Plough agriculture with irrigation |
| Neythal | Coastal land | Fishing and salt making |
| Palai | Parched land | Unfit for cultivation; cattle lifting and robbery |
Three levels of rulers
The book says the thinai pattern reflects uneven development across regions, and this shows in politics too. Kizhar were heads of villages or small territories (later called nadu), chiefs of tribal communities. Velir, many in number, held hilly and forested lands between the fertile kingdoms; chiefs such as Athiyaman, Pari, Ay, Evvi and Irungo commanded large areas rich in resources, were generous patrons of poets, fought one another over cattle and sometimes united against one of the three kings. Vendar were kings controlling large fertile territories.
Levels of rulers in the Sangam Age
- Vendar Crowned kings of large fertile territories: Cheras, Cholas, Pandyas.
- Velir Chiefs of hill and forest regions between the kingdoms; patrons of poets.
- Kizhar Heads of villages or small territories (nadu); tribal chiefs.
State or chiefdom? A debate
The book reports two views. The earlier and dominant view holds that Sangam society was a well-organised state society. A view put forward in recent decades holds that the Chera, Chola and Pandya polities were pre-state chiefdoms. The book also gives the counter-arguments, so the debate is set out below in both directions.
Arguments in the debate, as summarised in the textbook
-
Pre-state chiefdom view
- No social stratification is noticed
- Proper territorial association is absent
- Destructive warfare prevented agricultural surplus
- No evidence of taxation as in north India
-
Counter-arguments
- Social differentiation is evident in Marutham
- Muvendar territories are clear and confirmed by Greco-Roman texts
- Warfare for territory is a major theme of Puratthinai
- Taxes on highways and at Kaviripattinam; Chera king receives resources of hills and Musiri
- Trade was important from the late 1st century BCE to the 3rd century CE
Rise of the Vendar
From the chiefs of the Iron Age (c. 1100-300 BCE) emerged the Vendar of the early historic period. Chiefs who controlled larger pastoral and farming regions became vendar; those in marginal regions stayed velir. The Athiyamans (Ashoka's Satiyaputra) became weak and never reached royal status. Vendar subdued chiefs and fought each other with their own warriors and Velir allies. They displayed power through titles such as Kadungo, Imayavaramban, Vanavaramban and Peruvazhuthi, and by patronising bards in their courts (avaiyam) to spread their fame - Karikalan, for example, is said to have given a huge amount of gold to the poet of Pattinappalai.
Society and economy
Wars of territorial expansion probably created social disparities; war captives serving at cult centres and slaves are mentioned. Women took an active part in economic production, and many were poets. Crafts included bronze vessels, beads, gold work, textiles, shell bangles, glass, iron smithy and pottery, in centres such as Arikamedu, Uraiyur, Kanchipuram, Kaviripattinam, Madurai, Korkai and Pattanam in Kerala. Maduraikanchi describes day and night markets. Raw materials such as precious stones were collected and exchanged, worked in craft centres, then exchanged again.
- Merchants: names on pottery show non-Tamil traders in some towns; Manimekalai speaks of Magadha artisans, Maratha mechanics, Malva smiths and Yavana carpenters working with Tamil craftsmen; Tamil-Brahmi inscriptions use the terms vanikan, chattan and nigama; umanar were salt merchants who travelled in bullock carts with their families; chattu were itinerant merchants.
- Exchange: barter was common, though coins were used; Roman coins circulated as bullion.
- Overseas trade: ports have Roman amphorae and glassware; Roman gold and silver coin hoards are found in the Coimbatore region and elsewhere; contacts reached Rome and South-east Asia.
Five thinai: Kurinji (hills), Mullai (forest), Marutham (river plain), Neythal (coast), Palai (parched land). Three rulers: Kizhar, Velir, Vendar.
Worked example 1: linking landscape and living
Question: in which thinai would you expect (a) salt pans, (b) irrigated paddy fields, (c) herds and shifting plots? Working: salt comes from seawater, so the coast - Neythal; irrigated plough farming belongs to the river plain - Marutham; pastoralism with shifting cultivation is the forest zone - Mullai. Answer: (a) Neythal, (b) Marutham, (c) Mullai.
Worked example 2: answering both sides
Question: one scholar says, 'There was no taxation, so there was no state.' How would the other side reply, using the textbook? Working: find the matching counter-argument. The book cites taxes collected on highways and at the port of Kaviripattinam, and the Chera king receiving resources from the hills and from Musiri. Answer: there is evidence of taxation, so this argument for a pre-state chiefdom is weakened. A balanced answer states the claim, the reply and the fact that the debate continues.
Key takeaways: the five thinai tie landscape to livelihood. Rulers ranged from Kizhar to Velir to Vendar; the textbook presents both the dominant state view and the recent chiefdom view with counter-arguments. Vendar rose from Iron Age chiefs by controlling fertile land, winning wars, taking titles and patronising poets. Crafts, markets, many kinds of merchants and Roman trade marked the economy.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which thinai was associated with fishing and salt making?
- Kurinji
- Marutham
- Palai
- Neythal
Show answer
Answer: D. Neythal was the coastal land of fishing and salt making. Kurinji was hilly (hunting), Marutham riverine (plough farming) and Palai parched land.
-
2. The Velir were:
- chiefs of hill and forest regions between the fertile kingdoms
- Roman merchants
- heads of single villages only
- the three crowned kings
Show answer
Answer: A. The Velir controlled varied, mainly hilly and forest territories between the muvendar's lands; chiefs such as Athiyaman, Pari and Ay were patrons of poets.
-
3. Which is an argument the textbook lists for the view that Sangam polities were pre-state chiefdoms?
- Taxes were collected at Kaviripattinam
- No evidence of taxation as in the governments of north India
- Greco-Roman texts confirm the muvendar's territories
- Warfare for territory is a theme of Puratthinai
Show answer
Answer: B. The chiefdom view cites no stratification, no proper territorial association, destructive warfare and no taxation like north India. The other options are counter-arguments.
-
4. Umanar in the Sangam Age were:
- temple priests
- court poets
- salt merchants who travelled in bullock carts with their families
- village headmen
Show answer
Answer: C. The book says salt merchants called umanar travelled in bullock carts with their families for trade.
-
5. How did Roman coins circulate in the Sangam economy, according to the textbook?
- As bullion
- As the only legal currency
- As temple offerings only
- They were never found in south India
Show answer
Answer: A. The book says barter was common, coins were also used, and Roman coins circulated as bullion; hoards are found in the Coimbatore region and elsewhere.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.