Two views on the village panchayat, as the textbook presents them
-
Gandhi
- Gram Swaraj: each village a self-reliant republic for its vital needs
- Minimal power at the centre; villages govern themselves
- More power to the people is better for the people
-
Ambedkar
- Saw the village of his time as marked by localism, caste and communal division
- Feared dominant communities would control villages and silence others
- So the draft Constitution did not at first mention Panchayati Raj
Article 40 (Directive Principles): the State shall organise village panchayats and endow them with powers to function as units of self-government.
| Rural local bodies | Urban local bodies |
|---|---|
| Village Panchayat (with the Gram Sabha of all voters) | Municipal Corporation (large metropolitan cities) |
| Panchayat Union (intermediate or block level) | Municipality (smaller cities and towns) |
| District Panchayat | Town Panchayat (areas changing from rural to urban) |
| Wards as constituencies | Townships and notified areas (new industrial towns); Cantonment Boards (military areas) |
Key takeaways: local government is the elected, lowest tier that handles local needs and links people to the state. Gandhi wanted self-governing village republics; Ambedkar feared village domination by powerful groups; the compromise was Article 40 in the Directive Principles. Local bodies are rural (Panchayati Raj) or urban (corporations, municipalities, town panchayats, cantonment boards), divided by the nature of occupations.