• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

The 74th Amendment: urban local bodies, their working and challenges

Describe town panchayats, municipalities and municipal corporations under the 74th Amendment, the roles of the mayor and commissioner, the Twelfth Schedule, planning committees and the issues local bodies face.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the three kinds of urban local body under the 74th Amendment and how each is composed.
  • Explain the roles of the Mayor, Municipal Commissioner, standing and ward committees, and the Twelfth Schedule.
  • Explain the State Finance Commission, the District and Metropolitan Planning Committees, and the contemporary issues the textbook identifies.

India's towns and cities face pressures villages do not: crowding, migration, traffic, waste and slums. The 74th Amendment (Nagarpalika Act), 1992, notified in June 1993, gave urban local bodies a constitutional base and required states to bring their laws into line within one year.

Kinds of urban body before and after

Earlier, urban areas had municipal corporations, municipal committees, notified area committees, town area committees (created by state laws) and Cantonment Boards (under the central Cantonments Act, 1924). The 74th Amendment provides three kinds: the Nagar Panchayat (Town Panchayat), the Municipality (Municipal Council) and the Municipal Corporation.

Urban local bodies under the 74th Amendment
BodyWhere (as described in the textbook)Key features
Town PanchayatAn area in transition from rural to urbanA body corporate; a fixed range of elected ward members plus local MLAs and non-voting nominated experts; SC/ST and one-third women's reservation; an executive officer appointed by the state; obligatory duties such as water supply, drainage and street cleaning; five-year term
MunicipalityA smaller urban area, graded into classes by populationElected councillors by secret ballot, local MLAs as ex officio members, a few nominated members who cannot vote for the chairperson; a President and Vice-President; an Executive Officer appointed by the state; five-year term
Municipal CorporationA large cityCreated by state law (by Parliament for a Union Territory); council of elected and a few nominated members; Mayor and Deputy Mayor; Municipal Commissioner as chief executive; standing, subject and ward committees; five-year term

The exact population limits and numbers of members are set by each state's law; the textbook gives one set of figures as an illustration (for example, a town panchayat for an area of 5,000 to under 15,000 people).

Inside a municipal corporation

A corporation separates its deliberative wing (the council and its committees, which make decisions) from its executive wing (the Municipal Commissioner, who carries them out). The textbook adds that most corporations follow the pattern of the Bombay Municipal Corporation, and that the first corporations were in the presidency towns of Madras, Bombay and Calcutta.

Mayor and Municipal Commissioner

  • Mayor
    • Elected directly by voters in some states, by councillors in others
    • Presides over council meetings and keeps order
    • May expel or suspend members for gross misconduct
    • Has a casting vote in a tie; chairs the standing committee
  • Municipal Commissioner
    • Chief executive officer of the corporation
    • Usually an IAS officer appointed by the state government
    • Term of three years, extendable by the state
    • Carries out the council's decisions

Ward committees are formed in cities of 3 lakh or more; they look after water supply, drainage, removal of rain water and solid waste, immunisation, slum services, street lighting, roads and parks. Subject committees deal with matters such as water supply and sewage.

Twelfth Schedule, finance and planning

  • Twelfth Schedule (18 subjects): urban and town planning, regulation of land use and buildings, economic and social planning, roads and bridges, domestic water supply, public health and solid waste management, fire services, urban forestry and environment, weaker sections, slum improvement, urban poverty alleviation, parks and playgrounds, cultural and educational promotion, burial and cremation grounds, cattle pounds and prevention of cruelty to animals, registration of births and deaths, street lighting, parking and bus stops, regulation of slaughterhouses and tanneries.
  • State Finance Commission: recommends the sharing of taxes, duties, tolls and fees between the state and local bodies, their allocation among local bodies, the taxes that local bodies may levy, grants-in-aid, and measures to improve local finances.
  • District Planning Committee: consolidates panchayat and municipal plans into a draft district plan; at least four-fifths of its members are elected from among elected local members in proportion to rural and urban population.
  • Metropolitan Planning Committee: prepares a plan for a metropolitan area; at least two-thirds of its members come from elected municipal members and panchayat chairpersons.

Contemporary issues

The textbook lists problems that experts raise: local bodies have taken on many former state responsibilities, so the list of functions needs to be reclassified; village courts and policing cannot practically be handed to local bodies; many urban functions overlap with state departments; and many states have not fully put the amendments into operation. It also reproduces five systemic challenges for cities from a 2018 survey: outdated spatial planning, weak finances, poor management of staff, powerless mayors with governance fragmented among agencies, and no platforms for citizen participation or transparency.

Worked example 1: who is responsible?

(a) A councillor disrupts a corporation meeting repeatedly: the Mayor may suspend the member. (b) The council has decided to build a new drain; someone must issue the work order and supervise staff: the Municipal Commissioner. (c) Uncleared garbage in one ward of a city of 10 lakh: the ward committee.

Worked example 2: a District Planning Committee's elected share

A made-up District Planning Committee has 25 members. At least four-fifths must be elected from local bodies: 25 × 4 ÷ 5 = 20 members. If the district's population is 60% rural and 40% urban, those 20 are divided in that ratio: 20 × 0.6 = 12 from panchayats and 20 × 0.4 = 8 from municipalities. Check: 12 + 8 = 20.

74th Amendment: town panchayat, municipality, corporation; Twelfth Schedule (18 subjects); ward committees in cities of 3 lakh or more; District and Metropolitan Planning Committees; State Finance Commission.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: the 74th Amendment created three types of urban body, each with elected members, reservation and a five-year term. Corporations separate the deliberative council led by the Mayor from the executive Commissioner. The Twelfth Schedule lists functions, the State Finance Commission shares revenue, and planning committees join local plans. The textbook stresses unfinished devolution and weak city finances as the key challenges.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who is the chief executive of a Municipal Corporation?

    1. The Mayor
    2. The Deputy Mayor
    3. The Municipal Commissioner
    4. The District Collector
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Municipal Commissioner, usually an IAS officer appointed by the state, is the chief executive; the Mayor presides over the deliberative council.

  2. 2. How many subjects are listed in the Twelfth Schedule for municipalities?

    1. 18
    2. 29
    3. 12
    4. 22
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Twelfth Schedule lists 18 functions; the Eleventh Schedule lists 29 for panchayats.

  3. 3. Ward committees under the 74th Amendment are to be formed in municipal areas with a population of:

    1. 5,000 or more
    2. 50,000 or more
    3. 1 lakh or more
    4. 3 lakh or more
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Ward committees are constituted in municipalities with a population of 3 lakh or more.

  4. 4. Which body recommends how taxes and grants are shared between the state and its local bodies?

    1. State Election Commission
    2. State Finance Commission
    3. District Planning Committee
    4. Metropolitan Planning Committee
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The State Finance Commission makes recommendations on the sharing of taxes, duties, tolls and fees and on grants-in-aid.

  5. 5. In a made-up District Planning Committee of 30 members, at least how many must be elected from among elected members of local bodies?

    1. 20
    2. 24
    3. 15
    4. 25
    Show answer

    Answer: B. At least four-fifths: 30 × 4 ÷ 5 = 24 members.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery