- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The Madras Presidency and the roots of the non-Brahmin movement
Describe the Madras Presidency, how the scholarship of Ellis and Caldwell shaped a Dravidian identity, and the early grievances that the textbook says turned it into a non-Brahmin movement.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the extent of the Madras Presidency and the textbook's view of its politics in the early 20th century.
- Explain the contributions of F.W. Ellis and Robert Caldwell to the idea of a Dravidian family of languages.
- Outline the early steps of non-Brahmin protest, from the Madras Native Association (1852) to the Cardew statistics (1913).
Unit 14 of the Tamil Nadu textbook traces how modern Tamil Nadu's politics took shape. It begins in the Madras Presidency, where debates about language, identity and fair representation in education and jobs set the stage for the Justice Party, the Self-Respect Movement and the Dravidian parties. In this lesson we follow the textbook's account of those beginnings.
The Madras Presidency
According to the textbook, the Madras Presidency was formed by the British in 1801 for administrative and political needs. It was a multilingual province: besides present-day Tamil Nadu it included what are now parts of Andhra Pradesh, the Malabar region of Kerala, southern Karnataka, the southern tip of Odisha and Lakshadweep, with Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Kannada and Tulu speakers. The textbook states that scholars regard the conflict between Brahmins and non-Brahmins in the early 20th century as essential for understanding South Indian politics and society of that period, as many non-Brahmin groups who moved to towns sought to assert a Dravidian and Tamil identity and to challenge what they saw as a monopoly of power and privilege.
Scholarship and the Dravidian idea
The textbook explains that in Bengal and North India a Sanskrit- and Vedic-centred picture of Indian culture was then dominant. Research in the 19th century showed Indian culture was not uniform:
| Scholar | Contribution (as described in the textbook) |
|---|---|
| James Prinsep | Deciphered the Brahmi script in 1837 |
| Francis Whyte Ellis (1777-1819) | Collector of Madras; founded the College of Fort St. George (1812) to teach South Indian languages; translated part of the Thirukkural; in 1816, in a foreword to A.D. Campbell's Telugu grammar, set out the 'Dravidian proof' that South Indian languages led by Tamil form a family distinct from Sanskrit. Iyothee Thass called him a forerunner of the Tamil renaissance. |
| Robert Caldwell (1814-1891) | Missionary at Idaiyankudi in Tirunelveli; his *Comparative Grammar of the Dravidian or South Indian Family of Languages* (1856) established Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam and Tulu as a Dravidian family and stressed the antiquity of Tamil; also wrote a history of Tirunelveli |
The term 'Dravidian', the textbook says, came to describe non-Aryan, Tamil-speaking people and their language and culture. It then argues that two factors turned this Dravidian identity into a non-Brahmin identity: claims of social superiority, and the concentration of educational and job opportunities in a small section of society. It notes that Mahatma Jyotirao Phule led a non-Brahmin movement on similar lines in Maharashtra.
From language research to a political movement (textbook account)
- Language research Ellis (1816) and Caldwell (1856)
- Dravidian identity Pride in Tamil language and culture
- Grievances Unequal access to education and jobs
- Non-Brahmin identity Demand for fair representation
- Political organisation South Indian Liberal Federation, 1916
Early protests
- 1852: Gajulu Lakshminarasu Chetty, feeling that emerging nationalist leaders ignored non-Brahmin issues, left the British Indian Association and founded the Madras Native Association.
- After 1857, the textbook says, non-Brahmin leaders focused on social rather than political reform.
- After the Minto-Morley Reforms of 1909, they protested against inadequate representation in education and employment.
- 1913: Sir Alexander Cardew, a member of the Governor's Executive Council, presented statistics which, according to the textbook, showed that a community forming about three per cent of the population held most of the opportunities in public services.
Worked example 1: matching scholar and work
Which scholar's 1856 book gave the name 'Dravidian family of languages'? Reasoning: Ellis first stated the idea in 1816 in a foreword; the full comparative grammar of 1856 is Caldwell's. So: idea first, Ellis (1816); consolidated, Caldwell (1856).
Worked example 2: building a timeline
Order: Cardew's statistics; Madras Native Association; Prinsep's decipherment; Minto-Morley Reforms. Dates: 1837, 1852, 1909, 1913. Order: Prinsep, Madras Native Association, Minto-Morley Reforms, Cardew.
Ellis 1816 (Dravidian proof), Caldwell 1856 (Comparative Grammar), Madras Native Association 1852, Cardew statistics 1913.
Key takeaways: the multilingual Madras Presidency was the setting for the non-Brahmin movement. Research by Ellis and Caldwell established the Dravidian family of languages, which the textbook says fostered a Dravidian identity that grievances over education and jobs turned into a political non-Brahmin identity. Early landmarks were the Madras Native Association (1852) and Cardew's statistics (1913).
Check your understanding
-
1. Who wrote A Comparative Grammar of the Dravidian or South Indian Family of Languages (1856)?
- F.W. Ellis
- Robert Caldwell
- James Prinsep
- A.D. Campbell
Show answer
Answer: B. Robert Caldwell's 1856 work consolidated the idea of a Dravidian family of languages; Ellis had first proposed it in 1816.
-
2. According to the textbook, the Madras Native Association was founded in 1852 by:
- Gajulu Lakshminarasu Chetty
- Pitti Theagarayar
- T.M. Nair
- Dr C. Natesan
Show answer
Answer: A. Gajulu Lakshminarasu Chetty left the British Indian Association and founded the Madras Native Association in 1852.
-
3. The textbook says the Brahmi script was deciphered in 1837 by:
- Robert Caldwell
- Alexander Cardew
- F.W. Ellis
- James Prinsep
Show answer
Answer: D. James Prinsep deciphered the Brahmi script in 1837.
-
4. Which was NOT part of the Madras Presidency as the textbook describes it?
- Malabar region of Kerala
- Parts of present Andhra Pradesh
- Bengal
- Lakshadweep
Show answer
Answer: C. Bengal was a separate presidency. Malabar, parts of Andhra Pradesh and Lakshadweep were in the Madras Presidency.
-
5. The textbook says the Dravidian identity became a non-Brahmin identity mainly because of:
- the British army's recruitment rules
- the discovery of the Brahmi script
- trade with Europe
- claims of social superiority and unequal access to education and jobs
Show answer
Answer: D. It names two factors: claims of superiority and the concentration of educational and employment opportunities.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.