- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Incomplete records: meaning, features and limitations
Explain what incomplete records are, why some transactions are recorded fully, partly or not at all, list their features and limitations, and compare them with the double entry system on eight bases.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Say when accounting records are called incomplete records and who may keep them.
- Sort transactions into fully recorded, partly recorded and not recorded under incomplete records.
- State the six features and six limitations given in the Tamil Nadu textbook.
- Distinguish the double entry system from incomplete records.
Watch a small provision shop or a roadside tea stall for an hour. The owner collects cash, notes a few credit customers in a notebook and pays suppliers, but rarely keeps a journal, ledger and trial balance. At the end of the year the owner still wants to know two things: how much profit was made and what the business is worth. This unit shows how an accountant answers both questions from records that are not complete.
Meaning of incomplete records
Some organisations must keep their accounts under the double entry system. The Tamil Nadu textbook gives the example of companies in India, which must maintain accounting records on the double entry system under Section 128(1) of the Companies Act, 2013. Other organisations may or may not follow double entry strictly; they keep records as the owner and the accountant find convenient. When accounting records are not strictly maintained according to the double entry system, they are called incomplete records. The older name for this practice is the single entry system of book-keeping, and the book describes it as an incomplete and unscientific way of keeping books.
Usually the cash account and the personal accounts of customers (debtors) and suppliers (creditors) are kept fully. Other accounts are kept only when needed. So the transactions fall into three groups.
| How the transaction is treated | What it means | Example (made up) |
|---|---|---|
| Recorded fully | Both the debit and the credit aspects are entered | ₹8,000 received from a debtor: entered in the cash book and in the debtor's account |
| Recorded partly | Only one aspect is entered | Rent of ₹5,000 paid: entered only in the cash book; there is no rent account |
| Not recorded at all | Neither aspect is entered | Depreciation on the shop's furniture is never written in the books |
Incomplete records at a glance
-
Kept fully
Both aspects entered
- Cash account
- Debtors' personal accounts
- Creditors' personal accounts
-
Kept partly
One aspect only
- Expenses entered only in the cash book
- Purchases noted without a purchases account
-
Not kept
Left out
- Depreciation
- Real and nominal accounts in general
Features of incomplete records
- Nature: an unscientific and unsystematic way of recording; accounting principles and standards are not followed properly.
- Type of accounts kept: in general only cash and personal accounts are kept fully; real and nominal accounts are not kept properly, and some transactions are omitted.
- Lack of uniformity: each organisation records in its own way, to suit its needs.
- May not show a true and fair view: the profit or loss worked out cannot be relied upon, and the assets and liabilities may not show the true financial position.
- Suitability: only concerns with no legal duty to keep double entry books may use it, so it suits small sole traders and partnership firms.
- Mixing of personal and business transactions: for example, goods bought for the owner's home may be mixed with business purchases.
Limitations of incomplete records
- Records are not kept properly, because real and nominal accounts are missing.
- A trial balance is difficult to prepare, so arithmetical accuracy cannot be checked.
- True profit is hard to find, because profit rests on available information and estimates.
- The true financial position is hard to find, since asset and liability values are often estimates.
- Errors and frauds are not easily detected, as there is no internal check.
- Not accepted by government, tax and other authorities, because the accounts may not meet legal requirements.
Double entry system versus incomplete records
| Basis | Double entry system | Incomplete records |
|---|---|---|
| Recording of transactions | Both aspects of every transaction recorded | Some recorded fully, some partly, some left out |
| Accounts kept | Personal, real and nominal accounts kept fully | Mainly personal and cash accounts |
| Trial balance | Can be prepared to check accuracy | Difficult to prepare |
| Profit or loss | Trading and profit and loss account gives true profit or loss | Cannot be found accurately |
| Financial position | Balance sheet shows the true position | Only an estimate |
| Suitability | All types of organisations | Small sole traders and partnership firms |
| Reliability | Reliable: scientific and based on principles | Not reliable: unscientific |
| Acceptability | Accepted by all users, including tax authorities and financial institutions | May not be accepted by all users |
Worked example 1: how is each item treated?
Murugan (a made-up trader) keeps a cash book and a notebook of customers and suppliers. During a week: (a) he sells goods on credit to Ravi for ₹6,000; (b) he pays ₹1,200 for electricity; (c) his shop van loses value through use; (d) he pays ₹10,000 to a supplier. Working: ask which accounts he keeps. (a) Ravi's personal account is debited, and because he keeps no sales account the credit side is missing, so it is partly recorded. (b) It goes only into the cash book; there is no electricity account, so partly recorded. (c) No account records depreciation: not recorded. (d) The cash book is credited and the supplier's personal account is debited: fully recorded.
Worked example 2: who may keep incomplete records?
Which of these may keep incomplete records: (i) a private limited company, (ii) a small vegetable wholesaler run by one person, (iii) a two-partner tailoring firm? Working: a company is bound by law to keep double entry books, so (i) cannot. Concerns with no such legal duty may keep incomplete records, which is why the textbook says they suit small sole traders and partnership firms. Answer: (ii) and (iii).
Incomplete records = accounts not kept strictly on double entry. Usually only cash and personal accounts are complete.
Key takeaways: incomplete records (the single entry system) keep cash and personal accounts fully, other accounts partly or not at all. They are unscientific, lack uniformity, mix personal and business items and do not give a true and fair view. A trial balance is hard to prepare, errors are hard to detect, and authorities do not accept such accounts. The next lessons show how profit and the final accounts can still be worked out.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under incomplete records, which accounts are generally maintained fully?
- Real and nominal accounts
- Cash and personal accounts
- Nominal accounts only
- All accounts except cash
Show answer
Answer: B. Small traders usually keep the cash book and the accounts of debtors and creditors in full. Real and nominal accounts are not kept properly.
-
2. Depreciation on furniture under incomplete records is usually an example of a transaction that is:
- recorded fully
- recorded partly
- not recorded at all
- recorded twice
Show answer
Answer: C. Neither the depreciation account nor the furniture account is normally kept, so neither aspect is entered: it is not recorded at all.
-
3. Which organisation must maintain its accounting records on the double entry system, according to the textbook's example?
- A small sole trader
- A partnership firm with two partners
- A company in India
- A roadside fruit seller
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook cites Section 128(1) of the Companies Act, 2013, under which companies must keep double entry records. Sole traders and small firms have no such duty.
-
4. Why is it difficult to detect errors and frauds under incomplete records?
- Because a trial balance is always prepared
- Because only partial records exist and there is no internal check
- Because tax authorities check every entry
- Because all accounts are kept in duplicate
Show answer
Answer: B. With only partial records it is not possible to build internal checks, so errors and frauds can go unnoticed.
-
5. Case: Revathi's records show cash paid for wages only in her cash book; there is no wages account. This transaction is:
- fully recorded, because cash is involved
- not recorded, because there is no wages account
- partly recorded, because only one aspect is entered
- recorded in the trial balance
Show answer
Answer: C. Only the credit aspect (cash) is written; the debit aspect (wages) has no account. One aspect entered means it is partly recorded.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.