- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Why goodwill is valued, its classes and the methods at a glance
State when a partnership firm needs to value goodwill, distinguish acquired from self-generated goodwill and explain which may be recorded, calculate acquired goodwill, and outline the valuation methods.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the four occasions on which a firm values its goodwill.
- Distinguish acquired (purchased) goodwill from self-generated goodwill.
- Calculate acquired goodwill as purchase consideration minus net assets.
- Name the valuation methods that the next lessons use.
A firm's goodwill belongs to the partners who built it, in their profit sharing ratio. Whenever the mutual rights of partners change, someone gains or loses a share of that goodwill, so it must be valued to protect each partner's rights.
When is goodwill valued?
- When there is a change in the profit sharing ratio.
- When a new partner is admitted.
- When an existing partner retires, or a partner dies.
- When the firm is dissolved.
Classification of goodwill
Two kinds of goodwill
-
Acquired (purchased) goodwill
- Paid for in cash or kind
- Excess of purchase consideration over net assets taken over
- Recorded in the books
- Shown under fixed assets
-
Self-generated goodwill
- Built up by the firm itself
- Comes from location, loyal customers and similar features
- Nothing has been paid for it
- Not recorded in the books
When a firm buys an existing business, the price paid (the purchase consideration) may be more than the net assets (assets − liabilities) taken over. The excess is acquired goodwill. The Tamil Nadu textbook cites the accounting standard on fixed assets (AS 10) for the rule that goodwill is recorded only when some consideration in money or money's worth has been paid for it. The current standard on intangible assets, AS 26, likewise does not allow internally generated goodwill to be recognised.
Acquired goodwill = Purchase consideration − Net assets acquired (Assets − Liabilities)
Worked example 1: acquired goodwill
A made-up firm, Sakthi Traders, buys a business whose assets are valued at ₹6,40,000 and whose liabilities are ₹1,90,000, paying ₹5,20,000. Working: net assets = 6,40,000 − 1,90,000 = 4,50,000. Goodwill = 5,20,000 − 4,50,000 = ₹70,000, recorded as a fixed asset in Sakthi Traders' books.
Worked example 2: record it or not?
(a) Partners of a made-up firm feel that their popular shop is now worth ₹2,00,000 more than its net assets and wish to show goodwill of ₹2,00,000 in the balance sheet. (b) The same firm paid ₹30,000 over net assets when it bought a rival's branch last year. Working: (a) is self-generated goodwill; nothing was paid for it, so it cannot be recorded. (b) is acquired goodwill; consideration was paid, so ₹30,000 is recorded as goodwill.
Methods of valuing goodwill
Methods of valuation in the textbook
-
Average profit method
- Simple average profit
- Weighted average profit
-
Super profit methods
- Purchase of super profit
- Annuity method
- Capitalisation of super profit
-
Capitalisation method
- Capitalised value of average profit minus capital employed
All methods start from the firm's profits. The average profit methods multiply average profit by a number of years of purchase. The super profit methods first find the profit over and above what a normal business would earn on the same capital. The capitalisation method compares the business value implied by its profit with the capital actually employed.
Key takeaways: goodwill is valued whenever partners' rights change: change in ratio, admission, retirement or death, and dissolution. Only acquired goodwill, for which consideration has been paid, is recorded; it equals purchase consideration minus net assets. Self-generated goodwill is not recorded.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these does NOT require valuation of goodwill in a partnership firm?
- Admission of a new partner
- Retirement of a partner
- Purchase of new machinery
- Change in the profit sharing ratio
Show answer
Answer: C. Goodwill is valued when partners' mutual rights change. Buying machinery changes no partner's rights.
-
2. A firm pays ₹3,00,000 for a business with assets of ₹4,10,000 and liabilities of ₹1,60,000. Goodwill acquired is:
- ₹50,000
- ₹1,10,000
- ₹2,50,000
- ₹1,40,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Net assets = 4,10,000 − 1,60,000 = 2,50,000. Goodwill = 3,00,000 − 2,50,000 = ₹50,000.
-
3. Self-generated goodwill:
- is recorded at its estimated value
- is recorded only on dissolution
- cannot be recorded in the books
- is recorded as a current asset
Show answer
Answer: C. No consideration has been paid for self-generated goodwill, so it is not recorded.
-
4. Acquired goodwill is shown in the balance sheet under:
- current assets
- fixed assets
- current liabilities
- capital
Show answer
Answer: B. Acquired goodwill is an intangible fixed asset shown under fixed assets.
-
5. Which method uses super profit as its base?
- Simple average profit method
- Weighted average profit method
- Annuity method
- None of these
Show answer
Answer: C. The annuity method multiplies super profit by the present value annuity factor; the two average profit methods use average profit.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.