- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Limitations of financial statements and company financial statements
List the limitations of financial statements and describe the Companies Act provisions and the Schedule III format that the textbook gives for company financial statements.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the limitations of financial statements.
- State what company financial statements include and the requirements of Section 129(1), as given in the textbook.
- Place items under the main headings of the Schedule III balance sheet and apply the rounding-off rule.
Financial statements are useful, but they are not a perfect picture. Knowing their limits stops us from reading too much into a single number. Companies must also follow a set format, which makes their statements easier to compare.
Limitations of financial statements
Limitations of financial statements
- Lack of qualitative information Efficiency of employees or management is ignored
- Record of historical data May not reflect the current position
- Ignore price level changes No adjustment for inflation
- Lack of consistency Different firms use different methods
- Only interim reports True position known only when the business closes
- Limited access to external users Outsiders lack detailed, frequent data
- Influenced by personal judgement Not free from bias
Worked example 1: spotting the limitation
The company and all figures in this example are made up for practice. (a) Kurinji Ltd bought land years ago for ₹10,00,000 and still shows it at that figure although land prices nearby have risen sharply. (b) Kurinji uses one depreciation method and its rival uses another, so their profits are not directly comparable. (c) Kurinji's staff are highly skilled, but nothing in the statements shows this. Working: (a) is the historical data / price level limitation; (b) is lack of consistency; (c) is lack of qualitative information.
Financial statements of companies
The textbook gives these provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 (it calls it the Indian Companies Act, 2013):
- Section 2(40): financial statements include the balance sheet, the profit and loss account (or income and expenditure account), the cash flow statement, the statement of changes in equity and any explanatory note annexed to them.
- Section 129(1): the statements must give a true and fair view of the state of affairs of the company, comply with the Accounting Standards notified under Section 133, and be in the form provided in Schedule III.
- Where the statements do not comply with the Accounting Standards, the company must disclose the deviation, the reasons and the financial effects, if any.
The textbook prints Part I (Balance Sheet) and Part II (Statement of Profit and Loss) of Schedule III for understanding only. The main balance sheet headings are summarised below.
| Equity and liabilities | Assets |
|---|---|
| 1. Shareholders' funds: share capital; reserves and surplus; money received against share warrants | 1. Non-current assets: fixed assets (tangible, intangible, capital work-in-progress, intangible assets under development); non-current investments; deferred tax assets (net); long-term loans and advances; other non-current assets |
| 2. Share application money pending allotment | 2. Current assets: current investments; inventories; trade receivables; cash and cash equivalents; short-term loans and advances; other current assets |
| 3. Non-current liabilities: long-term borrowings; deferred tax liabilities (net); other long-term liabilities; long-term provisions | |
| 4. Current liabilities: short-term borrowings; trade payables; other current liabilities; short-term provisions |
The textbook also gives Schedule III's rounding-off rule: a company with turnover less than one hundred crore rupees may round figures to the nearest hundreds, thousands, lakhs or millions, or decimals of these; a company with turnover of one hundred crore rupees or more may round to the nearest lakhs, millions or crores, or decimals of these. Once a unit is chosen it must be used uniformly.
Worked example 2: placing items and rounding
The company and all figures in this example are made up for practice. Place these items of Mullai Ltd: trade payables, long-term borrowings, inventories, securities premium, trade receivables. Working: trade payables → current liabilities; long-term borrowings → non-current liabilities; inventories and trade receivables → current assets; securities premium → reserves and surplus under shareholders' funds. Mullai's turnover is below one hundred crore rupees and it reports in lakhs: an amount of ₹47,36,512 = 47.36512 lakhs, shown to two decimals as ₹47.37 lakhs.
Company financial statements: true and fair view, Accounting Standards, Schedule III format (Section 129(1), as the textbook states).
Key takeaways: statements leave out qualitative facts, use historical cost, ignore price changes, differ in methods between firms, are interim, are less detailed for outsiders and involve judgement. Company statements follow Section 2(40), Section 129(1) and Schedule III.
Check your understanding
-
1. Financial statements do not show
- past data
- non-monetary data such as the efficiency of employees
- short-term data
- long-term data
Show answer
Answer: B. Lack of qualitative information is a limitation: non-monetary facts like employee or management efficiency are ignored.
-
2. A company shows a building bought fifteen years ago at its original cost although prices have risen greatly since. This illustrates the limitation that financial statements
- lack consistency between firms
- give only interim reports
- ignore price level changes
- have limited access for outsiders
Show answer
Answer: C. No adjustment is made for changes in price levels, so an old asset at historical cost may not reflect the current position.
-
3. As stated in the textbook, Section 2(40) of the Companies Act, 2013 includes all of the following in financial statements EXCEPT
- the cash flow statement
- the statement of changes in equity
- the balance sheet
- the directors' report
Show answer
Answer: D. Section 2(40), as listed in the textbook, covers the balance sheet, profit and loss account, cash flow statement, statement of changes in equity and explanatory notes. The directors' report is not in that list.
-
4. In the Schedule III balance sheet, trade payables are shown under
- current liabilities
- non-current liabilities
- shareholders' funds
- current assets
Show answer
Answer: A. Trade payables appear under current liabilities, together with short-term borrowings, other current liabilities and short-term provisions.
-
5. According to the rounding-off rule given in the textbook, a company with a turnover of one hundred crore rupees or more may round its figures to the nearest
- hundreds or thousands only
- lakhs, millions or crores, or decimals of these
- rupee only
- ten crores only
Show answer
Answer: B. For turnover of one hundred crore rupees or more, the rule allows rounding to the nearest lakhs, millions or crores (or decimals). Hundreds and thousands are allowed only below that turnover.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.