- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Transgenic crops, bio-based products and biopiracy
Explain herbicide-tolerant, Bt, Flavr Savr and Golden rice crops, list benefits and concerns of GM foods, describe PHB, PLA, GFP, biopharming, bioremediation and algal biofuels, and distinguish bioprospecting from biopiracy.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain how glyphosate- and Basta-tolerant crops work.
- Describe Bt cotton and Bt brinjal, with the advantages and limits of Bt cotton.
- Explain Flavr Savr tomato and Golden rice, and the benefits and concerns of GM foods.
- Describe biopolymers, GFP, biopharming, bioremediation, biofuels, bioprospecting and biopiracy.
Transgenic (genetically modified, GM) plants carry new DNA introduced into their genome. This lesson looks at the crops and products the Tamil Nadu textbook describes, and at the debate and legal questions that come with them.
Herbicide-tolerant crops
Weeds compete with crops for light, water, nutrients and space and carry pests. The herbicide glyphosate kills plants by blocking the enzyme EPSPS (5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase), needed to make aromatic amino acids. Crops are made tolerant either by adding a soil-bacterium gene for a glyphosate-tolerant EPSPS, or a gene for an enzyme that breaks glyphosate down. Basta contains phosphinothricin (PPT), which inhibits glutamine synthetase in ammonia assimilation; the bar gene of Streptomyces hygroscopicus codes for phosphinothricin acetyl transferase (PAT), which inactivates it, and has been introduced into crops such as potato and sugar beet. The textbook lists advantages such as better weed control and yield, fewer sprays and less competition.
Insect-resistant Bt crops
Bacillus thuringiensis produces crystal (Cry) proteins, toxic to particular insect larvae such as bollworms but, as the textbook notes, harmless to other forms of life. When a larva eats the plant, the toxin is activated in its gut, damages the gut lining and kills it. Bt cotton resists bollworms; Bt brinjal carries the Cry1Ac gene, introduced by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation, against the brinjal fruit and shoot borer (Leucinodes orbonalis).
Bt cotton as described in the textbook
-
Advantages
- Higher yield through bollworm control
- Less insecticide use
- Possible lower cost of cultivation
-
Limitations
- Costly seed
- Effect reduced after about 120 days
- Ineffective against sucking pests: jassids, aphids, whitefly
- Reported effects on pollinators
DMH-11 (Dhara Mustard Hybrid), developed at the Centre for Genetic Manipulation of Crop Plants, University of Delhi, carries three soil-bacterium genes: barnase, barstar and bar (Basta tolerance). Virus-resistant crops carry genes that interfere with the virus.
Better food: Flavr Savr and Golden rice
Flavr Savr tomato carries an antisense gene that blocks production of polygalacturonase, the enzyme that softens fruit; ripening slows, so the fruit keeps its colour and flavour and stores longer. Golden rice (Ingo Potrykus and colleagues) makes β-carotene, a precursor of vitamin A, in its endosperm, aimed at areas where vitamin A deficiency causes childhood blindness (xerophthalmia). It contains a psy (phytoene synthase) gene from daffodil (Narcissus pseudonarcissus), a crtI gene from a soil bacterium (Erwinia) and a lycopene cyclase gene. This is biofortification.
| Benefits listed in the textbook | Concerns listed in the textbook |
|---|---|
| High yield without pest damage | Suspected effects on liver and kidney, and cancer |
| Less pesticide use | Hormonal imbalance |
| Less soil pollution | Allergies and anaphylactic shock |
| Conserves soil microbes | Effects of bacterial proteins on immunity; non-viable seed in 'terminator' technology |
Bio-based products and environmental uses
- PHB and PHAs (polyhydroxybutyrate, polyhydroxyalkanoates): biodegradable, biocompatible plastics made by bacteria such as Bacillus megaterium and Alcaligenes eutrophus; used in drug delivery, scaffolds and heart valves.
- PLA (polylactic acid): a biodegradable thermoplastic polyester from lactic acid or lactide, made from corn starch, cassava or sugarcane.
- GFP (green fluorescent protein) from the jellyfish Aequorea victoria: 238 amino acids, glows green under blue-UV light (395 nm) without cofactors; used as a reporter of gene expression and in biosensors.
- Biopharming (molecular farming): transgenic plants engineered to produce pharmaceutical substances.
- Bioremediation: microbes or plants clean up oil, pesticides and heavy metals - phytoremediation, mycoremediation, bioventing, bioleaching, bioaugmentation, composting, rhizofiltration. It works only for biodegradable pollutants and must be tested at small scale first.
- Algal biofuel: oil from algae such as Botryococcus braunii for biodiesel. Chlamydomonas reinhardtii deprived of sulphur switches to producing hydrogen through an [Fe]-hydrogenase.
Bioprospecting and biopiracy
Bioprospecting is discovering and commercialising new products from biological resources. When indigenous knowledge is used for profit without permission or payment to the communities who hold it, it becomes biopiracy. The textbook's cases: a European patent sought in the early 1990s on fungicidal use of neem oil, which was challenged and Indian traditional knowledge upheld; a 1995 US patent on turmeric for wound healing, revoked after a 1953 Indian Medical Association article showed the use was already known; and a 1997 US patent on 'basmati rice lines and grains', most of whose claims, including use of the name, were withdrawn by 2002.
Glyphosate blocks EPSPS; Basta (PPT) blocks glutamine synthetase, bar/PAT detoxifies it. Bt = Cry toxin. Flavr Savr = antisense polygalacturonase. Golden rice = β-carotene.
Worked reasoning example: matching problem and solution
Match each problem with a biotechnology answer: (1) cotton bolls eaten by caterpillars; (2) tomatoes rotting in transport; (3) vitamin A deficiency in rice-eating regions; (4) oil spill in soil. Reasoning: (1) caterpillars are larvae killed by Cry toxin, so Bt cotton; (2) softening is caused by polygalacturonase, so Flavr Savr's antisense gene; (3) rice endosperm lacks β-carotene, so Golden rice; (4) living organisms can degrade oil, so bioremediation.
Key takeaways: herbicide tolerance targets EPSPS (glyphosate) or uses bar/PAT (Basta); Bt crops carry Cry genes against insect larvae; Flavr Savr and Golden rice improve storage and nutrition; GM foods have listed benefits and debated concerns; PHB, PLA, GFP, biopharming, bioremediation and algal fuels are other applications; biopiracy is the unauthorised profit from indigenous knowledge.
Check your understanding
-
1. Glyphosate kills plants by inhibiting the enzyme:
- glutamine synthetase
- EPSPS
- polygalacturonase
- β-galactosidase
Show answer
Answer: B. Glyphosate blocks EPSPS in the pathway for aromatic amino acids. Basta (phosphinothricin) inhibits glutamine synthetase.
-
2. The bar gene used in Basta-tolerant crops codes for:
- phosphinothricin acetyl transferase
- a Cry toxin
- phytoene synthase
- EPSPS
Show answer
Answer: A. bar, from Streptomyces hygroscopicus, encodes PAT, which inactivates phosphinothricin, the active ingredient of Basta.
-
3. Which is a limitation of Bt cotton listed in the textbook?
- It increases bollworm damage
- It needs more insecticide sprays
- It cannot be grown in India
- It does not protect against sucking pests such as aphids and whitefly
Show answer
Answer: D. Cry toxins act on chewing larvae such as bollworms; sucking pests like jassids, aphids and whitefly are not controlled. Seed cost and reduced effect after about 120 days are other limits.
-
4. Flavr Savr tomato stays firm longer because:
- it produces a Cry protein
- it makes β-carotene
- an antisense gene blocks polygalacturonase production
- it is resistant to glyphosate
Show answer
Answer: C. Polygalacturonase breaks down pectin and softens ripening fruit. The antisense gene reduces this enzyme, delaying softening and lengthening shelf life.
-
5. Using indigenous knowledge for commercial profit without permission or payment to its holders is called:
- biopiracy
- bioremediation
- biopharming
- biofortification
Show answer
Answer: A. Biopiracy exploits traditional knowledge or resources without authorisation or compensation, as in the neem, turmeric and basmati patent cases.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.