• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Productivity, trophic levels and the flow of energy

Calculate net primary productivity from gross productivity and respiration, assign organisms to trophic levels and use the laws of thermodynamics and the ten percent law to trace energy flow.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define primary, secondary and community productivity and calculate NPP = GPP − respiration.
  • List the factors that affect primary productivity.
  • Place producers and consumers in trophic levels T1 to T4.
  • Apply the two laws of thermodynamics and the ten percent law to energy flow.

A paddy field and a desert patch of the same size receive similar sunshine, yet one feeds a village and the other hardly anything. The difference is productivity, the rate at which an ecosystem builds biomass. How that biomass then passes from plants to animals, and why so little reaches the top, is explained by energy flow.

Productivity

Productivity is the rate of biomass production per unit area per unit time, expressed as g/m²/year or kcal/m²/year. Primary productivity is the organic matter made by autotrophs by photosynthesis (and chemosynthesis); it is the energy source for every organism. Gross primary productivity (GPP) is the total made. Plants use part of it for their own respiration, and what remains is net primary productivity (NPP), also called apparent photosynthesis. The textbook estimates NPP of the whole biosphere at about 170 billion tonnes dry weight a year, of which oceanic producers contribute about 55 billion tonnes.

NPP = GPP − respiration of the producers.

Secondary productivity is energy stored in the tissues of consumers. Gross secondary productivity is the plant material eaten by herbivores minus what is lost as faeces, and net secondary productivity is what consumers store after respiration. Community productivity is the rate of net synthesis of organic matter by a group of plants per unit area per unit time. Primary productivity depends on the plant species, their photosynthetic capacity, nutrients, sunlight, rainfall, soil type and topography, so it differs widely between ecosystems.

Trophic levels

A trophic level (Greek trophe, food) is an organism's position in a food chain. Producers form the first trophic level (T1). Herbivores, the primary consumers, form T2. Carnivores that eat herbivores are secondary consumers (primary carnivores) at T3, and carnivores that eat them are tertiary consumers (secondary carnivores) at T4. Omnivores such as the crow eat both plants and animals and so can occupy more than one level.

Energy flow and thermodynamics

Energy flow is the transfer of energy between trophic levels. At every step part is passed on and part is lost as heat, so energy flow is always unidirectional: it never returns from carnivores to the Sun. Two laws govern it. The first law of thermodynamics says energy is neither created nor destroyed but changes form; in photosynthesis, light energy becomes chemical energy in glucose (6CO₂ + 6H₂O → C₆H₁₂O₆ + 6O₂, with light and chlorophyll), with no net gain or loss. The second law says every transformation lowers the free energy available; no transfer is 100% efficient, and a large part is dissipated as heat in respiration.

Unidirectional energy flow

  1. Sun Light energy
  2. Producers (T1) Light to chemical energy; heat lost in respiration
  3. Herbivores (T2) About 10% passed on
  4. Carnivores (T3) About 10% of T2
  5. Top carnivores (T4) About 10% of T3
Heat is lost at every step and cannot be reused.

The ten percent law, proposed by Lindeman (1942), says that only about 10% of the food energy at one trophic level is stored at the next; about 90% is lost in respiration, decomposition and as heat.

Worked example 1: NPP from GPP

A made-up grassland fixes 2400 kcal/m²/year (GPP) and its plants respire 1500 kcal/m²/year. NPP = 2400 − 1500 = 900 kcal/m²/year. As a share of GPP: 900 ÷ 2400 = 0.375, so 37.5% of the gross production is left for herbivores and decomposers. Check: 1500 + 900 = 2400.

Worked example 2: applying the ten percent law

Producers store 50,000 J. How much reaches T4? T2 = 10% of 50,000 = 5,000 J; T3 = 10% of 5,000 = 500 J; T4 = 10% of 500 = 50 J. Energy lost between T1 and T2 is 50,000 − 5,000 = 45,000 J. In one step: 50,000 × 0.1 × 0.1 × 0.1 = 50 J, which agrees. This is why food chains rarely go beyond four or five links.

Key takeaways: productivity is a rate; NPP is what plants have left after their own respiration. Organisms are grouped into trophic levels from producers (T1) upwards. Energy flows one way and shrinks to about a tenth at each step, as the laws of thermodynamics predict.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A forest has a GPP of 3000 kcal/m²/year and producer respiration of 1800 kcal/m²/year. Its NPP is:

    1. 4800 kcal/m²/year
    2. 1800 kcal/m²/year
    3. 3000 kcal/m²/year
    4. 1200 kcal/m²/year
    Show answer

    Answer: D. NPP = GPP − respiration = 3000 − 1800 = 1200 kcal/m²/year. Adding the two values (4800) is the common mistake.

  2. 2. Net primary productivity is also called:

    1. Apparent photosynthesis
    2. Gross photosynthesis
    3. Secondary productivity
    4. Standing crop
    Show answer

    Answer: A. NPP is the production that remains after the plant's respiration, which is what we can actually measure as growth, so it is called apparent photosynthesis.

  3. 3. A snake that eats frogs which eat insects which eat leaves occupies which trophic level?

    1. T1
    2. T2
    3. T4
    4. T3
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Leaves are T1, insects (herbivores) T2, frogs (eating herbivores) T3, so the snake eating frogs is at T4, a tertiary consumer.

  4. 4. Why is energy flow in an ecosystem unidirectional?

    1. Energy is created at each trophic level
    2. Energy lost as heat at each transfer cannot be passed back to producers
    3. Consumers return their energy to the Sun
    4. Decomposers convert heat back to light
    Show answer

    Answer: B. By the second law, each transfer dissipates part of the energy as heat, which plants cannot use again. So energy moves only forward from the Sun through the trophic levels.

  5. 5. If herbivores in a made-up pond store 2000 J, about how much energy will secondary consumers store according to the ten percent law?

    1. 200 J
    2. 20 J
    3. 1800 J
    4. 20,000 J
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Only about 10% passes to the next level: 10% of 2000 J = 200 J. The remaining 1800 J is lost mainly as heat.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery