• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Transgenic animals, biological products, cloning and ethics

Describe how transgenic animals are made and used, what biological products are, how Dolly the sheep was cloned by nuclear transfer, the advantages and disadvantages of animal cloning, and the ethical concerns of biotechnology.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define transgenesis, transgene and transgenic animal and list the steps to make one.
  • Give six uses of transgenic animals.
  • Define biological products and give examples, including monoclonal antibodies.
  • Describe the cloning of Dolly by nuclear transfer.
  • Weigh the advantages, disadvantages and ethical issues of animal cloning and biotechnology.

For centuries farmers improved livestock by selective breeding, choosing parents and waiting generations. Biotechnology now allows changes at the level of genes, in a single generation, and even the copying of a whole adult animal. These powers bring both benefits and serious questions.

Transgenic animals

Transgenesis is the introduction of extra (foreign) DNA into an animal's genome so that it creates and maintains a stable heritable character. The foreign DNA is the transgene, and the animals are transgenic animals, also called genetically modified organisms. Transgenic mice, rats, rabbits, pigs, cows, goats, sheep and fish have been produced.

Steps in producing a transgenic animal

  1. Identify and separate the gene The desired gene, for example a human protein gene
  2. Choose a vector Generally a virus, or direct transfer such as microinjection
  3. Combine gene and vector Make the recombinant construct
  4. Introduce it Into cells, tissues, an embryo or a mature individual
  5. Confirm integration and expression Show the gene is present and working in the animal
  • Research: to study gene expression and development in higher organisms.
  • Disease models: transgenic models exist for cancer, Alzheimer's disease, cystic fibrosis, rheumatoid arthritis and sickle cell anaemia, helping to test new treatments.
  • Biological products: to make medically important proteins, for example in milk.
  • Vaccine safety: transgenic mice are used to test the safety of vaccines.
  • Toxicity testing: animals carrying genes that make them more sensitive to toxic substances show effects sooner.
  • Farming: improving the quality and quantity of milk, meat, eggs and wool.

Biological products

A biological product is a substance derived from a living organism and used to prevent or treat disease: antitoxins, bacterial and viral vaccines, blood products and hormone extracts. They may be made by biotechnology in microbes, plant cells or animal cells, and rDNA technology lets them be produced on demand. Examples available today include recombinant insulin, human growth hormone, recombinant vaccines and proteins such as human alpha-lactalbumin. Animals can serve as bioreactors for such proteins, including antibodies. Monoclonal antibodies are used in treating cancer, heart disease and transplant rejection. Natural protein adhesives, being non-toxic, biodegradable and rarely triggering immune responses, could be used to reattach tendons, fill tooth cavities and repair bones.

Animal cloning and Dolly

Cloning is producing genetically identical individuals, naturally (as in asexual reproduction) or artificially. In biotechnology it also means copying cells or DNA fragments (molecular cloning). Dolly the sheep, produced by Ian Wilmut and Keith Campbell and announced in 1997, was the first mammal cloned from a differentiated somatic cell of an adult, using nuclear transfer and the totipotency of the nucleus. A gene knockout organism, by contrast, is one engineered so that one or more of its genes are made inoperative.

How Dolly was cloned (nuclear transfer)

  1. Donor cell Udder (mammary) cells from sheep A are starved for about 5 days, become dormant and totipotent
  2. Enucleated egg An egg from sheep B has its nucleus removed
  3. Fusion The dormant udder cell and the empty egg are fused, so the egg takes in the donor nucleus
  4. Early embryo The fused cell is cultured for about 6 days into an embryo
  5. Surrogate The embryo is implanted in a third ewe
  6. Birth About five months later Dolly is born, genetically identical to sheep A

According to the textbook, 277 udder cells were fused with 277 enucleated eggs; 29 embryos were implanted and only one lamb, Dolly, was born. That success rate shows how difficult cloning is.

Worked example 1: success rate of the Dolly experiment

Using the textbook's figures: fused cells = 277, embryos implanted = 29, live births = 1. Success per implanted embryo = 1 ÷ 29 × 100 ≈ 3.4%. Success per fused cell = 1 ÷ 277 × 100 ≈ 0.36%. Conclusion: fewer than 4 in 100 implanted embryos, and fewer than 1 in 250 fused cells, gave a live lamb, which fits the textbook's statement that more than 90% of cloning attempts fail.

Animal cloning: points for and against (as listed in the Tamil Nadu textbook)
AdvantagesDisadvantages
Benefits clinical trials and medical research; helps produce proteins and drugsSeen by some as a threat to biodiversity and to natural evolution
Aids stem cell researchTedious, very expensive, and can cause animals to suffer
Could help save endangered speciesSurrogates and clones show disease and high death rates; clones may age faster and be less healthy, as reported for Dolly; genetic disorders may occur; more than 90% of attempts fail; concerns about eating meat of cloned animals

Ethical issues

Biotechnology has given society cheaper medicines, better fruits and vegetables, pest-resistant crops and new cures, and also much controversy, because so much of it involves genetic manipulation. People fear unknown consequences; the major worry about rDNA technology is that new microorganisms might be created, by accident or deliberately for war, that cause epidemics or environmental disasters. Other concerns include animal welfare in cloning and the use of embryos for stem cells. The textbook's own judgement is that the risks are in fact slight and the potential benefits substantial; societies manage these risks through regulation and open discussion.

Worked reasoning example 2: whose genes does Dolly carry?

Three ewes were involved: A gave the udder cell, B gave the egg, C carried the pregnancy. Whom does Dolly resemble genetically? Reasoning: (1) The egg's own nucleus was removed, so B's nuclear genes were not passed on. (2) The nucleus came from A's udder cell. (3) C only provided the womb. Conclusion: Dolly's nuclear DNA is A's, so she is A's clone. (Strictly, a small amount of DNA in the egg's mitochondria came from B.)

Transgenic = foreign gene in the genome, inherited. Clone = genetically identical copy. Dolly: nucleus from an adult udder cell + enucleated egg + surrogate (nuclear transfer).

Key takeaways: transgenic animals carry and pass on a foreign gene and serve research, medicine and farming. Biological products such as insulin, growth hormone, vaccines and monoclonal antibodies come from living systems. Dolly was cloned from an adult somatic cell by nuclear transfer, with a very low success rate. Cloning and genetic manipulation raise ethical questions that must be weighed against their benefits.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Dolly the sheep was produced by:

    1. cloning by gene transfer
    2. cloning by nuclear transfer
    3. cloning by tissue culture of somatic cells
    4. fertilisation of an egg in vitro
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The nucleus of an adult udder cell was transferred into an enucleated egg, which developed into Dolly. This is nuclear transfer, without fertilisation.

  2. 2. Transgenic animals are those which have:

    1. foreign DNA in some of their cells
    2. foreign RNA in some of their cells
    3. foreign RNA in all their cells
    4. foreign DNA in all their cells
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A transgene integrated into the genome of the early embryo is passed to every cell and is heritable, so transgenic animals carry the foreign DNA in all their cells.

  3. 3. Which is NOT a use of transgenic animals given in the textbook?

    1. Testing the safety of vaccines
    2. Models for human diseases
    3. Making animals immune to all diseases
    4. Producing pharmaceutical proteins
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook lists vaccine testing, disease models and protein production. No transgenic animal is immune to all diseases.

  4. 4. In the Dolly experiment, the egg cell had its nucleus removed. Why?

    1. So that the clone would carry only the donor udder cell's nuclear genes
    2. To make the egg divide faster
    3. Because egg nuclei are toxic
    4. To prevent the surrogate from rejecting it
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Removing the egg's nucleus ensured that the embryo's nuclear genes came only from the adult udder cell, making Dolly a clone of the donor.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Animal cloning is costly and inefficient. Reason (R): More than 90 percent of cloning attempts fail to produce a viable offspring.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. With so many attempts failing, many eggs, embryos and surrogate mothers are needed for each success, which makes cloning expensive and inefficient. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery