• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Plant introduction and selection

Explain primary and secondary introduction, acclimatisation and quarantine, and compare natural selection with mass, pure line and clonal selection, including their advantages and limits.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define plant introduction, acclimatisation and quarantine.
  • Distinguish primary from secondary introduction with examples.
  • Describe mass selection, pure line selection and clonal selection.
  • State the main limitation of each selection method.

The fastest way to get a better crop is to borrow one that already exists elsewhere. The next fastest is to pick the best plants out of a mixed field. Introduction and selection are the oldest conventional breeding methods, and they use variation that is already present within a species rather than creating new genes.

Plant introduction

Plant introduction is bringing genotypes from the place where they normally grow to a new place or environment. Famous examples are the rice variety IR8 from the Philippines and the wheat varieties Sonora 63 and Sonora 64 from Mexico. An introduced plant must adjust to its new conditions; this adjustment is acclimatisation. All introductions must be free of weeds, insects and pathogens, which is ensured by quarantine, strict isolation imposed to prevent the spread of disease.

Two kinds of introduction
Primary introductionSecondary introduction
The introduced variety is well adapted and is released as it isThe introduced variety is selected further or hybridised with local varieties
The original genotype is not alteredOne or a few characters are transferred to local varieties, or a superior line is isolated
Example: a variety grown directly after testingExample: tea clones from China and North-East India selected in the Botanical Garden, Kolkata, and spread across India

In India the National Bureau of Plant Genetic Resources (NBPGR), New Delhi, is responsible for introducing and maintaining germplasm of agricultural, horticultural, botanical and medicinal interest; the textbook lists regional stations at Amritsar, Kolkata, Mumbai and Chennai (Meenambakkam).

Selection

Selection is choosing individuals with desirable traits from a mixed population; it is the oldest and most basic breeding method. Natural selection operates in nature (Darwin's survival of the fittest) and is slow. Artificial selection is done by people, in three main ways.

Mass selection: a large number of plants of similar, desirable phenotype are picked and their seeds mixed to form a new variety. The plants are not tested individually. After about five or six years of repeated selection, the seed is multiplied and given to farmers. Its drawback: it is hard to tell whether a plant looks good because of its genes or because of its surroundings (hereditary versus environmental variation).

Pure line selection: the term pure line was coined by Johannsen (1903). A pure line is the progeny of a single homozygous plant obtained by repeated self-pollination, so all its plants are homozygous and alike. Drawbacks: no new genotypes are created, and such a uniform variety adapts poorly and is less stable when the environment fluctuates.

Clonal selection: used in asexually propagated crops, where offspring formed by mitosis are genetically identical to the parent. Superior plants are picked from a mixture of clones, multiplied vegetatively and tested: separate clone rows, then a preliminary yield trial against standard varieties, then multi-location trials, before the best clone is released. A clone's genotype stays unchanged for a long time.

Three methods of artificial selection

  • Mass selection
    • Many similar plants chosen
    • Seeds bulked together
    • Variety somewhat mixed
    • Genes and environment hard to separate
  • Pure line selection
    • One homozygous plant
    • Repeated selfing
    • Uniform, homozygous variety
    • No new genotypes; poorly adaptable
  • Clonal selection
    • Vegetatively propagated crops
    • Best plants multiplied as clones
    • Genotype stays fixed
    • Example crops: potato, sugarcane, banana

Worked example 1: picking the method

Which selection method suits (i) sugarcane, (ii) a self-pollinated wheat landrace where one outstanding plant is found? Reasoning: (i) sugarcane is propagated by stem cuttings, so offspring are clones; clonal selection. (ii) wheat self-pollinates, so selfing one outstanding plant for a few generations gives a true-breeding line; pure line selection.

Worked example 2: why mass selection can mislead

Two made-up plants of the same height are chosen in mass selection. Plant X grew tall on a rich patch near a compost pit; plant Y grew tall in ordinary soil. Reasoning: X's height is partly environmental and may not be passed on; Y's is more likely genetic. Mass selection, without testing each plant's progeny, picks both alike. Lesson: progeny testing, as in pure line selection, separates hereditary from environmental variation.

Introduction borrows a variety; selection picks the best of what is already there. Neither creates new genes.

Key takeaways: introduced varieties need acclimatisation and quarantine; primary introductions are used as they are, secondary ones are improved further. Mass selection bulks similar plants, pure line selection breeds from one homozygous plant, and clonal selection multiplies the best vegetative clone.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Bringing in better varieties from outside and adjusting them to local conditions is called:

    1. Cloning
    2. Heterosis
    3. Introduction
    4. Mutation
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Plant introduction brings genotypes to a new area; the plant's adjustment to the new environment is acclimatisation.

  2. 2. Strict isolation of introduced plant material to prevent the spread of disease is:

    1. Quarantine
    2. Acclimatisation
    3. Emasculation
    4. Bagging
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Quarantine checks and isolates introduced material so that weeds, insects and pathogens do not enter. Acclimatisation is the plant's adaptation; emasculation and bagging are steps of hybridisation.

  3. 3. Pick out the INCORRECT pair.

    1. Mass selection: morphological characters
    2. Pure line selection: repeated self-pollination
    3. Natural selection: involves nature
    4. Clonal selection: sexually propagated crops
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Clonal selection is used in asexually (vegetatively) propagated crops, whose offspring are clones. The other three pairs are correct.

  4. 4. The term pure line was coined by:

    1. Shull
    2. Johannsen
    3. Muller
    4. Vavilov
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Johannsen coined pure line in 1903. Shull coined heterosis, Muller worked on induced mutation and Vavilov described centres of origin.

  5. 5. The main disadvantage of mass selection is that:

    1. It cannot separate hereditary variation from environmental variation
    2. It can be used only in clones
    3. It creates too many new genes
    4. It needs emasculation
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Plants are chosen on appearance without progeny testing, so a plant that looks good only because of favourable surroundings may be selected.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery