• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Management as art and science; management and administration

Explain why the textbook calls management an inexact science and not an art in full, describe a professional manager, and distinguish management from administration on the book's bases.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why management is called an inexact science.
  • Explain why management is not an art in full, and why it is a combination of art and science.
  • Distinguish management from administration and place each in the organisation.

Is a good manager born or made? If management were a pure science, anyone who learnt its laws would manage equally well. If it were a pure art, it could not be taught from books at all. The textbook takes a middle path, and its reasoning is a common long-answer topic. In the same section it separates management from administration, two words that are often used as if they meant the same thing.

Management as an inexact science

In a pure science, a principle can be tested in a laboratory and proved or disproved exactly. A botany student, for instance, can test whether a leaf contains starch and get a definite answer. Management principles are also tested, but in an organisation where the four Ms (men, machines, money and materials) are brought together to reach goals. There the results are never exact, because principles must bend to a changing environment, changing policies and practical difficulties. So the textbook calls management an inexact science.

Why management is not an art in full

An art is a skill learnt and then displayed whenever needed, as a carpenter, mechanic, mason or musician can show their craft anywhere. Every manager also needs a set of skills, but the level of those skills differs widely from one person to another, whatever their country. Two leaders in the same position can manage in very different ways. So management is not an exact art either. Its art side shows most clearly in decision making: judgement and imagination remain essential, and the textbook stresses that a computer cannot replace a manager in taking decisions.

Management: science side and art side

  • Science side
    • Organised principles that can be learnt
    • Tested in organisations using the 4 Ms
    • Results not exact, so an inexact science
  • Art side
    • Personal skill in applying principles
    • Skill level varies from manager to manager
    • Seen in judgement and decision making
The textbook's conclusion: management is a combination of both.

The textbook also quotes Louis A. Allen, who describes a professional manager as someone who specialises in planning, organising, leading and controlling the efforts of others, uses classified knowledge, a common vocabulary and principles in a systematic way, and follows the standards of practice and code of ethics laid down by a recognised body. Its conclusion is that management is neither a pure science nor a pure art but a combination of both: managers apply scientific principles and use personal skill to reach goals efficiently and quickly in a competitive, global business world.

Management is an inexact science and not an art in full; in practice it is a combination of art and science.

Management and administration

Administration is concerned with top-level decision making: framing policies and setting objectives. Management is executive in nature: it puts those plans and policies into action through the people working under it. In a company, the Board of Directors with the CEO or Managing Director may be called the administration, while the managers of production, marketing, finance, accounting, distribution and research and development may be called the management. The textbook adds that in practice the terms overlap, since a manager does both administrative and executive work; top-level managers belong to administration and middle and lower levels to management, so administration is above management.

Management and administration (main bases from the textbook)
BasisManagementAdministration
Level of authorityMiddle and lower levelTop level
RoleExecutiveDecisive
Concerned withPolicy implementationPolicy formulation
Area of operationWorks under administrationHas full control over the organisation's activities
Applicable toProfit-making business organisationsGovernment offices, military, clubs, hospitals, religious and educational bodies, and businesses
DecidesWho will do the work and howWhat should be done and when
FocusManaging workBest allocation of limited resources
Key personManagerAdministrator
RepresentsEmployees who work for remunerationOwners who get a return on capital invested
FunctionExecutive and governingLegislative and determinative

Where administration ends and management begins

  1. Board of Directors Administration: policies and objectives
  2. Managing Director Top level, linking policy to action
  3. Manager Management: puts plans into action
  4. Supervisor Management: directs the work on the floor

Worked example 1: administration or management?

In a made-up company, Nila Foods: (a) the board decides to open a new plant and sets its output target; (b) the production manager draws up shift rosters to meet that target. Reasoning: (a) decides what should be done and when, at the top level, which is policy formulation, so it is administration; (b) decides who will do the work and how, which is policy implementation, so it is management.

Worked example 2: art or science?

Two branch managers of the same made-up bank follow the same rule book, yet one branch performs far better. Reasoning: the rule book is the science side (organised principles), but the results differ because each manager's skill, judgement and decisions differ (the art side). This shows why the textbook says management combines both.

Key takeaways: management is an inexact science because its principles cannot be proved exactly in a changing organisation; it is not an art in full because managerial skill varies; it combines both. Administration frames policy at the top; management carries it out at the middle and lower levels.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why does the textbook call management an inexact science?

    1. Its principles cannot be learnt
    2. It has no principles at all
    3. Its principles cannot be proved or disproved exactly because conditions keep changing
    4. It is tested only in laboratories
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Management principles are tested in organisations where the 4 Ms interact and conditions change, so they cannot be proved or disproved precisely as in a laboratory.

  2. 2. The four Ms of management are:

    1. men, markets, money and motives
    2. machines, methods, motion and men
    3. materials, markets, minutes and money
    4. men, machines, money and materials
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook names men, machines, money and materials as the four Ms that are integrated to achieve goals.

  3. 3. According to the textbook, the art of management is most fully reflected in a manager's:

    1. decision making
    2. handwriting
    3. knowledge of law
    4. length of service
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says the art of management shows in decision-making capacity; judgement and imagination are needed and a computer cannot replace a manager here.

  4. 4. Which statement about administration is correct?

    1. It works under management
    2. It is concerned with policy formulation at the top level
    3. It decides who will do the work and how
    4. Its key person is the supervisor
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Administration is top level and decisive; it formulates policy and decides what should be done and when. Management implements policy.

  5. 5. In a company, which of these would the textbook treat as part of management rather than administration?

    1. Board of Directors
    2. Managing Director with the board
    3. Marketing manager
    4. Owners setting objectives
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook calls the Board with the CEO/MD the administration, while managers of units such as production, marketing and finance form the management.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Management as a process

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery