- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Recruitment versus selection; placement
Compare recruitment and selection on the textbook's eight bases, and explain placement, its significance, its principles and the probation period.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish recruitment from selection.
- Define placement and state Dale Yoder's view.
- Explain the significance and principles of placement and the probation period.
The textbook calls recruitment and selection two sides of the same coin. Once a person is selected, one more question remains: which exact job will he do? That is placement.
Recruitment versus selection
| Basis | Recruitment | Selection |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Searching for candidates and encouraging them to apply | Choosing suitable candidates and offering them jobs |
| Approach | Positive | Negative |
| Objective | Invite many candidates to apply | Pick the most suitable and eliminate the rest |
| Sequence | First | Second |
| Method | Economical | Expensive |
| Contractual relation | None; only vacancies are communicated | Creates a contract between employer and employee |
| Process | Simple | Complex |
| Time | Less time | More time, as every candidate is tested |
Placement
Placement is assigning a specific job to each selected candidate: placing the right person on the right job. It covers the first assignment of new employees and also the promotion, transfer or demotion of existing ones. The textbook quotes Dale Yoder, who defines placement as deciding the job to which an accepted candidate is to be assigned, and assigning him to that job.
Significance of placement
- Improves employee morale.
- Reduces employee turnover.
- Reduces conflicts and accidents.
- Avoids misfit between candidate and job.
- Helps the employee work towards the organisation's objectives.
- Gives the person a specific rank and responsibilities.
- Helps avoid short-term staff shortage.
Principles of placement
Principles of placement
- Job first, man next Place people according to the job's requirements
- Job offer Offer the job on the basis of qualification
- Terms and conditions Explain conditions and culture
- Awareness of penalties Tell the employee about penalties for lapses
- Loyalty and co-operation Build a sense of responsibility
Because a new employee is not yet familiar with the job and surroundings, he is generally put on probation (a trial period); the textbook mentions one to two years. If his performance is good, he is confirmed as a regular employee.
Job first, man next: the job's requirements decide who is placed, never the other way round.
Worked example 1: recruitment or selection?
Classify: (a) posting a vacancy on a job portal; (b) rejecting 80 of 100 candidates after a written test; (c) signing the contract with the chosen candidate. Working: (a) recruitment (positive, invites applicants); (b) selection (negative, eliminates); (c) selection (creates a contractual relation).
Worked example 2: applying 'job first, man next'
A made-up company has a vacancy for a tax assistant needing knowledge of accounts. The manager's nephew, a science graduate with no accounts background, is available. Reasoning: by the principle 'job first, man next', the job's requirement (knowledge of accounts) must not be compromised to suit a person. The nephew should not be placed in this post; a qualified person should be.
Key takeaways: recruitment is positive, first, cheaper, simpler and quicker and creates no contract; selection is negative, second, costlier, complex and slower and creates a contract. Placement assigns each selected person to the right job, improves morale and reduces turnover and misfits, follows principles such as 'job first, man next', and is followed by probation before confirmation.
Check your understanding
-
1. Selection is usually considered a ______ process.
- positive
- natural
- negative
- neutral
Show answer
Answer: C. Selection eliminates unsuitable candidates, so its approach is negative; recruitment is positive.
-
2. Which creates a contractual relation between employer and employee?
- Selection
- Recruitment
- Advertisement
- Word of mouth
Show answer
Answer: A. Recruitment only communicates vacancies; selection ends in a contract of employment.
-
3. 'Job first, man next' is a principle of:
- recruitment
- interview
- training
- placement
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook lists 'job first, man next' as the first principle of placement.
-
4. According to Dale Yoder, placement is:
- searching for candidates
- deciding the job to which an accepted candidate is to be assigned and assigning him to it
- testing the candidate's IQ
- checking references
Show answer
Answer: B. Yoder's definition covers both deciding the job for an accepted candidate and actually assigning him to it.
-
5. What happens after a new employee completes probation with good performance?
- He is demoted
- He is recruited again
- He is confirmed as a regular employee
- His contract ends automatically
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says that after a successful probation period the employee is confirmed as a regular employee.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.