- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
On-the-job versus off-the-job training; benefits of training
Compare on-the-job and off-the-job training on the textbook's bases and explain the benefits of training to the organisation, the employees and customers.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish on-the-job from off-the-job training.
- List the benefits of training to the organisation, employees and customers.
- Recommend a training approach in a simple case.
Long-answer questions often ask for the differences between the two kinds of training and for the benefits of training under separate headings. This lesson brings both together.
On-the-job versus off-the-job training
| Basis | On-the-job training | Off-the-job training |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Learning in the actual work environment | Training outside the actual work location |
| Cost | Cheapest | Needs separate rooms, specialists, projectors |
| Location | At the work place | Away from the work place |
| Suitable for | Production-related jobs in manufacturing | Managerial and non-production jobs |
| Approach | Practical | Theoretical |
| Principle | Learning by performing | Learning by acquiring knowledge |
| Carried out by | Experienced employees | Experts |
| Deals with | Day-to-day job requirements | Groups of workers at the same time |
| Distraction | More (noise of machines and tools) | None (away from the work floor) |
| Methods | Coaching, job rotation, apprenticeship, mentoring, understudy, job instruction, committee assignment | Role play, seminar, lecture, case study, vestibule, field trip, programmed instruction, demonstration, e-learning |
The two kinds are not rivals. Many organisations combine them: a new machine operator may first watch a demonstration and practise in a vestibule set-up, then move to the shop floor under a coach. The choice depends on the factors the textbook names: the skill required, the trainees' qualifications, the cost, the time available and how deep the knowledge must be. Practical, short skills for production jobs lean towards on-the-job methods; concepts, managerial skills and training of large groups together lean towards off-the-job methods.
Benefits of training
Benefits of training
-
To the organisation
- Better skills, productivity and profit
- Less waste and idle time
- Exposure to latest trends
- Less supervision
- Fewer accidents and compensation payments
- Lower labour turnover
- Better union-management relations
-
To employees
- More knowledge, skill and competence
- Quicker promotion and career growth
- Higher productivity and morale
- Higher earnings through incentives
- Confidence and positive attitude
- Voluntary safety practices
-
To customers
- Better quality products and services
- Innovative, value-added products
Training benefits three parties: the organisation, the employee and the customer.
Worked example 1: recommending training
A made-up textile company led by its managing director, Lakshmi, is buying new high-technology looms and wants staff ready before the machines start production. Reasoning: the looms are costly, and mistakes on the live floor could damage them or stop output, so off-the-job vestibule training on a training set-up, with demonstration by the supplier, suits the first stage; once the looms are running, coaching on the job can follow. Benefits to employees: new skills, higher productivity and earnings, confidence and safer working.
Worked example 2: benefit in numbers
Made-up figures: before training, a unit had 15 accidents a year with average compensation of ₹20,000 each; after training, 6 accidents. Working: before = 15 × 20,000 = ₹3,00,000; after = 6 × 20,000 = ₹1,20,000; saving = ₹1,80,000. This shows the benefit to the organisation of fewer accidents and lower compensation payments.
Key takeaways: on-the-job training is cheaper, practical and given by experienced employees at the workplace; off-the-job training is costlier, theoretical, given by experts away from distractions and suits managerial jobs. Training benefits the organisation (productivity, less waste, fewer accidents, lower turnover), employees (skills, promotion, morale, earnings, confidence) and customers (better and innovative products).
Check your understanding
-
1. Off-the-job training is given:
- on the shop floor during work
- outside the actual work location
- only on holidays
- only to customers
Show answer
Answer: B. Off-the-job training is carried out away from the actual work place, for example in a training room.
-
2. Which type of training is described as the cheapest to carry out?
- Off-the-job training
- Seminar method
- On-the-job training
- Vestibule training
Show answer
Answer: C. On-the-job training uses the actual workplace and experienced staff, so it needs no separate rooms or equipment.
-
3. Which is a benefit of training to customers?
- Better quality products and services
- Quicker promotion
- Fewer union disputes
- Reduced supervision
Show answer
Answer: A. Customers gain better-quality and innovative products; the others are benefits to the organisation or employees.
-
4. Off-the-job training follows which approach, according to the textbook's comparison?
- Practical
- Learning by performing
- Day-to-day job requirements
- Theoretical
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook's table lists off-the-job training as theoretical, learning by acquiring knowledge.
-
5. Made-up figures: accidents fall from 10 to 4 a year and each costs ₹15,000 in compensation. What is the yearly saving?
- ₹60,000
- ₹90,000
- ₹1,50,000
- ₹6,000
Show answer
Answer: B. Accidents fall by 10 − 4 = 6. Saving = 6 × 15,000 = ₹90,000.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.