• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why a redressal mechanism is needed; councils and the three tiers

See why Indian consumers need a grievance redressal mechanism, what consumer protection councils do, and how the three-tier quasi-judicial machinery is arranged, as the Tamil Nadu textbook describes it under the 1986 Act.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Give the reasons the textbook offers for consumers being exploited in India.
  • State the purpose of consumer protection councils.
  • Describe the three-tier redressal machinery and know that the 2019 Act has changed its details.

Rights mean little if there is nowhere to take a complaint. Chapter 18 explains the grievance redressal mechanism: the councils, the consumer courts and the voluntary organisations that help a cheated consumer get justice. Important update: the textbook describes the machinery under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986. That Act was replaced by the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, which renamed the District Forum as the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission and changed the money limits, some time limits and the membership rules. Learn the book's version for your examination, and remember that it is not the present law.

Why consumers need a redressal mechanism

Exploitation is common where consumers do not know their rights. The textbook lists reasons this happens in India: shortage of many products; a few firms enjoying monopoly power; many consumers being unaware of their rights, some with limited literacy; poverty; and lack of unity among consumers. As a result consumers suffer misleading advertisements, poor quality goods, short weights and measures and overcharging. The government has therefore built a system to hear and settle consumers' grievances.

Consumer protection councils

The Act provides for Consumer Protection Councils at the district, state and central (national) levels to spread consumer awareness. Their object, as the book says, is to promote and protect the rights of consumers. Councils are advisory bodies; they do not decide disputes. Disputes go to the three-tier quasi-judicial bodies.

The three-tier machinery

The consumer courts are called quasi-judicial: they work like courts, hear both sides and pass binding orders, but with simpler procedure than ordinary civil courts. The textbook arranges them in three tiers by the value of goods or services and compensation claimed.

Three tiers as given in the textbook (1986 Act limits)

  • National Commission New Delhi
    • Claims above ₹1 crore
    • Appeals from State Commissions
  • State Commission One in each state
    • Claims above ₹20 lakh up to ₹1 crore
    • Appeals from District Forums
  • District Forum At least one in each district
    • Claims up to ₹20 lakh
These limits are the textbook's, under the 1986 Act. They were revised under the 2019 Act and its rules, and are now based on the value paid for the goods or services; check the current limits before filing.

Councils spread awareness; the three tiers (District, State, National) settle disputes. The book's limits: up to ₹20 lakh, ₹20 lakh to ₹1 crore, above ₹1 crore - limits under the old 1986 Act.

Worked example 1: which tier, by the textbook's limits?

Using only the 1986-Act limits given in the textbook: (a) a ₹45,000 refrigerator plus ₹10,000 compensation claimed; (b) a ₹30 lakh flat-booking dispute plus ₹5 lakh compensation; (c) a ₹1.5 crore hospital negligence claim. Working: (a) 45,000 + 10,000 = ₹55,000, below ₹20 lakh: District Forum. (b) 30 + 5 = ₹35 lakh, above ₹20 lakh but not above ₹1 crore: State Commission. (c) ₹1.5 crore, above ₹1 crore: National Commission.

Worked example 2: council or court?

(a) A body holds awareness camps on reading labels in every block of a district. (b) A body hears a complaint about a faulty motorcycle and orders the dealer to replace it. Reasoning: (a) spreads awareness and promotes rights, which is the work of a consumer protection council. (b) decides a dispute and passes an order, which is the work of a quasi-judicial redressal body (the District Forum in the book's terms).

Key takeaways: shortages, monopoly, ignorance, poverty and disunity leave Indian consumers open to exploitation; councils at three levels promote and protect rights; disputes go to three quasi-judicial tiers; the textbook's limits and names are those of the 1986 Act, since replaced by the 2019 Act.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which is NOT a reason the textbook gives for consumers being exploited in India?

    1. Shortage of many products
    2. Monopoly power of a few firms
    3. Lack of unity among consumers
    4. Too much competition among sellers
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book lists shortages, monopoly, ignorance of rights, poverty and lack of unity. Strong competition would usually help consumers, not exploit them.

  2. 2. The main object of consumer protection councils is to:

    1. decide consumer disputes
    2. promote and protect the rights of consumers
    3. fix the prices of goods
    4. punish traders with prison
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The councils spread awareness and, as the Act says, promote and protect consumers' rights. Disputes are decided by the quasi-judicial bodies.

  3. 3. Using the textbook's 1986-Act limits, a claim of ₹12 lakh would go to the:

    1. District Forum
    2. State Commission
    3. National Commission
    4. Supreme Court directly
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Under the book's limits the District Forum hears claims up to ₹20 lakh; ₹12 lakh is within that.

  4. 4. Why are consumer courts called quasi-judicial?

    1. They have no power to pass orders
    2. They are run by companies
    3. They work like courts and pass binding orders but with simpler procedure
    4. They only give advice
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Quasi-judicial bodies hear both sides and pass binding orders like courts, while following a simpler procedure than ordinary civil courts.

  5. 5. Which statement about the textbook's description of the redressal machinery is correct today?

    1. It is exactly the present law
    2. It describes the 1986 Act, which was replaced by the Consumer Protection Act, 2019
    3. Consumer courts no longer exist
    4. Only the National Commission remains
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The book describes the machinery under the 1986 Act. The 2019 Act replaced it, renaming the District Forum as a District Commission and revising money limits and other details.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → The District Forum

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery