• Practice
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Debentures and how they differ from shares

Define a debenture under section 2(30), explain its features, classify debentures by convertibility, security, redemption and registration, and distinguish debentures from shares.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define a debenture and list its features.
  • Classify debentures on four bases.
  • Distinguish debentures from shares.

When internal funds such as share capital and accumulated profits are not enough, a company turns to outside sources: external commercial borrowing, bank loans, public deposits and debentures. A debenture lets a company borrow from the public for a fixed period at a fixed rate of interest without increasing its share capital.

This lesson explains the law as the Tamil Nadu textbook presents it, for study. It is not legal advice; company law and rules are amended from time to time.

Meaning

A debenture is a certificate issued under the company's common seal acknowledging a loan. Section 2(30) of the Companies Act, 2013 says 'debenture' includes debenture stock, bonds or any other instrument evidencing a debt, whether or not it creates a charge on the company's assets, so it covers both secured and unsecured debentures. Debentures are offered to the public much like shares.

Features

  1. Issued as a certificate under the common seal.
  2. Debenture holders are creditors, not owners.
  3. They carry a fixed rate of interest.
  4. They are redeemed after a fixed period.
  5. They may be secured or unsecured.
  6. Interest is a charge against profit; the textbook notes it is an allowable business expense.
  7. Debenture holders have no voting rights.
  8. Interest is payable even if there is a loss.

Kinds of debentures

Classification of debentures

  • Convertibility
    • Non-convertible (NCD): remain debt
    • Partly convertible (PCD): part becomes equity
    • Fully convertible (FCD): all becomes equity
    • Optionally convertible (OCD): investor may choose
  • Security
    • Secured: charge on fixed assets
    • Unsecured: holders rank as unsecured creditors
  • Redemption
    • Redeemable: repaid on a date, on demand, after notice or by drawings
    • Perpetual (irredeemable): no repayment date while a going concern
  • Registration
    • Registered: holder's name in the register
    • Bearer: negotiable, passes by delivery

For convertible debentures the issuer decides the conversion ratio, usually at the time of subscription, and after conversion the investor has the same status as an ordinary shareholder. All debentures, redeemable or not, become payable when the company goes into liquidation. The textbook notes that after the 2013 Act a company cannot issue perpetual (irredeemable) debentures.

Debentures and shares compared

Based on the textbook's table
BasisDebenturesShares
NatureA loan to the companyPart of the company's capital
Holder's statusCreditorOwner (member)
ReturnFixed interest, with priority over dividendDividend that varies with profit and the board's decision
When payableEven if there is no profitOnly out of profits
Charge on assetsGenerally have oneNone
Issue at discountAllowedNot allowed (except sweat equity)
VotingNo voting rightVoting right (equity)
Treatment of returnInterest is a business expenseDividend is not a business expense

Shareholder = owner, variable dividend from profits, votes. Debenture holder = creditor, fixed interest even in a loss, no vote.

Worked example 1: interest in a loss year

Made-up: a company has 2,000 debentures of ₹1,000 each at 8% interest, and makes a loss this year. Working: interest = 2,000 × 1,000 × 8 ÷ 100 = ₹1,60,000. It must still be paid because debenture holders are creditors. No dividend can be paid to shareholders this year, because dividends come only out of profits.

Worked example 2: partly convertible debentures

Made-up: an investor holds 100 PCDs of ₹500 each; 40% of the face value is to be converted into equity shares of ₹10 at par. Working: total face value = 100 × 500 = ₹50,000. Converted portion = 50,000 × 40 ÷ 100 = ₹20,000, giving 20,000 ÷ 10 = 2,000 equity shares. The remaining ₹30,000 stays as debt and continues to earn interest.

Key takeaways: a debenture is an instrument evidencing a debt (section 2(30)), issued under the common seal, with fixed interest and no voting rights; debentures are classified by convertibility (NCD, PCD, FCD, OCD), security, redemption and registration; perpetual debentures cannot now be issued, the textbook notes; debenture holders are creditors paid even in a loss, shareholders are owners paid only from profits.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Debenture holders are:

    1. owners of the company
    2. creditors of the company
    3. directors
    4. employees
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A debenture is a loan, so its holders are creditors; shareholders are the owners.

  2. 2. Which debentures can never be converted into equity shares?

    1. Fully convertible debentures
    2. Partly convertible debentures
    3. Non-convertible debentures
    4. Optionally convertible debentures
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Non-convertible debentures retain their debt character and cannot be converted into equity.

  3. 3. Interest of 9% on ₹5,00,000 of debentures in a year when the company makes a loss is:

    1. ₹45,000 and must be paid
    2. nil, because there is a loss
    3. ₹45,000 but only from next year's profit
    4. ₹9,000
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 5,00,000 × 9 ÷ 100 = ₹45,000. Debenture interest is payable even if there is a loss.

  4. 4. Bearer debentures are transferable by:

    1. registration only
    2. a court order
    3. a special resolution
    4. mere delivery
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Bearer debentures are negotiable instruments and pass by mere delivery, like share warrants.

  5. 5. Which statement is correct?

    1. Shares carry a fixed interest
    2. Debenture holders have voting rights
    3. Shares cannot be issued at a discount, while debentures can
    4. Dividend is payable even if there is a loss
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook's table notes debentures can be issued at a discount while shares cannot (except sweat equity). The other statements reverse the true positions.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery