• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Voting, quorum and proxy

Explain the meaning of voting, the open methods (voice, show of hands) and secret methods (ballot, postal ballot), and the meaning of quorum and proxy.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain voting and the voting rights of members.
  • Compare open and secret methods of voting.
  • Explain quorum and the role of a proxy.

A resolution is only as valid as the vote that passed it. The word vote comes from the Latin votum, a wish: by voting, a member formally declares his opinion for or against a proposal or a candidate. Section 47 of the Companies Act, 2013 deals with the voting rights of members.

This lesson explains company law as the Tamil Nadu textbook presents it, corrected where the Companies Act, 2013 says otherwise, for study only. It is not legal advice; rules are amended from time to time.

Open procedure

  • By voice: the chairman asks members to say 'Yes' or 'No' and judges the result by the strength of the voices. The textbook calls it unscientific and unsuitable for complex issues.
  • By show of hands: members in favour raise their hands, then those against; the chairman counts and announces the result. Each member present has one vote, whatever the number of shares.

Secret procedure

  • By ballot: members receive serially numbered ballot papers, mark them in secret and drop them in a ballot box; the chairman opens the box before tellers or scrutinisers, rejects defective papers, counts and announces the result.
  • By postal ballot: used by large companies whose members are spread across the country. Serially numbered ballot papers are posted in sealed covers to members who cannot attend; they return them sealed, and the covers are opened when votes are counted.

Open and secret voting

  • Open
    • Voice
    • Show of hands
    • Quick, but no secrecy
    • One member, one vote on a show of hands
  • Secret
    • Ballot
    • Postal ballot
    • Secrecy of the voter maintained
    • Suited to vital issues and scattered members

Besides these methods described in the textbook, the Act also provides for a poll, where votes are counted according to the shares each member holds, and for electronic voting in specified companies. A show of hands therefore measures heads, while a poll measures shareholding.

Quorum

One person does not make a meeting. The quorum is the minimum number of members who must be present for the meeting to transact business validly. Business done without a quorum is not valid. (The Act fixes the quorum for general meetings according to the number of members, and the articles may fix a higher one.)

Proxy

A proxy is a person appointed by a member to attend and vote at a general meeting on the member's behalf; the proxy is the member's agent and need not be a member. The appointment is made in writing (the proxy form), which must reach the company at least 48 hours before the meeting. A proxy has no right to speak at the meeting and cannot vote on a show of hands; a proxy can vote on a poll. (The textbook simply says a proxy cannot vote; its own specimen proxy form appoints the proxy 'to vote for me', which is correct for a poll.)

Show of hands counts members; a poll counts shares. A proxy attends for a member, may vote on a poll, but may not speak.

Worked example 1: show of hands versus poll

Made-up: at a meeting of Pandian Agro Ltd, 30 members are present. 20 small shareholders holding 2,000 shares in all vote against a resolution; 10 members holding 18,000 shares vote for it. Working: on a show of hands: 10 for, 20 against, so it is defeated. On a poll: 18,000 for, 2,000 against, so it is passed. As an ordinary resolution on a poll, 18,000 > 2,000. It would even pass as a special resolution, since 18,000 ≥ 3 × 2,000 = 6,000.

Worked example 2: is the proxy valid?

Made-up: a meeting starts at 11 a.m. on 15 July. Kannan's proxy form reaches the company at 4 p.m. on 13 July; Latha's reaches at 3 p.m. on 14 July. Working: the deadline is 48 hours before, that is 11 a.m. on 13 July. Kannan's form arrived 5 hours after that, so it is too late; Latha's is also late. Neither proxy can act. Had a form arrived by 11 a.m. on 13 July, the proxy could attend and vote on a poll, but not speak.

Key takeaways: voting declares a member's wish; open methods are voice and show of hands, secret methods are ballot and postal ballot; the Act also provides for a poll, which counts shares; a quorum is the minimum attendance for valid business; a proxy, who need not be a member, is appointed by a form lodged 48 hours before the meeting, may vote on a poll but may not speak.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who is not entitled to speak at a general meeting of the company?

    1. A shareholder
    2. A director
    3. A proxy
    4. The auditor
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A proxy may attend and vote on a poll but has no right to speak; the textbook's exercise gives the same answer.

  2. 2. Members spread across the country who cannot attend can vote by:

    1. show of hands
    2. voice
    3. postal ballot
    4. quorum
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Postal ballot sends serially numbered ballot papers by post to members who cannot attend in person.

  3. 3. The minimum number of members who must be present for a meeting to transact valid business is called the:

    1. proxy
    2. quorum
    3. agenda
    4. ballot
    Show answer

    Answer: B. That minimum number is the quorum; without it business is not validly transacted.

  4. 4. A proxy form must reach the company at least how long before the meeting?

    1. 48 hours
    2. 7 days
    3. 24 hours
    4. 14 days
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook's specimen notice and proxy form say the form must be deposited not less than 48 hours before the meeting.

  5. 5. Which method gives each member present one vote, regardless of shares held?

    1. Poll
    2. Postal ballot by shares
    3. Weighted ballot
    4. Show of hands
    Show answer

    Answer: D. On a show of hands each member present has one vote; a poll counts votes according to shares held.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery