- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Environmental economics and the economy-environment link
Define environmental economics, ecosystem and environment, explain the material balance model of Kneese and Ayres, and describe environmental goods, environmental quality and the environment as a public good.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define environmental economics, ecosystem and environment.
- Explain the material balance model and use it in a simple calculation.
- Describe environmental goods and environmental quality.
- Explain why the environment is a public good and what the free-rider problem means.
Every factory, farm and household takes something from nature and gives something back, usually waste. Chapter 10 of the Tamil Nadu textbook studies these two-way links. Its opening idea, borrowed from the mountaineer Edmund Hillary, is that environmental problems are social problems: people cause them and people suffer from them.
Meaning of environmental economics
Environmental economics (EE) studies the interactions between human economic activity and the natural environment. It is the part of economics concerned with the efficient allocation of environmental resources. The environment gives us direct value (clean air, beauty) and raw materials for production, so economy and environment are interdependent. EE deals with conservation and valuation of natural resources, pollution control, waste management and recycling. Its key aim is to find the tools and policies that move the market towards the most efficient use of natural resources, weighing all costs and benefits.
An ecosystem is all the living things in an area (plants, animals, micro-organisms) interacting with one another and with their non-living surroundings (sun, soil, water, climate, atmosphere). Ecosystems are the foundations of the biosphere. Environment (from the French environner, to surround) means all the conditions, circumstances and influences surrounding and affecting the development of an organism or community: the physical, chemical and biological factors that shape its form and survival.
Linkage between economy and environment: the material balance model
The link is explained by the material balance model of Allen Kneese and Robert Ayres. It treats the whole economy as a physically balanced flow of inputs and outputs, based on the first law of thermodynamics (conservation of matter and energy): what goes in must come out. All materials taken from the environment eventually return to it as wastes, unless they are recycled for a while.
Material balance: the economy inside the environment
- Environment supplies raw materials (R) Renewable and non-renewable resources
- Producers make final goods (F) Production leaves waste W1
- Households consume F Consumption leaves waste W2
- Wastes return to the environment W1 + W2 = R, unless recycled; nature absorbs only up to a limit
Then back to step 1: Environment supplies raw materials (R)
Material balance: R = F + W1 and F = W2, so R = W1 + W2. In the long run, everything taken from nature returns to it as waste.
Worked example 1: balancing the materials (made-up tonnes)
A region's industries take in 1,000 tonnes of raw material in a year (R). Factories turn 700 tonnes into goods (F) and discard 300 tonnes as waste (W1). Step 1: R = F + W1 → 1,000 = 700 + 300, which balances. Step 2: households use the 700 tonnes of goods and eventually discard them (W2 = 700). Step 3: total waste = W1 + W2 = 300 + 700 = 1,000 tonnes = R. Step 4, with recycling: if 200 tonnes of household waste are recycled back to factories, fresh raw material needed next year falls to 1,000 − 200 = 800 tonnes, and waste discharged to nature falls to 1,000 − 200 = 800 tonnes.
The environment is both a supplier of resources and a sink that cleans up wastes. Its power to absorb waste is limited; the textbook warns that in many respects the earth has reached saturation.
Environmental goods and quality
Environmental goods are usually non-market goods: clean air and water, landscapes, footpaths and cycle ways, parks, rivers, mountains, forests and beaches. Environmental quality is the condition of the environment measured against the needs of people and other species. The textbook observes that it has been declining.
The environment as a pure public good
-
Non-rival
- One person's use does not reduce another's
- Everyone breathes the same air
-
Non-excludable
- No one can be kept out
- Hard to charge a price
-
Result
- Free-rider problem: people use it without paying
- Over-use and depletion
- Nature's contribution and its depletion are missing from national income accounts
Worked example 2: the free-rider problem (made-up village)
A village of 100 families shares a lake. Cleaning it costs ₹50,000 and is worth ₹1,000 to each family. Step 1: total benefit = 100 × 1,000 = ₹1,00,000, more than the cost, so cleaning is worthwhile for the village. Step 2: each family reasons that, if others pay, it will enjoy the clean lake anyway, since no one can be excluded. Step 3: if every family waits for others, nothing is collected and the lake stays dirty. Solution: a collective decision, such as a panchayat levy of 50,000 ÷ 100 = ₹500 per family, which is less than the ₹1,000 benefit to each.
Key takeaways: environmental economics studies the efficient use of environmental resources and the two-way link between economy and environment. The material balance model (Kneese and Ayres) shows that inputs from nature equal wastes returned to it (R = W1 + W2). Environmental goods are mostly non-market, and the environment is a non-rival, non-excludable public good, which invites free riding and over-use.
Check your understanding
-
1. The material balance model linking economy and environment was developed by:
- Keynes and Friedman
- Adam Smith and Ricardo
- Allen Kneese and Robert Ayres
- Pearce and Barbier
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook credits the material balance model to Allen Kneese and Robert Ayres.
-
2. The material balance principle rests on which law?
- The first law of thermodynamics (conservation of matter and energy)
- The law of diminishing returns
- Say's law of markets
- The law of demand
Show answer
Answer: A. 'What goes in must come out' is the conservation of matter and energy, the first law of thermodynamics.
-
3. Made-up data: R = 800 tonnes and F = 550 tonnes. Waste from production W1 is:
- 1,350 tonnes
- 550 tonnes
- 800 tonnes
- 250 tonnes
Show answer
Answer: D. R = F + W1, so W1 = 800 − 550 = 250 tonnes.
-
4. A pure public good is one that is:
- rival and excludable
- non-rival and non-excludable
- sold only in markets
- rival but non-excludable
Show answer
Answer: B. Its use by one person does not reduce others' use (non-rival) and no one can be excluded, which causes the free-rider problem.
-
5. Which is an environmental good in the textbook's sense?
- A packet of biscuits
- A public beach
- A car
- A mobile phone
Show answer
Answer: B. Environmental goods are usually non-market goods such as clean air, rivers, forests, parks and beaches.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.