• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Keynes's critique and the principle of effective demand

State the criticisms of Say's Law, explain why Keynes's theory is a short-run general theory, and describe effective demand and its determinants: consumption (income and MPC) and investment (interest rate and MEC).

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • List Keynes's criticisms of Say's Law.
  • Explain why Keynes's theory is a short-run, general theory.
  • Define effective demand and trace its determinants.

The Great Depression of the 1930s did not fit the classical picture: goods stayed unsold and millions were jobless for years. Keynes's General Theory (1936) explained why, and changed economics.

Criticisms of Say's Law

  1. Supply does not create its own demand when demand does not rise as fast as production.
  2. The automatic adjustment process does not remove unemployment; a higher rate of investment does.
  3. Money is not neutral: individuals hold money for unforeseen needs and businesses keep cash reserves.
  4. General overproduction is possible.
  5. Full employment is a special case; capitalist economies often have underemployment.
  6. State intervention is needed when there is general overproduction and mass unemployment.

Features of Keynes's theory

Keynes argued against the classical belief that market forces always restore equilibrium. His theory is a general theory because it explains every situation: full employment and also less than full employment (underemployment). It is a short-run theory: capital equipment, labour supply, technology and efficiency of labour are taken as unchanged while employment is determined.

Effective demand

The starting point of Keynes's theory is the principle of effective demand: the money actually spent by people on the products of industry, on consumption and on investment. Since that money is paid out as rent, wages, interest and profit, effective demand equals national income, which equals national output. A rise in effective demand raises employment; a fall causes unemployment.

ED = Y = C + I = Output = Employment. Effective demand is the point where aggregate demand equals aggregate supply.

What determines effective demand

  • Consumption (C)
    • Level of income
    • Marginal propensity to consume: consumption rises when income rises, but by less
  • Investment (I)
    • Rate of interest: depends on money supply and liquidity preference
    • Marginal efficiency of capital: depends on prospective yield and supply price of the capital asset
  • Liquidity preference motives
    • Transaction
    • Precautionary
    • Speculative

Investment takes place when the marginal efficiency of capital (the expected rate of return on a new capital good over its cost) exceeds the rate of interest. Chapter 4 studies these functions in detail.

Worked example 1: when saving leaks out

Made-up: output = ₹500 crore, households consume ₹430 crore and save ₹70 crore, but firms, gloomy about sales, invest only ₹40 crore. Step 1, effective demand: C + I = 430 + 40 = ₹470 crore. Step 2, gap: 500 − 470 = ₹30 crore of goods unsold. Keynes's conclusion: firms cut output and employment; income falls until saving equals the ₹40 crore of investment. Supply did not create its own demand.

Worked example 2: the MPC at work

Made-up: the MPC is 0.75. Income rises from ₹1,000 crore to ₹1,200 crore. Step 1: ΔY = 200. Step 2: ΔC = MPC × ΔY = 0.75 × 200 = ₹150 crore. Step 3: extra saving = 200 − 150 = ₹50 crore. Answer: consumption rises by less than income, exactly as Keynes stated, so investment must fill the ₹50 crore gap if all new output is to be sold.

Worked example 3: will a firm invest?

Made-up: a machine is expected to return 12 per cent a year over its cost (MEC = 12 per cent). Case A: interest rate 9 per cent; 12 > 9, so investment is profitable and takes place. Case B: interest rate 14 per cent; 12 < 14, so borrowing to buy it would lose money; no investment. Answer: investment, and through it effective demand, depends on comparing MEC with the interest rate.

Key takeaways: Keynes rejected Say's Law: demand can fall short of supply, money is held, and unemployment can persist, so the state may need to act. His short-run general theory starts from effective demand (C + I), which equals national income and determines employment. Consumption depends on income and MPC; investment on the rate of interest and MEC.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Keynes's theory is called a 'general' theory because it:

    1. covers only full employment
    2. applies only to socialist economies
    3. explains both full employment and underemployment situations
    4. ignores money
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Classical theory dealt only with full employment; Keynes's theory explains every level of employment, including underemployment.

  2. 2. In Keynes's theory, effective demand is equal to:

    1. national income
    2. money supply
    3. exports
    4. government revenue
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Money spent on output is paid out as rent, wages, interest and profit, so effective demand equals national income and national output.

  3. 3. Made-up: MPC = 0.6 and income rises by ₹500 crore. Consumption rises by:

    1. ₹500 crore
    2. ₹200 crore
    3. ₹600 crore
    4. ₹300 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: D. ΔC = 0.6 × 500 = 300. The remaining ₹200 crore is extra saving.

  4. 4. Which is NOT one of the three motives of liquidity preference?

    1. Transaction motive
    2. Profit motive
    3. Precautionary motive
    4. Speculative motive
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Keynes's three motives for holding money are transaction, precautionary and speculative. The profit motive belongs to capitalism, not to liquidity preference.

  5. 5. Made-up: MEC = 8 per cent, interest rate = 10 per cent. What happens?

    1. Investment is not undertaken, because the expected return is below the cost of borrowing
    2. Investment rises
    3. Consumption falls to zero
    4. Saving equals zero
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Investment is made only when MEC exceeds the interest rate. Here 8 < 10, so the project would lose money.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery