- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Political geography: nation, state, boundaries and geopolitics
Distinguish nation, state and nation-state, compare frontiers and boundaries, apply the genetic classification of boundaries, and explain Mackinder's Heartland theory, the Rimland idea and the move towards a multipolar world.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish a nation, a state and a nation-state.
- Compare frontiers with boundaries and classify boundaries genetically.
- Explain Mackinder's Heartland theory, its critique, and the idea of a multipolar world.
Political geography studies how power is organised over space: how territories are defined, how borders are drawn and how location and resources affect relations between countries.
Nation, state and nation-state
Three political ideas
-
Nation
- A people who see themselves as one
- Bound by shared history, language, religion or culture
- Socially constructed; can change over time
-
State
- An independent, sovereign territory
- A government controls a clearly bounded area
- Borders recognised by other states
-
Nation-state
- A nation and a state coincide
- Shared national identity
- Defined borders and a single government
Nations have been called imagined communities, held together by ideas of unity around religion, ethnicity, language or culture. The textbook mentions Vaishali, a republic by the 6th century BCE, as one of the world's earliest republics.
Frontiers and boundaries
| Frontier | Boundary |
|---|---|
| A zone or area | A line |
| Usually natural: mountains, deserts, marshes, often thinly inhabited | Mostly drawn by people |
| Generally no political dispute | Often disputed by rival countries |
| Dynamic | Static: once fixed, rarely changes |
A frontier is a politico-geographical area beyond the defined limits of a political unit into which expansion could occur. By about 1900 frontiers had almost disappeared, replaced by boundaries. A boundary is a line marking the recognised limit of a political or administrative unit. The textbook notes that China touches 14 countries (Russia also has 14 land neighbours) and that the Canada-USA land border, about 8,893 km, is the world's longest.
Genetic classification of boundaries
- Antecedent: drawn before the cultural landscape developed, so usually non-contentious; for example many state boundaries of the USA.
- Subsequent: drawn after cultural regions had developed, often irregular and following cultural divides; for example many boundaries in Europe.
- Superimposed: imposed across a culturally uniform region, so people of one ethnic group end up on both sides; boundaries drawn by colonial powers across Africa are a standard example.
- Relict: no longer functions but survives in the landscape or in history, such as the former boundary between East and West Germany.
Geopolitics and Mackinder's Heartland
Geopolitics studies how territory, population, location and natural resources, as modified by economics and technology, affect relations between states. In 1904 Halford Mackinder described history as a struggle between land powers and sea powers and argued that the age of sea power was ending. He divided the world into three tiers:
Mackinder's three tiers
-
Heartland (pivot area)
- Interior of Eurasia with Arctic and inland drainage
- Natural fortress closed to sea power
- Open only from Eastern Europe
-
Inner or marginal crescent
- Lands of Europe and Asia around the Heartland
- Africa north of the Sahara
-
Outer or insular crescent
- The Americas, Africa south of the Sahara, Australia
- Also Britain and Japan
Mackinder's dictum: who rules East Europe commands the Heartland; who rules the Heartland commands the World Island; who rules the World Island commands the World.
The textbook notes that the theory made sense in 1904, before strong air and naval power, but does not hold well today. A later American geographer, Nicholas Spykman, argued the opposite: that the Rimland, the coastal belt of Eurasia around the Heartland, with its large populations and resources, was the real key to world power. The textbook's map shows both the Heartland and the Rimland.
A multipolar world
The textbook describes a shift from a unipolar world, dominated by one superpower, towards a multipolar world with several centres of power. It mentions groupings and institutions such as BRICS and its New Development Bank, the SCO, ASEAN and SAARC, debates about reforming bodies such as the UN, IMF and World Bank, the importance of sea lanes and chokepoints such as the Strait of Malacca and the Suez Canal, and large connectivity projects such as China's Belt and Road (One Belt One Road). Its closing message is that geography sets the limits within which human choices work.
Worked example 1: classify the boundary
A straight boundary along a line of latitude, surveyed when the area had few settlers: antecedent. A winding border that follows the edge of a language region in Europe: subsequent. A colonial line that splits one ethnic group between two countries: superimposed. A line that no longer divides two states but survives as a historic line: relict.
Worked example 2: apply Mackinder's logic
Why did Mackinder think the Heartland was safe from sea powers? Step 1, its northern seas are frozen for much of the year, so navies cannot enter. Step 2, deserts, plateaus and high mountains guard its south. Step 3, it had large resources and did not depend on outside trade. Step 4, its only open side was Eastern Europe. Conclusion: control of Eastern Europe meant control of a self-sufficient fortress. Air power, missiles and modern navies weaken this logic today.
Key takeaways: a nation is a people, a state is a sovereign territory, a nation-state joins the two. Frontiers are zones; boundaries are lines, classified as antecedent, subsequent, superimposed or relict. Mackinder's 1904 Heartland theory and Spykman's Rimland idea are classic geopolitical views; today's world is described as moving towards multipolarity.
Check your understanding
-
1. A clearly bounded, sovereign territory with its own government and internationally recognised borders is a:
- nation
- frontier
- state
- culture region
Show answer
Answer: C. A state is an independent, sovereign region whose government controls a defined, recognised territory.
-
2. Which describes a frontier rather than a boundary?
- A line agreed by treaty
- An area or zone, usually natural and thinly inhabited
- A static line that rarely changes
- Often disputed by rival countries
Show answer
Answer: B. A frontier is an areal, natural and dynamic zone; a boundary is a line, mostly drawn by people and often disputed.
-
3. A boundary drawn before the area was settled, such as many US state boundaries, is:
- antecedent
- subsequent
- superimposed
- relict
Show answer
Answer: A. Antecedent boundaries were drawn before the cultural landscape developed and are usually non-contentious.
-
4. In Mackinder's scheme, Britain and Japan belong to the:
- Heartland
- inner or marginal crescent
- Rimland only
- outer or insular crescent
Show answer
Answer: D. Because of their insularity from Eurasia, Mackinder placed Britain and Japan in the outer or insular crescent with the Americas, Africa south of the Sahara and Australia.
-
5. According to Mackinder, the only open gateway to the Heartland was:
- Eastern Europe
- the Arctic Ocean
- the Himalaya
- the Iranian Plateau
Show answer
Answer: A. Frozen seas, deserts, plateaus and mountains closed the Heartland on other sides; Eastern Europe was its gateway.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.