• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Counter-Reformation and the rise of nation-states

Explain the Catholic Counter-Reformation - the Society of Jesus, the Council of Trent and the Inquisition - and its effects, then explain how the decline of feudalism and of Church power helped Spain, England and France become nation-states.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the Society of Jesus, the Council of Trent and the Inquisition as parts of the Counter-Reformation.
  • Explain the causes of the rise of new monarchies: the decline of feudalism and of the Church's power.
  • Describe how Spain, England and France became nation-states.

The textbook's account of the sixteenth century ends with the Catholic Church's response to the Reformation and with the growth of strong kingdoms. The book describes the Counter-Reformation as the attempt of loyal churchmen to reform the Church from within, while also acting firmly against the Protestant protest.

The Society of Jesus

On 15 August 1534, in Paris, the Spaniard Ignatius of Loyola and six university students vowed chastity, poverty and obedience and a pilgrimage to Jerusalem. One of them was Francis Xavier, later a missionary in India and Japan. The Society of Jesus trained people for dedicated service of the Roman Church and the Pope, used education to teach the Catholic faith, and set up many educational institutions. Its priests, the Jesuits, the book says, raised the standard of the Church in Europe.

Reform within the Church

The Church's measures, the book says, were to remove abuses, reassert the Pope's authority and renew faith in the seven sacraments: Baptism, Confirmation, the Eucharist (Holy Communion), Reconciliation (Confession), Anointing of the Sick, Holy Orders and Marriage. Three events mark the Counter-Reformation: the Council of Trent, the Inquisition, and new religious schools.

The Council of Trent (1545-1563), called by Pope Paul III, met three times in eighteen years. It stressed faith in the Bible and Church teaching and the seven sacraments for salvation; upheld the celibacy of priests and the supremacy of the Pope; removed abuses such as the sale of indulgences, nepotism and the absence of bishops from their dioceses; required the study of the catechism; and supported images of Jesus and Mary in churches. The book says the Catholic Church became better organised as a result.

The Inquisition set up special Church courts to punish those judged heretics, with punishments ranging from forced recantation and flogging to burning at the stake; the Roman Inquisition was set up to deal with Protestants. The book also describes witch-hunts, in which women, usually widowed or single, were blamed for crop failures and disease and put to death, and gives an estimate of about 110,000 people tried and 60,000 put to death.

The Counter-Reformation (as the textbook describes it)

  • Society of Jesus (1534)
    • Ignatius of Loyola
    • Francis Xavier
    • Education to spread Catholic teaching
  • Council of Trent (1545-1563)
    • Seven sacraments affirmed
    • Celibacy and papal supremacy upheld
    • Abuses such as the sale of indulgences removed
  • Inquisition
    • Church courts against heresy
    • Witch-hunts
  • Effects
    • Europe divided by religion
    • Thirty Years' War (1618-1648)
    • Both sides used education

The effects: Europe was divided along religious lines, and wars broke out within and between countries, such as the Thirty Years' War (1618-1648) in the Holy Roman Empire. Protestant churches were plain, while Catholic churches became more ornamented, and both used education to spread their teachings.

Why new monarchies rose

Under feudalism, kings granted nobles tax-free lands (fiefs) and titles in return for military service. Kings were at the mercy of nobles who had their own vassals and armies and might side with the king's enemies. The book explains that feudalism declined because the plague killed many peasants, so nobles lost labour and taxes; many nobles died in the Crusades; and new warfare, using gunpowder and the English longbow, made mounted knights less important.

The Church, too, had been more powerful than kings: it held vast tax-free lands, collected the tithe (10% of produce), had its own ecclesiastical courts that royal courts could not overrule, and could excommunicate rulers - as Pope Gregory VII did to Henry IV of Germany. But the Black Death weakened the Church, which could not explain its causes, and the Pope's authority was increasingly challenged.

Three nation-states

How Spain, England and France became nation-states (from the textbook)
CountryKey rulersHow royal power was built
SpainFerdinand of Aragon and Isabella of Castile (joint rule from 1479)Marriage united Aragon and Castile; they drove out the Moors, kept nobles out of the royal councils, and grew rich from the Americas
EnglandHenry VII (1485-1509), first Tudor kingVictory in the Wars of the Roses; marriage to Elizabeth of York; ended livery and maintenance; Star Chamber court; marriage alliances with Scotland and Spain
FranceCharles VII; Louis XIVictory in the Hundred Years' War; Burgundy brought under control (about 1483); a permanent royal army; lawyers rather than nobles in the Royal Council

In Spain, the book records that Ferdinand and Isabella, devout Catholics, forced Muslims (Moors) and Jews to convert to Christianity and set up the Spanish Inquisition to watch the converts; many were tried, tortured and burnt. In England, livery (badges or uniforms for a noble's followers) and maintenance (a noble's protection of his followers) supported private armies, which Henry VII abolished; the Star Chamber, named after the stars painted on its ceiling in Westminster Palace, tried cases involving nobles. In France, Joan of Arc helped Charles VII win at Orleans and was called the Maid of Orleans; captured by the English, she was condemned as a witch and burnt (the book gives 1430; she was executed in 1431), and she was declared a saint in 1920.

Worked example 1: explaining the decline of feudalism

Question: Why did feudalism decline? Point 1 (population): the plague killed many peasants, so nobles lost workers and taxes. Point 2 (war): many nobles died in the Crusades, and gunpowder and the longbow made knights less useful. Point 3 (result): kings no longer depended so much on nobles, and new monarchies could assert themselves.

Worked example 2: Trent versus Luther

Compare: Luther accepted two sacraments (baptism and Holy Communion), allowed priests to marry and rejected papal authority. Step 1: the Council of Trent affirmed seven sacraments. Step 2: it upheld priestly celibacy. Step 3: it upheld the supremacy of the Pope. So Trent reformed abuses but kept the teachings the Protestants had rejected.

Counter-Reformation: Society of Jesus (1534), Council of Trent (1545-1563), the Inquisition. New monarchies: Spain (Ferdinand and Isabella), England (Henry VII), France (Louis XI).

— Unit 10, sections 10.4-10.5

Key takeaways: the Catholic Church answered the Reformation with the Jesuits, the Council of Trent and the Inquisition, leaving Europe divided by religion; feudalism and Church power declined through plague, war and new weapons; and Spain, England and France became strong nation-states under rulers who curbed their nobles.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who founded the Society of Jesus in Paris in 1534?

    1. Francis Xavier
    2. Pope Paul III
    3. Ignatius of Loyola
    4. John Calvin
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Spaniard Ignatius of Loyola and six students took their vows on 15 August 1534; Francis Xavier was one of the students.

  2. 2. Which of these did the Council of Trent uphold?

    1. The sale of indulgences
    2. Marriage of priests
    3. Only two sacraments
    4. The supremacy of the Pope
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Council upheld papal supremacy and priestly celibacy, affirmed seven sacraments, and removed abuses such as the sale of indulgences.

  3. 3. Which war does the book give as an example of the religious division of Europe?

    1. The Hundred Years' War
    2. The Thirty Years' War (1618-1648)
    3. The Wars of the Roses
    4. The Crusades
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Thirty Years' War, fought in the Holy Roman Empire between 1618 and 1648, is the book's example of wars arising from religious division.

  4. 4. What was the Star Chamber?

    1. A court created by Henry VII to try cases involving nobles, named after stars painted on its ceiling
    2. Henry VIII's Anglican council
    3. The Spanish Inquisition's court
    4. Louis XI's Royal Council
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The book says Henry VII created the Star Chamber court to put rebellious nobles on trial; it met in a room of Westminster Palace with stars painted on the ceiling.

  5. 5. Which pope excommunicated Henry IV of Germany?

    1. Leo X
    2. Alexander VI
    3. Paul III
    4. Gregory VII
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book gives Pope Gregory VII's excommunication of Henry IV of Germany as an example of the Church's power over kings.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery