- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Europe after Napoleon and the first socialists
Explain how Napoleon fell and how the Congress of Vienna and the Concert of Europe restored the old order, describe factory workers' lives, and compare the early and Utopian socialists: Saint-Simon, Fourier, Owen, Proudhon and Louis Blanc.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Outline Napoleon's fall and the settlement made by the Congress of Vienna (1815).
- Explain the role of Metternich and the Concert of Europe in suppressing liberal and national movements.
- Describe the ideas of the early and Utopian socialists, Proudhon and Louis Blanc.
Nineteenth-century Europe followed France's lead. The Austrian statesman Metternich, who stood for the old monarchies, is famously reported to have said that when France sneezes, Europe catches a cold - and France 'sneezed' three times, in 1789, 1830 and 1848. This chapter of the Tamil Nadu textbook traces the ideas and struggles of that century: socialism, Chartism, the revolutions of 1830 and 1848, the unification of Italy and Germany, and the Long Depression. We begin with the fall of Napoleon and the reaction that followed.
The fall of Napoleon
The book says the energies and ideals of the revolution were destroyed by Napoleon Bonaparte, whose reign was for some years a career of victory. But he never won command of the sea: in 1805 the British crushed his fleets. Spain rose against him in 1808, and a British army under Wellington drove the French out of the peninsula. In 1812 he invaded Russia with a great army (600,000 men, says the book) and was beaten back. He abdicated in 1814 and was exiled to Elba, returned for a last attempt in 1815, was defeated at Waterloo in Belgium by British, Belgian and Prussian forces, and was exiled to St Helena in the South Atlantic, where he died in 1821.
Napoleon's fall
- 1805 British destroy his fleets; no command of the sea.
- 1808 Spain rises; Wellington drives the French out.
- 1812 Invasion of Russia fails.
- 1814 Abdication; exile to Elba.
- 1815 Return; defeat at Waterloo.
- 1821 Death in exile on St Helena.
The Congress of Vienna and the Concert of Europe
An uneasy peace followed for nearly forty years. The book names two reasons it broke down into the wars of 1854-1871: the restored monarchs again aimed at absolute power and brought back privileges the revolution had abolished; and the diplomats at the Congress of Vienna (1815) drew boundaries that ignored nationality. Napoleon had reduced Italy to three political divisions; Vienna created eight states and handed northern Italy to Austria. Germany became a German Confederation of states with a Diet presided over by Austria (the book gives 38 states in one place and 39 in another; 39 is the usual figure).
To keep this order, the great powers - Austria, Prussia, Russia and Britain - formed the Concert of Europe, which claimed to preserve the balance of power but in practice intervened against internal rebellions during the Metternich Era (1815-1848). Metternich also organised a Holy Alliance of monarchies to suppress democratic and national movements. Popular revolts in Naples (1820) were crushed with Austrian troops and in Spain with French troops. Yet the American and French Revolutions had made democracy and liberty known, and liberals kept working for them - though, the book notes, democracy alone offered no answer to poverty or class conflict.
The new working class
The Industrial Revolution ended the domestic system and made workers live near factories in long rows of tenements. Wages were very low, working days ran to fifteen or even eighteen hours, and women and children were employed in large numbers, while a small class of capitalists sought profit. Unorganised workers were at their employers' mercy, so they began forming trade unions. Governments first declared unions illegal and jailed or banished leaders, but in 1824 unions were legalised in Britain. With them came the idea of an alternative to capitalism: socialism.
Early and Utopian socialists
Socialist ideas in the modern sense first came from thinkers studying how food and goods were produced and shared. Morelly, in Code de la Nature (1755), condemned private property and proposed a communistic society. François Babeuf, an agitator of the revolutionary years, felt the revolution had ignored peasants and workers and called for common ownership of land.
The first socialists were not revolutionaries. They designed model communities in which the means of production would be owned in common, everyone would work at assigned tasks and share the results, and there would be no poverty or unemployment; several hundred such communes were set up in Europe and the USA. Marx and Engels later called them 'Utopian Socialists'.
| Thinker | Background | Main ideas |
|---|---|---|
| Saint-Simon (1760-1825) | French aristocrat who fought against the British in the American war | Faith in science and progress; scientists should replace priests in the social order; property owners could keep power only by funding knowledge; *New Christianity* urged concern for the poor |
| Charles Fourier (1772-1837) | French Utopian socialist | Social conditions cause misery; everyone should have a basic minimum; rejected 'original sin'; harmony is the law of nature and society; self-contained cooperative communities called phalanstères sharing profit and loss |
| Robert Owen (1771-1858) | Humanitarian factory owner (Manchester; the model mills of New Lanark) | Reformed his own factories and employed no child under 10; *A New View of Society* urged national education, public works for the unemployed and Poor Law reform; his efforts helped pass the Factory Act of 1819; cooperative communities; Grand National Consolidated Trades Union (1834) |
| Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (1809-1865) | French anarchist from the working class | 'What is Property?' declared property theft; all government oppressive; replace the nation-state with federations of self-governing communes; influenced Bakunin |
| Louis Blanc (1811-1882) | French socialist; started the *Revue du Progrès* (1839) | 'Organisation of Labour': state-financed, worker-controlled social workshops guaranteeing work for all; socialism needs state power; in 1848 got the provisional government to open workshops for the unemployed |
Anarchism, as the book defines it, is the belief that the state should be abolished and society organised on a voluntary, cooperative basis without force. Proudhon's followers issued the Manifesto of the Sixty (1864), saying 1789 had brought political but not economic equality and that workers should represent themselves. Bakunin, influenced by Proudhon, wanted to overthrow the state through a general strike. The Poor Laws, codified in England in 1597-98, gave relief to the old, sick and infant poor and work in workhouses to the able-bodied unemployed.
Two routes to a fairer society
-
Proudhon (anarchist)
- The state is oppressive
- Replace it with federations of communes
- Labour as the basis of society
-
Louis Blanc (state socialist)
- Socialism needs state power
- State-financed social workshops
- Work guaranteed for everyone
Worked example 1: matching a thinker to a scheme
Question: a scheme proposes self-contained cooperative communities in which profits and losses are shared equally. A second proposes workshops paid for by the state but run by the workers. Whose ideas are these? Working: 'self-contained cooperative' communities with shared profit and loss are the phalanstères of Fourier; state finance with worker control is Louis Blanc's 'social workshops'. Answer: Fourier and Louis Blanc. Note the difference: Fourier's communities stand apart from the state, while Blanc relies on it.
Worked example 2: why call them 'Utopian'?
Question: why did Marx and Engels call Saint-Simon, Fourier and Owen 'Utopian'? Working: a utopia is an ideal society that exists only as a plan. These thinkers hoped to persuade people, including the rich, to build model communities by example; they did not rely on a class struggle. Marx and Engels claimed their own analysis of history and class conflict was 'scientific'. Answer: the label marks the difference between idealistic plans for change by goodwill and example, and a theory that change would come from the conflict of classes.
Congress of Vienna (1815): old monarchies restored, boundaries drawn without regard to nationality. Utopian socialists: Saint-Simon, Fourier (phalanstères), Owen (New Lanark, cooperatives). Proudhon: anarchism. Louis Blanc: state-financed social workshops.
Key takeaways: after Napoleon's defeat, the Congress of Vienna and Metternich's Concert of Europe restored monarchs and crushed revolts, ignoring national feeling. Meanwhile factory workers lived in misery, unions were legalised in 1824, and thinkers searched for alternatives to capitalism - from the model communities of the Utopians to Proudhon's anarchism and Louis Blanc's state-financed workshops.
Check your understanding
-
1. Where was Napoleon exiled for the first time, in 1814?
- St Helena
- Corsica
- Elba
- Waterloo
Show answer
Answer: C. After abdicating in 1814 Napoleon was exiled to Elba. After his defeat at Waterloo (1815) he was sent to St Helena, where he died in 1821.
-
2. Why does the book say the peace settlement of 1815 prepared the way for later wars?
- It restored absolute monarchs and drew boundaries that ignored nationality
- It gave Germany and Italy national unity too early
- It abolished all monarchies in Europe
- It gave Britain control of the continent
Show answer
Answer: A. The book names two factors: restored rulers aimed at absolute power again, and the Congress of Vienna's boundaries disregarded the principle of nationality (for example, northern Italy was handed to Austria).
-
3. In which year were labour unions legalised in Britain?
- 1815
- 1819
- 1834
- 1824
Show answer
Answer: D. Unions were at first declared illegal, but in 1824 they were legalised. 1819 is the Factory Act; 1834 is Owen's Grand National Consolidated Trades Union and the Tolpuddle case.
-
4. Which Utopian socialist proposed cooperative communities called phalanstères?
- Saint-Simon
- Charles Fourier
- Robert Owen
- Louis Blanc
Show answer
Answer: B. Charles Fourier envisaged harmonious self-contained cooperative communities called phalanstères with equal sharing of profit and loss.
-
5. Which thinker argued that socialism could not be achieved without state power?
- Proudhon
- Louis Blanc
- Bakunin
- Fourier
Show answer
Answer: B. Louis Blanc proposed state-financed, worker-controlled social workshops and argued that socialism needs state power. Proudhon and Bakunin, as anarchists, opposed the state; Fourier relied on voluntary communities.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.