- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Liberation struggles in Indonesia and the Philippines
Explain how nationalism grew under Dutch rule in Indonesia and under Spanish and American rule in the Philippines, the impact of Japanese occupation, and how Indonesia (1949) and the Philippines (1946) became independent.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe Dutch rule in the East Indies and the rise of Boedi Oetomo, Sarekat Islam, the Communists and Sukarno's Nationalist Party.
- Explain how Indonesia won independence after the Second World War.
- Trace the Philippine struggle from Spanish rule and the Spanish-American War to independence in 1946.
Mao's victory, following India's independence, showed that imperialism could be defeated. In Southeast Asia nationalism was still young before the twentieth century, but three and a half years of Japanese occupation destroyed the prestige of the European colonial powers. When they returned in 1945, the book says, they found that ruling as before was unrealistic and tried instead to hand power to friendly, moderate nationalists who could block communism. The book studies two cases: Indonesia, a Dutch colony, and the Philippines, an American one.
The Dutch East Indies
The Dutch held parts of Java and Sumatra from the seventeenth century and conquered the outer islands in the second half of the nineteenth. They wanted economic, not political, control: most people fished and farmed, many worked on European sugar, tobacco, tea and coffee plantations, and the discovery of oil made the colony still more valuable. Nationalism came later here than in the Philippines because the Dutch were slow to introduce Western education. The book also notes that the Dutch accepted Eurasians into their society, so Eurasians saw their interests as Dutch - unlike the Philippines, where Eurasians led the national movement.
| Year | Development in Indonesia |
|---|---|
| 1903-04 | Decentralisation Law and provincial councils - but no part for Indonesians |
| 1908 | Boedi Oetomo ('High Endeavour'), the first native political society, founded by medical students guided by Wahidin Sudirohusodo; mainly cultural, of Javanese civil servants and students |
| 1910s | Sarekat Islam (Muslim Union), formed to resist Chinese economic power, became socialist and nationalist; demanded self-government in 1916; membership rose from 350,000 to two and a half million in two years, says the book |
| 1918 | The Dutch created a People's Council, the Volksraad, at Batavia (Jakarta); it lasted until 1942 |
| 1919-20 | Communists, failing to capture Sarekat Islam, formed the Indonesian Communist Party |
| 1926-27 | Communist-led uprising in western Java and Sumatra crushed; thousands imprisoned |
| Late 1920s | Sukarno, a young engineer, founded the Indonesian Nationalist Party, backed by the Westernised secular middle class; police raids followed, Sukarno was jailed and the party dissolved (1931) |
In the Depression years the Dutch answered unemployment, wage cuts and protest with repression and censorship, and Sukarno and others were in prison until 1942, when the Dutch surrendered the East Indies to Japan (March 1942). Some Indonesians organised secret resistance; others, led by Sukarno and Hatta, believed supporting Japan was the best route to independence. Late in the war Japan agreed to discuss independence, and Sukarno and Hatta proclaimed it in August 1945.
After Japan's withdrawal, under the Potsdam decisions, British forces landed in September 1945 and released about 200,000 prisoners of war, mainly Dutch. The Dutch reoccupied most islands except Java and Sumatra, where Sukarno ruled as president, and refused to recognise him. British-arranged talks produced a Dutch-Indonesian Agreement: the Dutch recognised Java and Sumatra as an independent republic, to join the other islands in a federation, the United States of Indonesia. The Dutch twice tried to overturn the peace, but world opinion, led by Jawaharlal Nehru, and the UN Security Council forced a settlement. A round table conference at The Hague adopted a constitution, and in December 1949 Indonesia became independent.
Indonesia's road to independence
- 1908 Boedi Oetomo.
- 1916 Sarekat Islam demands self-government.
- 1926-27 Communist rising crushed.
- 1931 Sukarno's party dissolved; leaders jailed.
- 1942-45 Japanese occupation.
- 1945-49 Dutch return; agreement; world pressure; Hague conference.
- December 1949 Indonesia independent.
The Philippines
The Philippines, about 7,000 islands named after the Spanish prince Philip, son of Charles V, came under Spanish rule after Miguel López de Legazpi's expedition of 1565. Spain ruled for over 300 years, imposing its language, culture and religion. Filipino nationalism developed earlier than elsewhere in the region. The brutal crushing of the Cavite uprising (20 January 1872) of Filipino troops and workers at the Cavite arsenal, and the public execution of three priests - Jose Burgos, Jacinto Zamora and Mariano Gomez - made them martyrs of the national cause.
The Spanish-American War grew out of US interest in Cuba. Although Spain had decided to give Cuba limited self-government, the US Congress demanded the withdrawal of Spanish forces and authorised force; the USA declared war on 25 April 1898 and won easily. By the Treaty of Paris (10 December 1898) Spain gave up Cuba, ceded Guam and Puerto Rico to the USA and transferred the Philippines to it. Meanwhile Emilio Aguinaldo and the Cavite rebels had driven the Spanish out of many areas; after a victory at Alapan in May 1898 he raised the Philippine flag for the first time, and under the Malolos Constitution he became the first president of the republic. It lasted until the Americans captured him on 23 March 1901.
The nationalists found they had exchanged one master for another and turned to guerrilla war. Under pressure from a lobby in the USA, the American government set up representative institutions early: English-language education, an examination-based civil service, provincial courts, elected local governments and an elected national legislature, in which the Nationalist Party won a majority of the 80-member Assembly. Its leader Quezon declared that Filipinos would prefer to rule themselves even in hell rather than be ruled by others in heaven. The Communist Party (PKP), founded in 1930, was banned, but communist pressure helped push the USA to concede internal self-government.
The Tydings-McDuffie Act (1934), ratified by plebiscite in 1935, promised independence after ten years, with the USA keeping military bases and control of foreign policy meanwhile; Quezon became president. Immediately after Pearl Harbour, Japan conquered the Philippines - often called the worst military defeat in US history; the book says about 23,000 American and about 100,000 Filipino soldiers were killed or captured. The Communist-led Hukbalahap (People's Army against the Japanese) fought a strong guerrilla war, but after the American return the Huks were attacked by their former allies; their rebellion was crushed by the mid-1950s with US help. The USA kept its promise: after elections in April 1946 the Philippines became independent on 4 July 1946, remained one of America's most loyal allies and was one of only three Asian states to join the South East Asia Treaty Organisation (SEATO) in 1954.
Two roads to independence
-
Indonesia (Dutch)
- Nationalism late; slow Western education
- Japanese occupation 1942-45
- Dutch tried to return by force
- Independence December 1949 after world pressure
-
Philippines (Spanish, then American)
- Nationalism early (Cavite 1872, Aguinaldo)
- US set up elected institutions
- Tydings-McDuffie Act promised freedom (1934)
- Independence 4 July 1946, as promised
Worked example 1: why nationalism came later in Indonesia
Question: using the book, give two reasons why the national movement in the East Indies took shape later than in the Philippines. Working: (1) the Dutch were slow to introduce Western education, so a modern educated class that could lead a movement grew late; (2) in Indonesia Eurasians identified with the Dutch, whereas in the Philippines Eurasians identified with the native cause and became leaders. A third point: Spanish rule had already produced martyrs and revolts by 1872. Answer: late education and the loyalty of the Eurasian elite to the Dutch.
Worked example 2: counting years of colonial rule
Question: Spanish rule in the Philippines began in 1565 and ended in 1898; American rule ended in 1946. How long was each, and what was the total? Working: 1898 - 1565 = 333 years (the book's 'over 300 years'); 1946 - 1898 = 48 years; total 1946 - 1565 = 381 years. Check: 333 + 48 = 381. Answer: about 333 years of Spanish and 48 years of American rule, 381 years in all.
Indonesia: Boedi Oetomo 1908, Sarekat Islam, Communist Party, Sukarno's Nationalist Party; Japanese occupation 1942; independence December 1949 (Hague conference). Philippines: Cavite 1872; Spanish-American War and Treaty of Paris 1898; Aguinaldo; Tydings-McDuffie Act 1934; independence 4 July 1946.
Key takeaways: in Indonesia nationalism grew from Boedi Oetomo and Sarekat Islam to the Communists and Sukarno, survived Dutch repression and, after Japanese occupation and a struggle against the returning Dutch, won independence in December 1949 with the help of world opinion. In the Philippines early nationalism faced Spain, then the USA after 1898; American rule built elected institutions, the Tydings-McDuffie Act promised freedom, and after Japanese occupation the country became independent on 4 July 1946.
Check your understanding
-
1. What was the first native political society in the East Indies (1908)?
- Sarekat Islam
- The Indonesian Nationalist Party
- The Volksraad
- Boedi Oetomo
Show answer
Answer: D. Boedi Oetomo ('High Endeavour'), founded in 1908 by medical students guided by Wahidin Sudirohusodo, was the first native political society. The Volksraad was a Dutch-created council (1918).
-
2. Which leader founded the Indonesian Nationalist Party and later became Indonesia's president?
- Hatta
- Wahidin Sudirohusodo
- Sukarno
- Quezon
Show answer
Answer: C. Sukarno, a young engineer, organised the Indonesian Nationalist Party, was imprisoned by the Dutch and ruled Java and Sumatra as president after 1945.
-
3. By the Treaty of Paris (10 December 1898), Spain:
- Kept the Philippines
- Transferred sovereignty over the Philippines to the USA and ceded Guam and Puerto Rico
- Gave the Philippines independence
- Gave Cuba to the USA as a colony
Show answer
Answer: B. Spain renounced its claim to Cuba, ceded Guam and Puerto Rico to the USA and transferred the Philippines to the USA.
-
4. Which Act of 1934 provided a ten-year period for transferring power to Filipinos?
- The Tydings-McDuffie Act
- The Jones Act
- The Lend-Lease Act
- The Malolos Constitution
Show answer
Answer: A. The Tydings-McDuffie Act (Philippines Independence Act) of 1934, ratified by plebiscite in 1935, provided a ten-year transition; independence came on 4 July 1946.
-
5. Who was the first president of the Philippine republic under the Malolos Constitution?
- Manuel Quezon
- Jose Burgos
- Emilio Aguinaldo
- Miguel López de Legazpi
Show answer
Answer: C. Emilio Aguinaldo was elected first president under the Malolos Constitution; the republic lasted until his capture by American forces on 23 March 1901.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.