- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The UNO and global disputes
Describe how the United Nations dealt with Palestine and the Arab-Israeli conflict, the question of China's seat, the Korean War, the Suez Crisis and the Hungarian uprising, and what these cases show about its strengths and limits.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the UN's role in Palestine, the creation of Israel and the wars of 1948 and 1967, as the book presents them.
- Explain the UN's part in the Korean War and the 'Uniting for Peace' resolution.
- Compare the UN's success in the Suez Crisis with its failure in Hungary (1956).
The book examines how the UN handled the great disputes of the early Cold War. Some show it acting effectively; others show that it was helpless when a great power was determined to defy it. Contested political issues, especially the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, are presented here as the book describes them, with its figures and judgements attributed to it.
Palestine and the creation of Israel
After the Second World War Jews demanded a homeland in Palestine, and Arabs opposed it; the matter went to the UN. In May 1947 the General Assembly set up the UN Special Committee on Palestine (UNSCOP). The book reports that, according to UNSCOP, Arabs held about 85 per cent of the land and Jews about 5.8 per cent, yet the committee recommended partition into two states, which the book gives as 45 per cent for the Arab state and 55 per cent for the Jewish state. When the UN voted for partition in November 1947, fighting broke out at once. On the eve of British withdrawal, Israel declared independence on 14 May 1948. The war ended with a UN General Assembly resolution affirming the right of Palestinian refugees to return home and receive compensation. Israel joined the UN the next year; UN peacekeepers were placed on the Israeli-Egyptian border, and the UN Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) was set up to help refugees.
The 1967 (Six Day) War: tensions grew; the book says the USA was supplying Israel with advanced planes and missiles by 1966, there were artillery exchanges between Israel and Syria in April 1967, Egypt's President Nasser demanded the withdrawal of UN troops and on 23 May closed the Straits of Tiran to Israeli shipping, and in early June Israel attacked Egypt, destroying almost all its air force on the ground. In six days Israel occupied the West Bank, the Gaza Strip, East Jerusalem, Syria's Golan Heights and Egypt's Sinai; the book says 250,000 more Palestinians went into exile. A UN resolution called for the withdrawal of Israeli forces from occupied territories; the book notes that it referred to Palestinians only as refugees, which it attributes to US influence, and that the USA vetoed later UN calls for an international peace conference including the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO). The PLO, formed in 1964 under Yasser Arafat, waged guerrilla war against Israel until the 1980s before entering peace negotiations in the 1990s.
China's seat
When Mao's Communists won in 1949 and Chiang Kai-shek moved his Nationalist government to Formosa (Taiwan), the USSR proposed that Communist China replace Nationalist China on the Security Council. When this was refused, the USSR boycotted the Security Council and other UN bodies. The People's Republic of China became a permanent member only in 1971.
The Korean War (1950-53)
Korea, ruled by Japan since 1910, was divided at the 38th parallel in 1945: the Soviet-occupied north had a third of the people and most of the industry; the American-controlled south had two-thirds of the people and most of the farmland. In the south, UN-supervised elections made Syngman Rhee president; in the north the USSR set up a communist government under Kim Il Sung. Both occupying armies withdrew, and Rhee openly spoke of uniting Korea by force. On 25 June 1950 North Korea invaded the South.
The Security Council, meeting while the USSR was absent, called for an end to the fighting and asked members to help. Sixteen members sent forces and forty-five gave aid; the American General MacArthur commanded the UN forces. When the USSR returned to the Council, the General Assembly, on the USA's initiative, passed the 'Uniting for Peace' resolution (1950): if the Security Council could not agree, the Assembly could meet in emergency session and recommend the use of force. The USSR called it illegal. An armistice in July 1953 ended the fighting; the war had raised the importance of the General Assembly.
Suez and Hungary, 1956
| Aspect | Suez Crisis | Hungarian uprising |
|---|---|---|
| Background | The canal linking the Red Sea and the Mediterranean, built by the Frenchman Ferdinand de Lesseps, was owned by the Anglo-French Suez Canal Company. In July 1956 President Nasser nationalised it | Stalin-era leader Rakosi was replaced as premier by Imre Nagy (1953) but kept control of the party; writers and intellectuals demanded his removal, achieved in July 1956 |
| Crisis | Israel invaded Sinai (29 October); British and French aircraft bombed Egyptian bases; their troops landed at Port Said (5 November) | A peaceful demonstration in Budapest (23 October) became a national rising against Soviet control; Nagy, back as premier, began a multi-party coalition |
| UN action | Britain and France vetoed a Security Council resolution; the General Assembly, at the USA's initiative, met in emergency session, condemned the invasion and created the UN Emergency Force (UNEF), a peace force sent with both sides' consent | Soviet troops crushed the rising on 4 November. The USSR vetoed the Security Council resolution demanding withdrawal; the Assembly passed it, but nothing came of it |
| Result | British and French troops left by 22 December 1956, Israel by March 1957; Nasser emerged a hero of Arab and Egyptian nationalism | The UN was shown to be helpless against a determined great power; with Khrushchev's leaked secret speech, it led many writers and intellectuals worldwide to leave communist parties |
When the UN could and could not act
-
UN effective
- Korea: Council acted while the USSR was absent
- Suez: Assembly and UNEF; aggressors withdrew
- Superpowers were not in direct conflict, or agreed
-
UN helpless
- Hungary: USSR vetoed and ignored the Assembly
- Disputes involving permanent members
- Middle East after 1967 shaped by the superpowers
Worked example 1: what made Suez different from Hungary?
Question: both crises came in October-November 1956. Why did the UN succeed at Suez but fail in Hungary? Working: at Suez, Britain and France vetoed in the Security Council, but the USA - a superpower - backed the Assembly's demand, and they could not hold out against both superpowers and world opinion, so they withdrew and UNEF moved in. In Hungary, the aggressor was a superpower itself, the USSR, which vetoed in the Council and ignored the Assembly; no member was willing to fight it. Answer: the UN worked when the superpowers did not protect the aggressor, and failed when the aggressor was a superpower - the book's lesson that a determined great power could defy the UN.
Worked example 2: why did the USSR's boycott matter in Korea?
Question: explain how the USSR's absence from the Security Council in June 1950 affected the UN's response to Korea. Working: the USSR was boycotting the Council over China's seat. A permanent member can block a resolution by voting against it, but an absent member cannot. So the Council could pass a resolution against North Korea and call for help, and sixteen nations sent forces under MacArthur. When the USSR returned, the West turned to the Assembly through 'Uniting for Peace'. Answer: the boycott removed the Soviet veto at the decisive moment, which allowed UN military action.
UN and disputes: Palestine partition vote (November 1947), Israel (14 May 1948), UNRWA; China's seat (PRC from 1971); Korea 1950-53 and 'Uniting for Peace'; Suez 1956 and UNEF; Hungary 1956 (Soviet veto); Six Day War 1967.
Key takeaways: the UN recommended the partition of Palestine, and the creation of Israel in 1948 and the war of 1967 produced lasting conflict and refugee problems that the UN could not resolve. The Soviet boycott let the Security Council act in Korea, and 'Uniting for Peace' strengthened the General Assembly. At Suez the UN's emergency force secured withdrawal, but in Hungary the Soviet veto showed that the UN was helpless against a determined great power.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which committee did the UN General Assembly set up in May 1947 to investigate Palestine?
- UNRWA
- UNSCOP
- UNEF
- UNESCO
Show answer
Answer: B. The UN Special Committee on Palestine (UNSCOP) was set up in May 1947 and recommended partition. UNRWA helped refugees; UNEF was the 1956 Emergency Force.
-
2. What did the 'Uniting for Peace' resolution provide?
- That the USSR would rejoin the Security Council
- That if the Security Council could not agree, the General Assembly could meet in emergency session and recommend force
- That Korea would be united by elections
- That China's seat would go to the People's Republic
Show answer
Answer: B. Passed on the USA's initiative during the Korean War, it let the General Assembly act in emergency session when the Security Council was deadlocked. The USSR called it illegal.
-
3. Who nationalised the Suez Canal in July 1956?
- Ferdinand de Lesseps
- Imre Nagy
- Yasser Arafat
- Gamal Abdel Nasser
Show answer
Answer: D. Egypt's President Gamal Abdel Nasser nationalised the canal, until then owned by the Anglo-French Suez Canal Company. De Lesseps had built it.
-
4. What does the Hungarian uprising of 1956 show about the UN, according to the book?
- If a great power was determined to defy the UN, the UN was helpless
- The UN could always stop aggression
- The General Assembly could send troops into the USSR
- Hungary was expelled from the UN
Show answer
Answer: A. The USSR vetoed the Security Council resolution and ignored the Assembly's; the book says this showed that a great power determined to defy the UN made it helpless.
-
5. Which territories did Israel occupy at the end of the Six Day War of 1967?
- Only the Sinai
- Lebanon and Jordan
- The West Bank, Gaza Strip, East Jerusalem, Golan Heights and Sinai
- Cyprus and Crete
Show answer
Answer: C. The book lists the West Bank, the Gaza Strip, East Jerusalem, Syria's Golan Heights and Egypt's Sinai.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.