- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The Montagu-Chelmsford reforms and the non-Brahmin movement
Describe dyarchy and the central legislature under the reforms of 1919, the Indian response, and the rise and character of the non-Brahmin movements as the textbook presents them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain dyarchy, reserved and transferred subjects, and the central legislature of 1919.
- Describe the Congress's response and the formation of the Indian Liberal Federation.
- Explain the origins, trends and southern pattern of the non-Brahmin movements, and the book's view of how nationalists and the government responded to them.
After the war Britain offered constitutional reforms, and at the same time movements of non-Brahmin and lower castes questioned the dominance of upper castes. Both shaped politics in the 1920s, especially in the Madras Presidency.
The reforms of 1919
Edwin Montagu, Secretary of State, and Lord Chelmsford, Viceroy, announced a scheme that became law in 1919. The book calls it the Indian Councils Act of 1919; it is generally known as the Government of India Act, 1919. It enlarged the provincial councils with elected majorities and introduced dyarchy (double government) in the provinces.
Dyarchy in the provinces
-
Reserved subjects
- Law and order, finance and other important subjects
- Under the Governor and his officials
- Not responsible to the legislature
-
Transferred subjects
- Health, education, local self-government
- Under Indian ministers
- Ministers responsible to the legislature
The Governor could overrule ministers by special (veto) powers, which the book says made a mockery of the scheme. At the centre the Act created two houses. According to the textbook, the Central Legislative Assembly had 144 members, 41 of them nominated, and the Council of States 60 members, 26 nominated. Neither house controlled the Governor-General and his Executive Council, the centre controlled the provinces, and the vote remained restricted. Power stayed with British authorities.
Indians who had backed the war expected more. The Congress met in a special session at Bombay in August 1918 and called the scheme 'disappointing and unsatisfactory'. The book describes British policy as 'carrot and stick'. A group of moderate or liberal leaders led by Surendranath Banerjea wanted to work the reforms, left the Congress, and formed the Indian Liberal Federation.
Roots of the non-Brahmin movements
The book explains that hierarchical society found expression in caste associations and movements that questioned upper-caste dominance; upper castes also controlled the means of production, so middle and lower castes depended on them. Nineteenth-century liberalism and humanism stirred awareness, and by 1900 several movements led by non-Brahmin leaders had arisen.
| Movement | Region (as the textbook gives it) |
|---|---|
| Namasudra movement | Bengal and eastern India |
| Adidharma movement | North-western India |
| Satyashodhak movement (Jyotirao Phule) | Western India |
| Dravidian movements | South India |
The book traces the first expression to **Jyotirao Phule's book Gulamgiri (the book dates it 1872) and his Satyashodhak Samaj, which sought to free lower castes from Brahminical dominance and from scriptures it considered exploitative. Colonial education helped indirectly. So did the census, published every ten years, which ranked castes by 'social precedence'; claims and counter-claims followed and many new caste associations formed. These associations worked for social recognition, education and jobs, and electoral politics from the 1880s** gave them a further push.
Two trends emerged: 'Sanskritisation' of lower castes (adopting upper-caste customs to claim higher status), and radical pro-poor peasant-labour movements. The book says northern and eastern movements were mostly Sanskritic, while western and southern ones split and were absorbed into nationalist and Dravidian-Left movements. All criticised what they called Brahmin domination.
The southern pattern
In the south, according to the textbook, Brahmins formed only 3.2 per cent of the population but held 72 per cent of all graduates, and dominated government services. Educated and trading members of non-Brahmin castes challenged this, at first as an elite movement, through the Non-Brahmin Manifesto issued at the end of 1916, which claimed that non-Brahmins formed the bulk of taxpayers yet received no benefits from the state. The book says the colonial government used these genuine grievances to divide and rule, as with the Brahmanetara Parishat in Bombay and the Justice Party in Madras, at least till 1930. Both regions also had radical possibilities, seen in the Dalit-Bahujan movement under Dr Ambedkar and the Self-Respect Movement under Periyar E.V. Ramasamy.
The book also judges the nationalists: they failed to understand the liberal democratic content of this awakening among the lower strata. Some ignored it, most, especially the extremists, opposed it, and a few even called its leaders British stooges. Yet, the book notes, early non-Brahmin leaders were using the same methods with the government as the early nationalists had.
Worked example 1: the numbers in the central legislature
Question: using the textbook's figures, how many members of each house were not nominated? Working: Assembly: 144 − 41 = 103; Council of States: 60 − 26 = 34. Share nominated in the Assembly: 41 ÷ 144 ≈ 28%. Answer: 103 and 34 members respectively; yet even an elected majority could not control the Governor-General's government.
Worked example 2: reading a ratio of under-representation
Question: Brahmins were 3.2% of the southern population and held 72% of graduates (the book's figures). How many times their population share was that? Working: 72 ÷ 3.2 = 22.5. Answer: 22.5 times, which explains why non-Brahmin leaders argued for a fairer share of education and jobs.
Dyarchy (1919): reserved subjects with the Governor, transferred subjects with ministers answerable to the legislature - but the Governor could overrule them.
Key takeaways: the 1919 reforms gave provinces dyarchy and the centre two houses, but real power stayed with British officials; the Congress called them disappointing and the Liberals split away. Caste movements, from Phule's Satyashodhak Samaj to the Dravidian movement, questioned upper-caste dominance. In the south, the Non-Brahmin Manifesto of 1916 challenged Brahmin predominance in education and services. The book criticises both the colonial use of these grievances and the nationalists' failure to understand them.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under dyarchy, which subject was 'transferred' to Indian ministers?
- Law and order
- Finance
- Education
- Defence
Show answer
Answer: C. Health, education and local self-government were transferred to ministers responsible to the legislature; law and order and finance were reserved.
-
2. How did the Congress describe the Montagu-Chelmsford scheme at its special Bombay session of August 1918?
- Generous and welcome
- Disappointing and unsatisfactory
- A step to complete independence
- Acceptable without change
Show answer
Answer: B. The Congress termed the scheme 'disappointing and unsatisfactory'. Leaders who wanted to work it formed the Indian Liberal Federation.
-
3. Which pair is correctly matched according to the textbook?
- Namasudra movement - South India
- Satyashodhak movement - Western India
- Adidharma movement - Eastern India
- Dravidian movement - North-western India
Show answer
Answer: B. Satyashodhak was in western India; Namasudra in Bengal and eastern India; Adidharma in north-western India; the Dravidian movements in the south.
-
4. Which book of Jyotirao Phule does the textbook treat as the first expression of the non-Brahmin movement?
- Annihilation of Caste
- Mook Nayak
- Castes in India
- Gulamgiri
Show answer
Answer: D. The book names Phule's Gulamgiri. Annihilation of Caste and Castes in India are works of Ambedkar, and Mook Nayak was his journal.
-
5. The Non-Brahmin Manifesto, issued at the end of 1916, claimed that non-Brahmins:
- formed the bulk of taxpayers but received no benefits from the state
- wanted to leave the British Empire
- rejected all government jobs
- supported the Home Rule League
Show answer
Answer: A. The manifesto asserted that non-Brahmins formed the bulk of the taxpayers, including most zamindars and agriculturists, yet received no benefits from the state.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.