- Practice
- About 22 min
- 5 practice questions
From the Rajaji formula to the Mountbatten Plan (1944-1947)
Explain the Rajaji formula, the Wavell Plan and Simla Conference, the 1946 elections, the Cabinet Mission, the interim government, Direct Action Day and the Mountbatten Plan that led to partition and independence.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the points of the Rajaji formula (1944) and explain why the Simla Conference (1945) failed.
- Describe the Cabinet Mission of 1946, the elections, the interim government and the effect of Direct Action Day.
- Explain the Mountbatten Plan and how the Congress came to accept partition.
Sections 7.5 and 7.6 of the textbook describe the last years before independence. The book says the Lahore resolution of 1940 had changed the debate from Muslims as a 'minority' to Muslims as a 'nation', with Muhammad Ali Jinnah claiming to be the community's sole spokesman.
The Rajaji formula, 1944
In April 1944, while Congress leaders were in jail, C. Rajagopalachari (Rajaji) put forward a proposal. After his release, Gandhi proposed talks with Jinnah on this basis in July 1944, but the talks achieved nothing.
- After the war a commission would mark out the contiguous districts where Muslims were in an absolute majority, and a plebiscite of all adults there would decide whether they wanted Pakistan.
- If there was partition, the two states would agree to run certain essential services, such as defence or communications, together.
- Border districts could choose to join either sovereign state.
- The scheme would be carried out only after the full transfer of power.
The Wavell Plan and the Simla Conference, 1945
Wavell went to London in March 1945 and convinced Churchill that a Congress-Muslim League coalition was needed. In June 1945 he called a conference at Simla, and Nehru, Patel and the Congress President Maulana Abul Kalam Azad were released for it. He proposed an Executive Council of Indians only, apart from himself and the Commander-in-Chief, with equal numbers of caste Hindus and Muslims, separate representation for the Scheduled Castes, and the start of talks on a new constitution.
The Simla Conference (25 June-14 July 1945) broke down over who could nominate members. The League insisted on the exclusive right to nominate all Muslim members, so that the Congress could name only caste Hindus - not a Muslim or a member of the Scheduled Castes. The book sees this as a way to deepen the communal divide and deny the Congress the status of representing all Indians. Wavell thought a council without the League unworkable and abandoned the talks. In April 1946 a convention of League legislators in Delhi defined Pakistan as a 'sovereign independent state' made up of Bengal and Assam in the north-east and Punjab, the North-West Frontier Province, Sind and Baluchistan in the north-west; Azad rejected this for the Congress. Meanwhile Churchill had been voted out, and the Labour Prime Minister Clement Attlee declared that India's independence was certain, with only its terms to be settled.
The Cabinet Mission and the elections, 1946
The Cabinet Mission arrived in March 1946 to set up a national government before the final transfer of power. Its members were Pethick-Lawrence (Secretary of State for India, who led it), Sir Stafford Cripps and A.V. Alexander. (Section 7.6 of the book names Cripps as the Secretary of State heading the mission; Unit 6 of the same book, and standard histories, give the leader as Pethick-Lawrence.) It proposed a constitution-making body elected across the provinces and princely states and a loose confederation in which the League could run the north-west and north-east and the Congress the rest; partition was not proposed. Jinnah signalled acceptance on 6 June 1946, and Nehru told the AICC on 7 July 1946 that the Congress accepted it. On 29 July 1946 Jinnah announced the League's opposition and that it would not take part in forming the Constituent Assembly.
In the elections of July-August 1946, the book says, the Congress won 199 of the 210 general seats, while the League won 76 seats, all but one from Muslim-reserved constituencies. Because the League stayed out, 207 members attended the first session of the Constituent Assembly on 9 December 1946.
The interim government and Direct Action
In June 1946 Wavell invited fourteen leaders to an interim government. The League objected when the Congress proposed Zakir Hussain, a Muslim, from its own quota. On 12 August 1946 Wavell invited Nehru to form the government, and twelve members were announced on 25 August; Nehru took office on 2 September 1946. The League's call for Direct Action on 16 August 1946 led to bloodshed in Calcutta and other places, and fresh communal violence followed in Bombay, Ahmedabad and Noakhali in East Bengal. The book describes Gandhi going to the riot-hit areas, staying with a few followers in a deserted house in Beliaghata, Calcutta, and insisting that Muslims driven from their homes in Delhi were Indian nationals whom the state must protect. (Most accounts date Gandhi's Beliaghata stay and the Delhi relief camps to August-September 1947; the book places them in 1946.)
The League joined the reconstituted interim government on 26 October 1946 with Liaquat Ali Khan, I.I. Chundrigar, A.R. Nishtar, Ghazanfar Ali Khan and Jogendra Nath Mandal, but Jinnah stayed out. The book says its members boycotted Nehru's informal consultations and seemed set on wrecking the government from within. The last straw, in the book's account, was the budget of finance member Liaquat Ali Khan in early 1947, with new taxes on industry and trade and an inquiry into about 150 big business houses, which the book describes as a calculated blow at industrialists who backed the Congress.
The Mountbatten Plan and partition
On 20 February 1947 Attlee told Parliament that Britain would leave India by June 1948. Lord Mountbatten replaced Wavell as Viceroy in March 1947 (the book gives 22 March). His plan divided Punjab into West (to Pakistan) and East, and Bengal into West (to India) and East (to Pakistan). The Congress Working Committee accepted partition on 1 May 1947. After visiting London, Mountbatten announced the plan (on 3 June 1947, a date the book does not give) and brought British withdrawal forward to 15 August 1947, leaving only about eleven weeks. The AICC on 15 June 1947 approved a resolution moved by Govind Ballabh Pant accepting partition; the book says it needed the persuasion of Nehru and Patel and Gandhi's moral authority. In its summary, the book says freedom came with partition and a heavy toll of lives in communal riots, and that free India was born with a challenge to secularism.
The road to 15 August 1947 (dates as in the textbook)
- Rajaji formula April 1944.
- Simla Conference 25 June-14 July 1945; breaks down.
- Cabinet Mission Arrives March 1946; League withdraws 29 July 1946.
- Direct Action Day 16 August 1946; interim government from 2 September 1946.
- Attlee's statement 20 February 1947: Britain to leave by June 1948.
- Mountbatten Plan Partition accepted by the CWC (1 May) and the AICC (15 June 1947).
- Independence 15 August 1947, with partition.
Worked example 1: comparing two proposals
Question: How did the Rajaji formula differ from the Cabinet Mission Plan? Step 1: Rajaji accepted the possibility of partition, decided by a plebiscite in Muslim-majority districts after the war. Step 2: the Cabinet Mission did not propose partition; it offered a loose confederation. Step 3: both tried to meet the League's demand while keeping some common services or a common centre.
Worked example 2: counting weeks
Mountbatten's plan was announced on 3 June 1947 and independence came on 15 August 1947. June has 30 days, so 3 June to 30 June is 27 days; July adds 31 (58); 1-15 August adds 15 (73 days). 73 ÷ 7 is about 10.4 weeks - roughly the 'eleven weeks' the book mentions.
1944 Rajaji formula; 1945 Simla Conference; 1946 Cabinet Mission, Direct Action Day, interim government; 20 February 1947 Attlee's statement; 1947 Mountbatten Plan; 15 August 1947 independence and partition.
Key takeaways: the Rajaji formula and the Simla Conference failed to bridge the gap; the League's success in Muslim seats, its withdrawal from the Cabinet Mission plan and Direct Action Day hardened the deadlock; the interim government did not work smoothly; and Attlee's deadline and the Mountbatten Plan led to independence with partition on 15 August 1947.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under the Rajaji formula, how was it to be decided whether Muslim-majority districts would form Pakistan?
- By a decision of the Viceroy
- By the Muslim League alone
- By a plebiscite of the adult population after the war
- By the princely states
Show answer
Answer: C. A post-war commission would mark out contiguous Muslim-majority districts, and a plebiscite of the adult population there would decide.
-
2. Why did the Simla Conference of 1945 break down?
- Wavell refused to release Congress leaders
- The League claimed the exclusive right to nominate all Muslim members of the Council
- The Congress demanded immediate partition
- Churchill cancelled the conference
Show answer
Answer: B. The League wanted the sole right to nominate Muslims, so the Congress could name only caste Hindus. Wavell found a council without the League unworkable and abandoned the talks.
-
3. According to the book, how many of the 210 general seats did the Congress win in the 1946 elections?
- 76
- 207
- 210
- 199
Show answer
Answer: D. The Congress won 199 of 210 general seats. 76 was the League's tally, and 207 was the number of members who attended the first session of the Constituent Assembly.
-
4. Who moved the resolution accepting partition at the AICC on 15 June 1947?
- Govind Ballabh Pant
- Jawaharlal Nehru
- Maulana Abul Kalam Azad
- Rajagopalachari (Rajaji)
Show answer
Answer: A. The book says the resolution was moved by Govind Ballabh Pant and needed the persuasion of Nehru and Patel and Gandhi's moral authority to pass.
-
5. By what date did Attlee's statement of 20 February 1947 say Britain would leave India?
- 15 August 1947
- 26 January 1950
- June 1948
- December 1946
Show answer
Answer: C. Attlee said Britain intended to leave by June 1948. Mountbatten later brought the date forward to 15 August 1947.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.