- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
India's neighbourhood policy and India-Afghanistan relations
Explain the principles behind India's relations with its neighbours, including Panchsheel, the Gujral Doctrine and the textbook's account of Neighbourhood First, and trace India-Afghanistan relations from the 1950 Friendship Treaty onwards.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Name India's neighbours and explain why the textbook says relations with them have had ups and downs.
- State the five principles of the Gujral Doctrine and the idea of Neighbourhood First.
- Describe India-Afghanistan relations: the 1950 treaty, development aid, SAARC membership, the 2011 strategic partnership and India's interests.
A country can choose its friends, but not its neighbours. India shares land or sea borders with Afghanistan, Pakistan, China, Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh, Myanmar, Sri Lanka and the Maldives. This chapter of the Tamil Nadu textbook looks at India's relations with each of them, beginning with the principles India follows.
Principles of India's neighbourhood policy
The textbook says India, placed in a politically sensitive region, has tried to keep cordial relations with its neighbours, following the five principles of Panchsheel, though relations have had ups and downs and some neighbours have at times been hostile. Two later ideas are also described:
| Gujral Doctrine (five principles) | What it means |
|---|---|
| No demand for reciprocity | With Bangladesh, Bhutan, Maldives, Nepal and Sri Lanka, India gives and accommodates what it can in good faith |
| No use of territory against others | No South Asian country should let its territory be used against another country of the region |
| Non-interference | No country should interfere in the internal affairs of another |
| Territorial integrity | All must respect each other's territorial integrity and sovereignty |
| Peaceful settlement | All disputes should be settled through peaceful bilateral negotiations |
The textbook also describes Neighbourhood First, a policy of giving priority to ties with immediate neighbours, marked by inviting South Asian leaders to the new government's swearing-in in 2014 and by early visits to neighbouring countries.
India and Afghanistan
- 1950: India and Afghanistan signed a Friendship Treaty. Ties were strong under King Zahir Shah.
- 1979-1989: during the Soviet intervention and the resistance to it, India's role was limited, though it continued industrial, irrigation and hydroelectric projects.
- Mid-1990s: after the Taliban took control, the textbook says India, with Iran, Russia and Tajikistan, supported the Northern Alliance that opposed them. In 1999 a hijacked Indian Airlines flight (IC-814) was taken to Kandahar.
- After 2001: India relied on development projects, humanitarian aid and training of Afghan personnel. It proposed Afghanistan's membership of SAARC, which Afghanistan joined on 3 April 2007.
- 2011: India became the first country with which Afghanistan signed a strategic partnership agreement.
The textbook lists India's projects, such as rebuilding schools, a power substation in Kabul, an agricultural university in Kandahar, a cricket stadium, telephone exchanges and tube wells, and notes that these earned India goodwill as soft power. Trade grew through a Preferential Trade Agreement (2003) and, from 2011, duty-free access for almost all Afghan goods; Iran's Chabahar port offers a route for Afghan trade that bypasses Pakistan. The textbook names India's interests as strategic (a friendly Afghanistan and a regional role), economic (minerals, trade, investment) and security (Afghanistan must not become a safe haven for militant groups). Note that the textbook describes conditions up to about 2019; the situation in Afghanistan has changed since then, so your teacher may add recent developments.
India's interests in Afghanistan (textbook)
-
Strategic
- A friendly state in the region
- A role as a regional power
-
Economic
- Mineral wealth
- Trade via Chabahar port
- Protecting Indian investment
-
Security
- No safe haven for militant groups
- Concern over drug trafficking
-
Development
- Schools, power, roads
- Training of personnel
- Goodwill (soft power)
Gujral Doctrine: no demand for reciprocity from smaller neighbours, no hostile use of territory, non-interference, respect for integrity and sovereignty, peaceful bilateral settlement.
Worked example 1: which Gujral principle?
A made-up situation: a smaller neighbour asks India for electricity on easy terms without offering anything in return, and India agrees in good faith. Working: this fits the first principle, that India does not insist on reciprocity from smaller neighbours such as Bhutan, Nepal or Sri Lanka. If instead an armed group used one country's territory to attack another, that would break the second principle.
Worked example 2: soft power or hard power?
Classify India's actions as described in the textbook: (a) building a school and a cricket stadium; (b) training civil servants; (c) gifting attack helicopters (2015). Working: (a) and (b) are soft power: they win goodwill through development and skills. (c) adds military capability, a form of hard power. The textbook says India faces a choice between relying on soft power and doing more.
Key takeaways: India follows Panchsheel with its neighbours; the Gujral Doctrine adds non-reciprocity towards smaller neighbours, non-interference, respect for sovereignty and peaceful bilateral settlement. India-Afghanistan ties rest on the 1950 Friendship Treaty, development aid, SAARC membership (2007) and the 2011 strategic partnership, with strategic, economic and security interests.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these is a principle of the Gujral Doctrine?
- India must always demand equal concessions from every neighbour
- Disputes should be settled through peaceful bilateral negotiations
- India should form military alliances with all neighbours
- Neighbours should adopt India's constitution
Show answer
Answer: B. The five principles include settling all disputes through peaceful bilateral negotiations. The first principle is in fact the opposite of demanding equal concessions: India does not ask for reciprocity from smaller neighbours.
-
2. In which year did India and Afghanistan sign a Friendship Treaty?
- 1947
- 1971
- 1950
- 2011
Show answer
Answer: C. They signed a Friendship Treaty in 1950. 2011 is the year of the strategic partnership agreement.
-
3. When did Afghanistan become a member of SAARC, after India proposed its membership?
- July 1996
- 8 December 1985
- 1 January 2015
- 3 April 2007
Show answer
Answer: D. India proposed Afghanistan's membership in 2005 and Afghanistan joined on 3 April 2007. SAARC itself was founded on 8 December 1985.
-
4. Why is Iran's Chabahar port important for India-Afghanistan trade, according to the textbook?
- It is India's largest naval base
- It is in Pakistan
- It is the capital of Afghanistan
- It provides a new transit route for Afghan trade with India and the world
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says Chabahar could substantially increase Afghanistan's exports by providing a new transit route to India and the rest of the world.
-
5. Which of these is an example of India's 'soft power' in Afghanistan?
- Imposing trade sanctions
- Fighting a war
- Closing the border
- Rebuilding a school and giving it grants
Show answer
Answer: D. Soft power wins influence through attraction and goodwill, such as development projects, schools and training. The other options are coercive measures.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.