- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Birth of the United Nations, the General Assembly and the Security Council
Explain how the United Nations was created, its purposes and six organs, how the General Assembly and the Security Council work, and the debate over the veto.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Put the steps that created the United Nations, from 1942 to 1945, in order.
- Name the four purposes and six main organs of the UN.
- Compare the General Assembly and the Security Council and explain the veto and the arguments about it.
The League had failed, but it left behind a dream: a universal organisation working for peace. After the Second World War, which the textbook says caused around 72 million casualties, the leaders who had fought together turned that dream into the United Nations. This lesson follows how the UN was built and how its two best-known organs work.
From wartime alliance to world organisation
How the United Nations came into being
- 1942: Declaration by United Nations Twenty-six nations pledged to fight the Axis powers together; the name came from US President Franklin D. Roosevelt.
- August-October 1944: Dumbarton Oaks China, the Soviet Union, the United Kingdom and the United States drew up the blueprint; by October the outline of the Charter was ready.
- 26 June 1945: San Francisco Representatives of fifty countries signed the UN Charter.
- 24 October 1945 The Charter came into force and the United Nations officially began.
Notice a difference from the League: the UN began as a wartime alliance, formed soon after the United States entered the war in December 1941. (The textbook links 24 October 1945 with the end of the Pacific war; in fact the war in the Pacific ended in August-September 1945, and 24 October is the date the Charter came into force.)
| Four main purposes of the UN |
|---|
| Military security |
| Economic and social progress |
| Upholding of human rights |
| International justice |
The drafters' dilemma and the veto
The Charter's authors faced the League's old problem: how to balance national sovereignty with international idealism, how to deal with the fact that some countries were more powerful than others, and how to stop a great power simply walking out, as Japan had done in the 1930s. Their answer was the veto, given to the five founding powers: China, France, Great Britain, the United States and the Soviet Union (today the Russian Federation holds the Soviet seat). They are called the Permanent Five (P-5). The Charter kept the League's goals of security and peaceful settlement, and gave much more weight to social and economic progress, because many saw the economic crisis of the inter-war years as a root cause of the war.
The six main organs
In 1945 the UN had six main organs: the General Assembly, the Security Council, the Economic and Social Council, the Trusteeship Council, the International Court of Justice and the Secretariat. In the textbook's comparison, the General Assembly is the UN's parliament, the Security Council its executive committee and the Secretariat its bureaucracy.
General Assembly and Security Council
-
General Assembly
- All member states; one nation, one vote
- Main deliberative organ
- Budget and admission of members by two-thirds majority
- Resolutions are recommendations with moral weight
- Regular session from September; two-week general debate
- Work done through six main committees
-
Security Council
- Fifteen members: five permanent and ten elected for two years
- Primary responsibility for international peace and security
- Meets whenever peace is threatened
- Decisions are legally binding on members
- A resolution needs nine of fifteen votes and no 'No' vote from a P-5 member
The six main committees of the General Assembly are: Disarmament and International Security; Economic and Financial; Social, Humanitarian and Cultural; Special Political and Decolonization; Administrative and Budgetary; and Legal. When peace is threatened, the Security Council first asks the parties to settle peacefully; if fighting breaks out it seeks a ceasefire through negotiation, economic sanctions or by authorising force carried out by willing members, and it can set up peacekeeping operations. The textbook lists examples such as the Congo operation (ONUC, 1960-1964) and the India-Pakistan Observation Mission (UNIPOM, 1965-1966).
Security Council voting rule: at least 9 of the 15 members must vote yes, and none of the five permanent members may vote no.
The debate over the veto
- Criticism: the veto is called undemocratic because one country can block the majority. The chapter notes that permanent members have vetoed resolutions criticising themselves or their allies, and quotes critics, including Amnesty International, who say the veto has served political self-interest over protecting civilians.
- Reform ideas: groups outside the P-5, such as the Non-Aligned Movement and the African Union, have proposed limits on the veto, and adding permanent members is under discussion.
- Uniting for Peace: by resolution 377 A of 3 November 1950, the General Assembly declared that if the Security Council fails to act to keep peace, the Assembly may itself consider the matter and recommend action.
- India's aspiration: the textbook explains India's wish for a permanent seat by its experience of taking the Kashmir question to the UN in the Cold War years and by its self-image as a voice of the developing world.
Worked example 1: will the resolution pass?
A made-up vote in the Security Council: 11 members vote yes, 3 vote no and 1 abstains. Case A: the three 'no' votes are all elected members. 11 ≥ 9 and no permanent member voted no, so the resolution passes. Case B: one of the 'no' votes is a permanent member. The yes votes still reach 11, but a permanent member's 'no' is a veto, so the resolution fails. (In UN practice an abstention by a permanent member is not treated as a veto.)
Worked example 2: which organ?
Decide which organ fits: (a) admitting a new member state and passing the UN budget; (b) ordering sanctions on a state threatening peace; (c) a debate where each head of state speaks in September. Answer: (a) the General Assembly, by two-thirds majority (the Security Council recommends new members first); (b) the Security Council, whose decisions bind members; (c) the General Assembly's general debate.
Key takeaways: the UN grew from the 1942 Declaration, Dumbarton Oaks (1944) and the San Francisco Charter (1945), and began on 24 October 1945. It has four purposes and six main organs. The General Assembly is universal and deliberative with recommendatory resolutions; the Security Council has 15 members, binding decisions and the P-5 veto, which is widely debated.
Check your understanding
-
1. Where did China, the Soviet Union, the United Kingdom and the United States draw up the blueprint of the UN in 1944?
- San Francisco
- Dumbarton Oaks
- Geneva
- The Hague
Show answer
Answer: B. The blueprint was prepared at Dumbarton Oaks between August and October 1944. The Charter itself was signed at San Francisco in June 1945.
-
2. A Security Council draft gets 10 yes votes, 4 no votes and 1 abstention. One of the 'no' votes is from France. What happens?
- It passes, because 10 is more than 9
- It passes, because the majority voted yes
- It fails, because a permanent member voted no
- It goes automatically to the International Court of Justice
Show answer
Answer: C. Ten yes votes clear the nine-vote requirement, but France is a permanent member, and its 'no' vote is a veto. So the resolution fails.
-
3. What is the legal status of a General Assembly resolution, according to the chapter?
- It is a recommendation that carries heavy moral weight
- It binds every member like a Security Council decision
- It becomes law only if the ICJ approves it
- It has no effect at all
Show answer
Answer: A. General Assembly resolutions are recommendations. Because they express the view of most of the world, they carry moral weight and often lead to treaties and conventions.
-
4. Which of these is NOT one of the six main committees of the General Assembly?
- Legal Committee
- Economic and Financial Committee
- Disarmament and International Security Committee
- Peacekeeping Command Committee
Show answer
Answer: D. The six committees are Disarmament and International Security; Economic and Financial; Social, Humanitarian and Cultural; Special Political and Decolonization; Administrative and Budgetary; and Legal. There is no 'Peacekeeping Command Committee'.
-
5. What did the 'Uniting for Peace' resolution of 1950 provide?
- That the veto would be abolished
- That the General Assembly may act when the Security Council fails to keep peace
- That India would become a permanent member
- That the Trusteeship Council would close
Show answer
Answer: B. Resolution 377 A said that when the Security Council fails to exercise its primary responsibility for peace, the General Assembly may consider the matter and recommend action. It did not abolish the veto.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.