- Practice
- About 19 min
- 5 practice questions
Indigenous peoples, their rights and the right to development
Explain why indigeneity is hard to define, the characteristics given by Julian Berger, the Indian approach through Scheduled Tribes, the threats indigenous peoples face, UNDRIP (2007) and the right to development.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain self-identification and list the characteristics of indigenous peoples given by Julian Berger.
- Describe how the idea of indigeneity is understood in India.
- Summarise the threats indigenous peoples face, the main groups of rights in UNDRIP and what the right to development asks of states.
Environmental questions are closely tied to people who live closest to the land. Development projects, mining and forest policy affect them first. The textbook therefore moves from the environment to indigenous peoples and their rights. It estimates, as the book puts it, about 350 million indigenous people of some 5,000 cultures living across about 20 per cent of the Earth's territory.
Who are indigenous peoples?
The hardest problem is the lack of agreement on who is indigenous. Even the UN working group on indigenous rights could not settle on a formal definition, because no fixed set of tests fits every group. Is it small numbers, long attachment to one's land, or a non-industrial way of life? There is no international agreement on a definition; communities decide for themselves, which is called self-identification. Agreement is easier for some groups, such as the First Nations of North America, the peoples of the Amazon forests, the Inuit of the far North and indigenous groups of Papua New Guinea.
The textbook gives weight to a description by Julian Berger, a UN official, for whom belonging to a separate culture (language, religion, social and political systems, values, knowledge, laws, economy, art, music, dress and so on) is central. In his account indigenous peoples:
- descend from the original inhabitants of a territory overcome by conquest;
- are often nomadic or semi-nomadic, such as shifting cultivators, herders and hunter-gatherers, with labour-intensive farming that produces little surplus and needs little energy;
- lack centralised political institutions, organising at the community level and deciding by consensus;
- share a language, religion and culture and a link to a territory, like a national minority, but are dominated by another culture and society;
- hold a custodial, non-materialist view of land and resources and want a development path different from the dominant society's;
- consider themselves indigenous and are accepted as such by the group.
The textbook adds a careful point: indigenous peoples generally lack political power and inclusion, but their powerlessness comes from their distinct position, not the other way round. They are not 'socially static'; the charge of conservatism, it says, reflects only their slower adjustment to ever more complex societies. International Day of the World's Indigenous Peoples is observed on 9 August.
| Community | Region |
|---|---|
| Inuit | Canada, Arctic, Alaska, Greenland |
| Yanomami | Amazon Basin |
| Maori | New Zealand |
| Sami | Scandinavia |
| Vedda | Sri Lanka |
| Jarawas | Andaman Islands |
| Aborigines | Australia |
| Ainu | Japan |
| Chittagong Hill Tribes | Bangladesh |
Indigeneity in India
The textbook notes that the Government of India hardly recognises any community officially as 'indigenous'. Experts, it says, build an Indian approach on three assumptions: such groups (a) lived in the region before colonisation or conquest by outsiders, (b) became marginalised as a result, and (c) live more by their own social, economic and cultural institutions than by the general law. In India the idea overlaps with tribal consciousness. These communities are called Adivasis (original inhabitants), Adim Jati, Vanavasi and other names; the Constitution recognises them as Scheduled Tribes and their areas as Scheduled Areas. A working description uses features such as distinctive culture, geographical isolation, shyness of contact with the wider community and backwardness, and covers groups from the Gonds and Bhils, numbering millions, to the Great Andamanese, only dozens. The textbook quotes the scholar Sharad Kulkarni (1988), who described lost habitats, exploitation and weak protective laws, but also activists' efforts and some 'rays of hope'.
Threats faced by indigenous peoples
Threats and issues listed in the chapter
-
Land
- Eviction and denial of land rights
- Forced resettlement and displacement
- Loss of access to traditional resources
-
Culture
- Discrimination and structural violence
- Exploitation of traditional arts and stories
-
Politics
- Autonomy and self-determination
- Few countries recognise them
- Minimal political participation
- Neglect by civil society
-
Welfare
- Poverty
- Health problems
- Unemployment
UNDRIP, 2007
The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples was adopted by the General Assembly on 13 September 2007. It has 46 Articles, came out of drafting begun in 1985 by the Working Group on Indigenous Populations, and sets a universal framework of minimum standards for the survival, dignity and well-being of indigenous peoples. It also supports other instruments such as the Convention on the Rights of the Child, ILO Convention 169 and CEDAW.
| Articles | Theme | Examples of rights |
|---|---|---|
| 1-6 | Human rights, self-determination, nationality | All human rights; self-determination; autonomy or self-government; nationality |
| 7-10 | Life, liberty, culture, security | Against forced assimilation; against forced removal or relocation |
| 11-13 | Culture, religion, language | Spiritual traditions; languages, histories and oral traditions |
| 14-17 | Education, media, employment | Own educational systems; own-language media |
| 18-24 | Participation and development | Free, prior and informed consent; health; own development priorities |
| 25-32 | Land and resources | Own and control traditional lands; redress for land taken without consent |
| 33-37 | Self-government and indigenous laws | Own institutions; recognition of treaties |
| 38-42 | Implementation | Consultation by states; duties on the UN system and the Permanent Forum |
| 43-44 | Nature of guarantee | Rights are minimum standards; equal for men and women |
The right to development
The textbook argues that trade, investment, finance, aid, debt, technology and global governance all affect the right to development, whose aim is freedom from fear and freedom from want for everyone. It cites the Marrakesh Agreement establishing the WTO, which links trade with higher living standards, full employment and sustainable use of resources. States, including as members of the WTO and development banks, should build human rights into trade and investment agreements, and aid and lending should be adequate, effective, transparent, participatory and aimed at those most in need.
Worked example 1: apply the Declaration
A made-up case: a company plans a mine on a forest community's traditional land, and the government approves it without asking the community. Analysis: UNDRIP's land and participation articles call for the community's free, prior and informed consent, and for redress or compensation if land is taken without it. The right against forced removal (Articles 7-10) also applies if people would be moved.
Worked example 2: self-identification
Question: Why does international practice rely on self-identification? Reasoning: (1) no list of tests (numbers, lifestyle, location) fits every group; (2) an outside definition could exclude real communities or impose an identity on them; (3) so a group's own sense of identity, accepted by its members, is treated as decisive, as Berger's sixth point says.
Key takeaways: there is no agreed definition of indigenous peoples, so self-identification is used; Berger lists six characteristics. India does not officially use the term, but Scheduled Tribes and tribal consciousness shape the debate. Indigenous peoples face threats to land, culture, politics and welfare. UNDRIP (2007, 46 Articles) sets minimum standards, and the right to development asks states to put human rights into trade, aid and lending.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is meant by 'self-identification' in the context of indigenous peoples?
- Indigenous communities decide for themselves whether they are indigenous
- The UN issues identity cards to indigenous people
- Governments decide who is indigenous
- Only groups below a fixed population count are indigenous
Show answer
Answer: A. Because there is no internationally agreed definition, indigenous communities decide their own indigeneity. That is self-identification.
-
2. On which date is the International Day of the World's Indigenous Peoples observed?
- 15 August
- 6 August
- 26 August
- 9 August
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter states that the day is celebrated on 9 August every year.
-
3. Under the Indian Constitution, indigenous communities are recognised as:
- Scheduled Castes
- Scheduled Tribes
- Other Backward Classes
- National Minorities
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says that under the Constitution they are recognised as Scheduled Tribes and their territories as Scheduled Areas.
-
4. How many Articles does the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (2007) contain?
- 17
- 30
- 46
- 169
Show answer
Answer: C. UNDRIP has 46 Articles. Seventeen and 169 are the numbers of SDGs and targets; 30 is the number of articles in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
-
5. Which right in UNDRIP is most directly at stake when a dam is planned on indigenous land without asking the community?
- Right to create media in their own language
- Right to nationality
- Right to free, prior and informed consent
- Right to employment
Show answer
Answer: C. UNDRIP repeatedly requires free, prior and informed consent for laws, policies and use of indigenous land, with redress for land taken without it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.