• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

India and the great powers: the United States and Russia

Trace India's relations with the United States from wartime contacts to the strategic partnership and civil nuclear agreement, and India's relations with the Soviet Union and Russia from 1955 to the Special and Privileged Strategic Partnership.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why India-US relations were distant during the Cold War and how they improved after 1991.
  • Describe the India-US civil nuclear (123) agreement.
  • Trace India-Soviet and India-Russia relations: the 1955 visits, the 1971 treaty, the 1993 treaty and the partnerships of 2000 and 2010.

For most of the Cold War, India was closer to Moscow than to Washington. Since the 1990s, India has built strong ties with both. This lesson follows the textbook's account of how India's relations with the two great powers changed.

India and the USA: distant beginnings

Formal contact began during the Second World War: in 1940 envoys were exchanged (Thomas Wilson and Sir Girija Shankar Bajpai) and an office opened in Delhi; full diplomatic relations followed in 1946 under President Harry S. Truman. Several things kept the two apart, in the textbook's account:

  • Kashmir at the UN: Pakistan contested Kashmir's accession; the UN took up the issue in 1948 and set up the UN Commission for India and Pakistan (UNCIP). India criticised the roles of the USA and the UK.
  • Military alliances: the US-sponsored SEATO and CENTO, and Pakistan's membership and military pact with the USA, left little room for closeness.
  • Aid and pressure: India received food under PL-480 (agreements from 1954) and sought economic help, but the textbook says the USA tried to influence India's economic programmes.
  • Nuclear tests: after India's tests in May 1998, the USA imposed economic sanctions, lifted in 2001.

A new partnership after the Cold War

The textbook says India's democracy, its large population with IT and English skills, and the rise of Asia changed American views. A new strategic partnership began in the 1990s. India welcomed the US position during the Kargil conflict of 1999, when, the textbook says, the USA did not back Pakistan for violating the Line of Control. A US presidential visit in 2000 signalled a new era, and cooperation spread to science and technology, climate, education, health and disaster relief. Later years brought a defence framework (2005), the first strategic dialogue (2010) and US recognition of India as a major defence partner (2016).

The India-US Civil Nuclear Agreement, known as the 123 Agreement, grew from a joint statement of 18 July 2005. India agreed to separate its civil and military nuclear facilities and place all civil facilities under International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) safeguards; in return the USA agreed to work for full civil nuclear cooperation. 'Sensitive' enrichment and reprocessing technology was excluded. The US Senate approved the agreement on 1 October 2008, allowing India to buy nuclear fuel and technology. The textbook also notes possible roadblocks: trade and technology disputes and US pressure on India's traditional ties with Iran, which India balances in pursuit of an autonomous foreign policy.

India and the Soviet Union (1947-1991)

At first, the Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin doubted India's non-alignment. Friendship grew with Nehru's visit to the USSR in June 1955 and Nikita Khrushchev's visit to India in December 1955. The textbook says the Soviet Union respected India's strategic autonomy, and cooperation grew in metallurgy, defence, energy and trade, at the time India adopted planning and a socialistic pattern of society. The Indo-Soviet Treaty of Peace, Friendship and Cooperation (1971) was a landmark. In the 1971 war the USSR firmly supported India and sent ships to the Indian Ocean to counter the US Seventh Fleet in the Bay of Bengal; the emergence of Bangladesh cemented trust.

India and Russia (1991-present)

India-Russia relations after 1991
YearDevelopment in the textbook
1991Soviet Union collapses; the 1971 Treaty becomes ineffective; a period of uncertainty and 'benign neglect'
1993New Treaty of Friendship signed during President Boris Yeltsin's visit; only regular consultation, no 'special relationship'
2000Declaration on Strategic Partnership; annual summits begin
2010Raised to a 'Special and Privileged Strategic Partnership'

Today, the textbook says, defence is the strongest pillar: India is the largest importer of Russian defence equipment, and Russia shares high-end defence technology. The two cooperate in nuclear energy, oil and gas, space, science and technology, the UN, BRICS and the SCO, and on the International North-South Transport Corridor. Russia supports India's claim to a permanent seat on the UN Security Council and, the textbook says, has supported India on the Kashmir issue.

India's ties with the two great powers

  • United States
    • Distant in the Cold War: Kashmir at UN, SEATO and CENTO, PL-480
    • Sanctions after 1998 tests, lifted 2001
    • Strategic partnership from the 1990s
    • 123 civil nuclear agreement (2005-2008)
  • Soviet Union / Russia
    • Friendship from the 1955 visits
    • 1971 Treaty and support in the 1971 war
    • Uncertainty after 1991; 1993 treaty
    • Strategic partnership 2000; special and privileged 2010

123 Agreement: India separated civil and military nuclear facilities and placed civil ones under IAEA safeguards, in return for civil nuclear cooperation with the USA.

Worked example 1: why did the USSR matter in 1971?

Reasoning from the textbook: in 1971 India had just signed the Treaty of Peace, Friendship and Cooperation. When the USA sent its Seventh Fleet into the Bay of Bengal, Soviet ships moved into the Indian Ocean to counter it. The textbook links the war's outcome and the emergence of Bangladesh to a lasting trusted partnership with the USSR.

Worked example 2: what did India give and get in the 123 Agreement?

Working: India gave (1) a separation of civil and military facilities and (2) IAEA safeguards on all civil facilities. India got (1) the possibility of buying nuclear fuel and technology and (2) broad civil cooperation. It did not get 'sensitive' enrichment and reprocessing technology, which the deal excluded.

Key takeaways: India-US relations were cool during the Cold War because of Kashmir at the UN, US alliances that included Pakistan and US pressure; after 1991 they became a strategic partnership, with the 123 civil nuclear agreement (2005-2008) as a milestone. India-Soviet ties grew from 1955 and peaked with the 1971 Treaty; after a dip in the 1990s, India and Russia formed a strategic partnership in 2000, raised to a special and privileged one in 2010, with defence as the main pillar.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which US-sponsored alliances, according to the textbook, widened the gap between India and the USA?

    1. SAARC and ASEAN
    2. SEATO and CENTO
    3. BRICS and SCO
    4. NAM and the Commonwealth
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The formation of SEATO and CENTO, and Pakistan's inclusion and military pact with the USA, left little hope of improved relations.

  2. 2. Under the 123 Agreement, India agreed to

    1. leave the Non-Aligned Movement
    2. give up all nuclear weapons immediately
    3. buy only American defence equipment
    4. separate its civil and military nuclear facilities and place civil ones under IAEA safeguards
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The 18 July 2005 framework required India to separate civil and military facilities and place all civil facilities under IAEA safeguards, in exchange for civil nuclear cooperation.

  3. 3. In which year was the Indo-Soviet Treaty of Peace, Friendship and Cooperation signed?

    1. 1955
    2. 1962
    3. 1993
    4. 1971
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The treaty was signed in 1971, a landmark just before the 1971 war. 1955 saw the Nehru and Khrushchev visits; 1993 a new treaty with Russia.

  4. 4. What was India-Russia relations raised to in 2010?

    1. A military alliance
    2. A New Treaty of Friendship
    3. A Special and Privileged Strategic Partnership
    4. A free trade area
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The 2000 Declaration on Strategic Partnership was elevated to a 'Special and Privileged Strategic Partnership' in 2010.

  5. 5. Why did the textbook describe Russia's attitude to India in the early 1990s as 'benign neglect'?

    1. Russia had joined SEATO
    2. Russia had broken off diplomatic relations
    3. Russia was focused on domestic affairs and on the USA and Europe, and lacked interest and resources for ties with India
    4. Russia supported Pakistan in a war
    Show answer

    Answer: C. After 1991, Russia turned to its own problems and to the West; the 1993 treaty called only for consultation, and the textbook calls this period one of benign neglect.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → India, the European Union and Japan

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery