• Practice
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Indirect elections and the election of the President

Explain indirect elections, describe the electoral college that elects the President of India, and compare the merits and demerits of indirect and direct elections.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define an indirect election with an example.
  • Identify who is and who is not part of the electoral college for the President.
  • Compare the merits and demerits of indirect elections.

Not every office in India is filled by people voting directly. For some posts, the people elect representatives, and those representatives then elect the office-holder. This two-step method is an indirect election.

What is an indirect election?

In an indirect (representative) election, voters first elect their representatives, who in turn elect the person to the office. The textbook's main example is the election of the President of India. The Rajya Sabha, which you met in Unit 1, is also chosen indirectly by state and Union Territory legislators.

How the President of India is elected

  1. Citizens vote They elect MPs to Parliament and MLAs to state and UT assemblies
  2. Electoral college forms Elected members of both Houses of Parliament + elected members of the legislative assemblies of all states and UTs (with legislatures)
  3. Electoral college votes It elects the President
Two steps: the people elect legislators, and the elected legislators elect the President.

Important note: nominated members of either House of Parliament or of state legislative assemblies are not part of the electoral college. Only elected members vote for the President.

Merits and demerits

Merits of indirect electionsDemerits of indirect elections
Less expensive than direct electionsWhen the number of voters is very small, there is a risk of corruption, bribery and horse-trading (buying the votes of representatives)
More suited to large countriesLess democratic, because people do not choose directly and the result may not reflect their true will

Direct and indirect elections side by side

  • Direct
    • People vote for the office-holder
    • Examples: MPs (Lok Sabha), MLAs, local bodies
    • More democratic but expensive
  • Indirect
    • People elect representatives, who choose the office-holder
    • Examples: President, Rajya Sabha members
    • Cheaper, but small electorate risks horse-trading

President of India: elected by ELECTED MPs and ELECTED MLAs. Nominated members do not vote.

Worked example 1: who votes?

Case (made up): Four people: (a) an elected MP of the Lok Sabha; (b) a member nominated to the Rajya Sabha for her work in music; (c) an elected MLA of Tamil Nadu; (d) a voter in Madurai. Reasoning: Only elected members of Parliament and of the state/UT assemblies form the electoral college. A nominated member and an ordinary voter are not part of it. Answer: (a) and (c) vote for the President; (b) and (d) do not.

Worked example 2: why is a small electorate risky?

Question: Why does the textbook say corruption is a danger when the number of voters is very small? Reasoning: When crores vote, no one can buy enough votes to change the result. When only a few hundred representatives vote, persuading or buying a handful can swing the outcome. Answer: a small electorate makes horse-trading and bribery easier.

Key takeaways: In an indirect election, people elect representatives who choose the office-holder. The President of India is elected by an electoral college of elected MPs and elected MLAs of states and UTs; nominated members are excluded. Indirect elections are cheaper and suit large countries, but are less democratic and open to horse-trading.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which office in India is filled by an indirect election, according to the textbook?

    1. Member of the Lok Sabha
    2. Member of a village panchayat
    3. Member of the Legislative Assembly
    4. President of India
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The President is elected by an electoral college of elected legislators, not directly by the people.

  2. 2. Which of these persons is NOT part of the electoral college for the President?

    1. An elected member of the Rajya Sabha
    2. An elected member of the Lok Sabha
    3. A nominated member of the Rajya Sabha
    4. An elected member of a state legislative assembly
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Nominated members of either House or of the assemblies are not included; only elected members vote.

  3. 3. Which is a merit of indirect elections?

    1. Less expensive
    2. More democratic than direct elections
    3. Removes all chance of bribery
    4. Every citizen votes for the office-holder
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Indirect elections cost less and suit large countries. They are less democratic and more open to horse-trading.

  4. 4. 'Horse-trading' in an indirect election means:

    1. Holding elections at cattle fairs
    2. Buying or improperly influencing the votes of representatives
    3. Counting votes by hand
    4. Using animals as election symbols
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Horse-trading is the bargaining for, or buying of, representatives' votes, which is easier when the electorate is small.

  5. 5. Why are indirect elections called less democratic?

    1. They are held less often
    2. Only women vote
    3. People do not elect the office-holder themselves, so the result may not reflect their will
    4. They are conducted by the courts
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Representatives choose on the people's behalf, so the people's own choice is one step removed.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery