- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Purpose and feedback: hard mixed assessment scenarios
Untangle scenarios where one assessment serves several purposes, judge which feedback actually improves learning, and choose the best assessment decision under exam pressure.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Earlier courses classified an assessment by its purpose. Advanced questions make this harder: one test serves two purposes, the scenario is long, or the options differ only in the quality of the feedback given. This lesson adds two tools to the purpose method: separating the uses of one assessment, and judging feedback.
One assessment, several uses
The same evidence can be used in more than one way. A term test can be summative for the report card and also formative if the teacher analyses the common errors and re-teaches them in the next term. A portfolio can show growth (formative) and be graded at the end (summative). When a question asks which use is described, find the verb that describes what is done with the results: recorded, reported, certified point to summative; re-taught, adjusted, planned point to formative; reflected, set goals, self-corrected point to assessment as learning. If the question asks about the assessment's main purpose, pick the use that the scenario emphasises.
What makes feedback formative
Assessment is formative only if its information is used to close the gap between where learners are and where they need to be. Feedback does this when it is specific (it names what is right and what is missing), timely (it arrives while the learner can still act on it), focused on the task, not the person, and forward-looking (it says what to do next). Feedback such as 'Good', '6/10' or 'Try harder' is evaluative: it judges but does not show the way forward. Research on formative assessment, notably by Paul Black and Dylan Wiliam, is widely cited for the finding that well-used formative assessment improves learning; you do not need any figures, only the principle.
| Feedback | Type | Why |
|---|---|---|
| '7/10. Good effort.' | Evaluative | A judgement with no next step |
| 'Your diagram is labelled correctly; add arrows to show the direction of water flow.' | Descriptive (formative) | Specific and says what to do next |
| 'You are a clever girl.' | Person-focused praise | About the person, not the task |
| 'Compare your answer with step 3 of the model; where did your method change?' | Descriptive, prompts self-assessment | Moves the learner towards assessment as learning |
Peer and self-assessment done well
Peer and self-assessment work when learners know the criteria, ideally from a rubric or examples of good work, and when the aim is improvement rather than marks. Without shared criteria, they become guesswork or popularity contests. Teachers build the skill gradually: first judging anonymous samples together, then peers' work with prompts, and finally their own work.
Worked example 1
At the end of term, a teacher records marks in the report card, then studies the answer scripts and finds that most students confused area with perimeter. In the first week of the next term, she re-teaches the difference with grid paper. Step 1: uses: recording marks (summative), and using error patterns to re-teach (formative). Step 2: the question asks what her analysis and re-teaching show. Answer: a summative test being used formatively, which is assessment for learning.
Worked example 2
Four teachers respond to the same weak paragraph. Which response is most formative? (i) '5/10'. (ii) 'Poor; rewrite.' (iii) 'Your first sentence states the main idea clearly. The next two sentences do not support it; replace them with one example from the story.' (iv) 'Well done for trying.' Step 1: check specificity: only (iii) names a strength and a gap. Step 2: check next step: only (iii) says what to do. Answer: (iii). The others are evaluative or person-focused.
Name each use of the evidence by what is done with it. Feedback is formative only if it is specific, timely, about the task and tells the learner what to do next.
Key takeaways
- One assessment can serve summative and formative uses; read the verbs.
- A summative test becomes formative when its error analysis drives re-teaching.
- Descriptive feedback names strengths, gaps and next steps; marks alone are evaluative.
- Peer and self-assessment need shared criteria.
- Feedback should be about the task, not the person.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which feedback is most likely to improve a student's next attempt?
- 'Your method is right, but you forgot to convert centimetres to metres in step 2; redo that step.'
- '8/10, which is a good score; keep it up and try the next paper in the same way.'
- 'Excellent work, you are very bright and clearly one of the best students in the class.'
- 'Needs improvement; please be more careful and work harder before the next test comes.'
Show answer
Answer: A. It is specific, about the task, and says exactly what to do next.
-
2. A teacher uses last year's final examination papers to find common errors and plans this year's teaching around them. Here the summative results are being used:
- Only summatively, since they are final results
- For placement of individual students
- Formatively, to improve teaching and learning
- As assessment as learning
Show answer
Answer: C. Using results to plan teaching is a formative use, even of summative data.
-
3. Peer assessment is most effective when:
- Learners share clear criteria and aim at improvement
- Peers give only marks to each other, with no comments or reasons for the marks
- Friends are paired together to mark each other, so that they feel at ease with it
- It replaces all of the teacher's feedback, so that the teacher need not mark the work
Show answer
Answer: A. Shared criteria and an improvement focus make peer judgements accurate and useful.
-
4. Feedback that comments on a learner's personal qualities rather than the work is:
- Person-focused, and less useful for improving the task
- Descriptive feedback, which is more useful for improving the task
- Diagnostic feedback, which is more useful for improving the task
- Criterion-referenced feedback, which is more useful for improving the task
Show answer
Answer: A. Comments about the person do not tell the learner how to improve the work.
-
5. Which pair is correctly matched?
- 'Recorded in the report card': assessment for learning
- 'Re-taught the next day': assessment of learning
- 'Certified for promotion': assessment as learning
- 'Self-corrected using a checklist': assessment as learning
Show answer
Answer: D. Learners correcting their own work with criteria is assessment as learning; recording and certifying are 'of', re-teaching is 'for'.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.