| Feedback | Type | Why |
|---|---|---|
| '7/10. Good effort.' | Evaluative | A judgement with no next step |
| 'Your diagram is labelled correctly; add arrows to show the direction of water flow.' | Descriptive (formative) | Specific and says what to do next |
| 'You are a clever girl.' | Person-focused praise | About the person, not the task |
| 'Compare your answer with step 3 of the model; where did your method change?' | Descriptive, prompts self-assessment | Moves the learner towards assessment as learning |
Name each use of the evidence by what is done with it. Feedback is formative only if it is specific, timely, about the task and tells the learner what to do next.
- One assessment can serve summative and formative uses; read the verbs.
- A summative test becomes formative when its error analysis drives re-teaching.
- Descriptive feedback names strengths, gaps and next steps; marks alone are evaluative.
- Peer and self-assessment need shared criteria.
- Feedback should be about the task, not the person.