- Advanced
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Finding the cause behind persistent misbehaviour
Analyse a pattern of persistent misbehaviour by asking when, where and what follows it, and choose a response that removes the cause.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Foundation and practice courses taught what to do in the moment. Advanced questions go further: a pupil misbehaves again and again, simple corrections have failed, and the item asks what the teacher should conclude or do next. The key skill is to treat behaviour as information. Persistent misbehaviour usually serves a purpose for the pupil or signals an unmet need, and the best response removes that cause.
Look for the pattern
A teacher can learn a great deal by noting three things over several days: when the behaviour happens (which subject, which activity, which time of day), what happens just before it (a difficult task, a reprimand, a change of activity), and what happens just after it (the class laughs, the teacher gives attention, the pupil is sent out and escapes the task). The pattern often points to the cause more reliably than the pupil's explanation.
Common causes and matching responses
| Likely cause | Typical clue | Response that fits |
|---|---|---|
| Seeking attention | Behaviour stops when the teacher attends; occurs when ignored for long | Give attention for good behaviour; ignore minor attention-seeking; give a responsibility |
| Avoiding a task | Starts when difficult work begins; ends when pupil is sent out | Break task into steps, give support; do not remove the pupil from the task |
| Work too easy | Pupil finishes fast, then disturbs others | Extension tasks, leadership roles |
| Unclear expectations | Many pupils do it, especially during transitions | Re-teach the routine |
| Personal or physical need | Sudden change; tiredness; hunger; distress | Private talk; involve parents or counsellor |
The hidden trap: a consequence that rewards
Sending a pupil out of the room seems like a punishment, but if the pupil wanted to escape a difficult task, it actually gives them what they wanted, and the behaviour will increase. Similarly, a long public scolding can reward a pupil who wanted the class's attention. Advanced questions often hide this trap in an option that sounds firm.
Note that finding the cause does not mean excusing the behaviour. The pupil is still expected to follow the class rules, and the teacher still responds calmly when they are broken. The difference is that the response is designed to make the behaviour unnecessary, so that it fades instead of returning in a new form.
Worked example 1
Scenario: 'Every maths period, as soon as written practice begins, Aman starts making jokes and is sent to the corridor. This has happened for three weeks and is getting worse.' Working: when? At the start of written practice. What follows? He leaves the task. The pattern suggests he is avoiding work he finds hard, and sending him out rewards the avoidance, which is why it is getting worse. The best response is to keep him in the task with support: break the practice into smaller steps, check his first answer quickly, and praise effort. Sending him out again, or giving him more of the same practice as punishment, would not address the cause.
Worked example 2
Scenario: 'Sonal finishes her work in five minutes and then chats with her neighbours. Reminders work for a minute only.' Options: give her extension problems or a peer-helper role; seat her alone at the back; take marks off her work; ignore the chatting. Working: the clue is that she finishes very fast, so the cause is likely work that is too easy and idle time. Seating her alone or taking marks off addresses neither the cause nor the disturbance to others, and ignoring lets it continue. The best answer is extension problems or a peer-helper role.
Behaviour is information: note when it happens, what comes before and what follows. Remove the cause, and never let the 'punishment' give the pupil what the behaviour was seeking.
Key takeaways
When simple corrections fail, study the pattern of when, before and after. Common causes are attention, task avoidance, work that is too easy, unclear routines, and personal needs. Match the response to the cause, and watch for consequences, such as sending a pupil out, that reward the behaviour they are meant to stop.
Check your understanding
-
1. A pupil misbehaves every time a hard task begins and is regularly sent outside. Why might the behaviour be increasing?
- Being sent out lets the pupil escape the task, which rewards the behaviour
- The pupil is not being punished often enough, because the teacher is too lenient
- Hard tasks should never be given to a pupil who finds them upsetting
- The pupil actually wants more homework, so the task is too short
Show answer
Answer: A. If the behaviour's function is escape, removal from the task reinforces it.
-
2. Many pupils become noisy every time they move from desks to groups. The most likely cause is:
- every pupil seeking attention separately
- an unclear or untaught transition routine
- work that is far too easy for all of them
- a personal problem of each single pupil
Show answer
Answer: B. When many pupils misbehave at the same point, look first at the routine for that point.
-
3. A pupil calls out silly comments and stops whenever the teacher speaks to him. Which response best fits the likely cause?
- Scold him at length each time so that he learns that the comments are not allowed
- Ask the class to laugh along with him so that the comments seem like harmless fun
- Give attention when he behaves well and give minimal attention to silly comments
- Send him to another class for the rest of the term so that he cannot disturb this one
Show answer
Answer: C. The pattern suggests attention-seeking; attention should follow good behaviour instead.
-
4. Which three things should a teacher note to understand a pattern of behaviour?
- The pupil's marks, caste and religion in the last three examinations
- The parents' jobs, income and address recorded in the admission form
- Only what the pupil says about it when asked, taken as the whole account
- When it happens, what happens just before, and what happens just after
Show answer
Answer: D. These three observations reveal triggers and what maintains the behaviour.
-
5. A capable pupil finishes early and disturbs others. The best response is:
- to make her repeat the same task again and again
- to give extension work or a responsibility
- to seat her alone at the back of the room
- to cut marks from her work for disturbing
Show answer
Answer: B. The cause is idle time from easy work; extension removes it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.