- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Reading the models of disability in hard statements
Identify the medical and social models of disability inside long, loaded statements, and pick the policy or teacher action each model leads to, even when the wording is designed to mislead.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The foundation and practice courses taught what the medical and social models say. Advanced questions rarely ask for definitions. Instead they give a paragraph written by a headteacher, a parent or a policy committee and ask which model lies behind it, or which action follows from it. The wording is often mixed: a statement may use friendly language yet locate the problem entirely in the child. This lesson gives you a reliable test for such statements and practises it on hard cases.
The location test
Every statement about disability places the problem somewhere. Ask one question: where does the statement say the difficulty lives? If it lives inside the person, as a defect to be diagnosed, treated or cured before the person can take part, the statement follows the medical model. If it lives in the surroundings, such as steps without a ramp, print without Braille, rigid timetables, or attitudes of pity and low expectation, the statement follows the social model. The social model does not deny that impairments exist; it separates the impairment (a condition of the body or mind) from the disability (the exclusion that results when society does not adjust).
| Clue in the statement | Points to |
|---|---|
| 'Suffers from', 'is confined to a wheelchair', 'cannot be taught until treated' | Medical model |
| 'Barriers', 'access', 'the school must adjust', 'participation' | Social model |
| Kind words, but the child must change or be placed apart | Medical model in friendly clothing |
| Diagnosis used to plan support inside the ordinary class | Compatible with the social model |
Why the model matters for teachers
The model a school holds decides what it changes. A medical-model school waits for therapy to 'fix' the child and often recommends a special setting. A social-model school asks which barriers in its building, materials, teaching and attitudes stop the child from learning and removes them. That is why inclusive education, universal design for learning and the rights-based approach in modern disability law all rest on the social model. Remember that the RPwD Act 2016 lists 21 disabilities; exams use it as an example of a rights-based law, not as a source of medical labels.
Trap: diagnosis is not the medical model
A common trap offers a statement such as 'The school arranged an assessment of the child's hearing so that it could seat him well and use captions in videos.' Some candidates call this medical because it mentions an assessment. It is not. Information about an impairment is useful; the question is what it is used for. If the diagnosis is used to remove barriers inside the shared classroom, the thinking is social-model. If it is used to decide that the child does not belong until treated, it is medical-model.
Worked example 1
Statement: 'We love having Meena with us, poor thing. Once her speech therapy is complete and she can speak like the others, she can join group discussions.' Step 1: where is the problem? In Meena's speech, which must be corrected first. Step 2: what changes? Nothing in the class; Meena waits. Step 3: the affectionate tone ('we love having her', 'poor thing') is pity, which is itself an attitudinal barrier. Answer: medical model, with a charity-style tone. A social-model response would let her take part now, using picture cards, writing or gestures alongside speech.
Worked example 2
A committee writes: 'Students with low vision fail science because diagrams are printed small and the board is far away. We will provide enlarged diagrams, tactile models and spoken descriptions in every science lesson.' Step 1: the cause of failure is placed in the printed material and the classroom layout. Step 2: the school changes the material and teaching, for every lesson, not as a favour. Answer: social model. Notice that the committee still names an impairment (low vision); naming it does not make the statement medical.
Find where the statement locates the problem. Inside the child, to be fixed first: medical model. In barriers the school can remove: social model. Kind words do not change the answer.
Key takeaways
- Apply the location test, not the tone test.
- Impairment is a condition; disability is the exclusion that follows when barriers remain.
- Diagnosis used to plan support in the class fits the social model; diagnosis used as a gate fits the medical model.
- Pity is an attitudinal barrier, not inclusion.
- Inclusive education, UDL and rights-based law all rest on the social model.
Check your understanding
-
1. A headteacher says: 'Children who use wheelchairs cannot attend our school because our classrooms are upstairs.' Which reading reflects the social model?
- The children's impairment is the barrier, so they need a special school where they can learn separately
- The school has done nothing wrong because it did not create the impairment and need not change
- The children should wait until they can use stairs, and the school should then admit them
- The stairs and the room allocation are the barrier, and the school should move classes or build access
Show answer
Answer: D. The social model places the problem in the environment. Here the barrier is the upstairs classroom, which the school can change.
-
2. Which statement follows the medical model even though it sounds caring?
- 'He is such a brave boy; once his treatment finishes, he can sit with the class.'
- 'We added captions to all videos so that every child can follow them.'
- 'The class now uses picture timetables that help everyone.'
- 'We changed the seating so that she can lip-read the teacher.'
Show answer
Answer: A. The caring words hide the fact that he must be treated before he can take part, which locates the problem in the child.
-
3. A school assesses a child's hearing and then uses captions and front seating for her. This shows:
- The medical model, because any assessment of a child is a medical act
- Segregation, because she is given different seating from the other pupils
- Exclusion, because she is singled out from the rest of the class
- The social model, because the assessment is used to remove barriers in class
Show answer
Answer: D. Information about an impairment is used to plan support inside the shared classroom, which fits the social model.
-
4. In the social model, 'disability' refers to:
- The physical or mental condition of the person concerned
- The exclusion that results when society does not remove barriers
- A medical diagnosis made by a doctor or a specialist
- A permanent lack of ability to learn in an ordinary school
Show answer
Answer: B. The social model separates impairment (the condition) from disability (the exclusion caused by barriers).
-
5. Which policy most clearly rests on the medical model?
- Making all new school buildings fully accessible to every learner from the day they open
- Training teachers in universal design for learning so that lessons reach all learners
- Admitting children with disabilities only after a doctor certifies them 'fit for normal classes'
- Providing learning materials in several formats so that every learner can use them
Show answer
Answer: C. Requiring the child to be certified 'normal' before admission makes the child, not the school, responsible for fitting in.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.