- Advanced
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Four theories under pressure: fine distinctions and mixed items
Separate the four major theories of language development on their finer terms, such as mand and tact, competence and performance, and inner speech, and solve mixed multi-statement items quickly.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The foundation and practice courses taught the four big names: Skinner, Chomsky, Piaget and Vygotsky, with the evidence each one explains. Harder questions no longer ask which theorist believed in imitation. They put two theories in one statement, use the theorists' own technical terms, or give four statements and ask which are correct. This lesson adds the finer vocabulary and a method for working through such items without being caught by a half-true option.
Skinner's finer terms
In his account of verbal behaviour, Skinner sorted speech by what controls it and what reinforces it. A mand is an utterance that asks for something and is reinforced by getting it: a child says 'water' and is given water. A tact names something the speaker is in contact with: the child sees a dog, says 'dog', and is reinforced by an adult's approval. An echoic response simply repeats what was heard, as when a toddler copies 'bye-bye'. All three are learned through reinforcement, which is why the theory places so much weight on the environment and on adults who reward speech.
Chomsky's finer terms
Chomsky separated competence, the speaker's unconscious knowledge of the rules of a language, from performance, the actual speech produced, with its slips, hesitations and false starts. A child's speech may contain errors of performance while the underlying rule knowledge is sound. His poverty of the stimulus argument says that the speech children hear is too limited and untidy to explain the rich grammar they end up with, so something must be built in: the language acquisition device and a universal grammar shared by all human languages. When an item mentions sentences a child has never heard before, think of Chomsky.
Piaget and Vygotsky: the direction of influence
For Piaget, thought comes first and language reflects it. Young children's egocentric speech, talking aloud without adjusting to a listener, shows the egocentrism of their thinking and fades as thinking becomes social. For Vygotsky, language and thought begin separately and then join; talk first used with others turns into private speech that guides the child's own action, and finally into silent inner speech. So the same observation, a child muttering while doing a puzzle, is read by Piaget as a sign of immaturity and by Vygotsky as a tool of self-guidance that becomes more common when a task is hard.
| Clue in the item | Theory it points to |
|---|---|
| Reward, imitation, shaping, mand, tact, echoic | Skinner (behaviourist) |
| Inborn device, universal grammar, competence, novel sentences | Chomsky (nativist) |
| Egocentric speech, language reflects thought, stages of thinking | Piaget (cognitive constructivist) |
| Private or inner speech, ZPD, help from a more knowledgeable other | Vygotsky (social constructivist) |
A method for multi-statement items
Read every statement on its own and mark it true or false before looking at the option list. A statement is false if it gives the right term to the wrong theorist, reverses a direction (for example 'Vygotsky held that thought determines language'), or overstates a claim ('Chomsky said the environment plays no part'). Then pick the option that matches your marks exactly. Elimination is faster than recall: one statement you are sure is false usually removes two options.
Worked example 1: a four-statement item
Statements: (1) Skinner treated a request reinforced by the thing requested as a mand. (2) Chomsky's competence refers to the errors a child makes while speaking. (3) Piaget saw egocentric speech as a reflection of the child's thinking. (4) Vygotsky held that private speech gradually becomes inner speech. Working: statement 1 is true by definition. Statement 2 is false, because errors in actual speech belong to performance, not competence. Statement 3 is true. Statement 4 is true. So the correct choice is 1, 3 and 4 only. Notice how one confusion, competence versus performance, is the whole trap.
Worked example 2: an assertion-reason item
Assertion: Children produce sentences they have never heard. Reason: Language is learned only by imitating adult speech. Working: the assertion is true and is commonly observed. The reason is false, because imitation alone cannot produce something never heard; that is exactly Chomsky's argument against a purely behaviourist account. So the answer is that the assertion is true but the reason is false. A quick check for assertion-reason items: first judge each part separately, and only if both are true ask whether the reason explains the assertion.
Judge each statement separately first. A right term with the wrong theorist, a reversed direction or an overstated 'only' or 'no part' makes a statement false.
Key takeaways
- Mand asks, tact names, echoic repeats: all are Skinner's reinforced verbal behaviour.
- Competence is rule knowledge; performance is actual speech with its slips.
- Piaget: thought leads, egocentric speech fades. Vygotsky: social speech becomes private and then inner speech.
- Mark statements true or false before reading the options; watch for 'only' and 'never'.
Check your understanding
-
1. A child who sees an aeroplane says 'plane!' and her father smiles and says 'Yes, a plane.' In Skinner's terms, the child's utterance is best called:
- a mand
- a tact
- an echoic
- a holophrase showing universal grammar
Show answer
Answer: B. The child names something she is in contact with and is reinforced by approval, which is a tact. A mand would be a request reinforced by getting the thing; an echoic would repeat words just heard.
-
2. Which statement about Chomsky's ideas is correct?
- Performance is the knowledge of rules that never shows in speech.
- Competence is the speaker's unconscious knowledge of the rules of the language.
- The environment plays no part at all in language development.
- Children learn grammar mainly through reinforcement of correct sentences.
Show answer
Answer: B. Competence is underlying rule knowledge. Performance is actual speech. Chomsky did not say the environment plays no part (a child needs to hear a language), and reinforcement is Skinner's explanation.
-
3. The 'poverty of the stimulus' argument is used to support which claim?
- Children must bring some built-in capacity for grammar to language learning.
- Children learn best when adults simplify all their speech.
- Thought develops before language in every child.
- Private speech becomes inner speech with age.
Show answer
Answer: A. The argument says the speech children hear is too limited to explain the grammar they acquire, so something must be innate. That is Chomsky's nativist claim.
-
4. Assertion: A child talks to herself more when a jigsaw puzzle becomes difficult. Reason: According to Vygotsky, private speech helps children guide their own actions. Choose the correct option.
- Both are true and the reason explains the assertion.
- Both are true but the reason does not explain the assertion.
- The assertion is true but the reason is false.
- The assertion is false but the reason is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Children's self-talk rises with task difficulty, and Vygotsky explains this as private speech used to plan and guide action. Both are true and the reason explains the assertion.
-
5. Consider: (1) Piaget held that language reflects thought. (2) Vygotsky held that thought always comes before language and is unaffected by it. (3) Skinner explained language through reinforcement. Which are correct?
- 1 and 2 only
- 1 and 3 only
- 2 and 3 only
- 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: B. Statement 2 is false: Vygotsky held that language shapes thought and that the two join and influence each other. Statements 1 and 3 are true.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.