- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Accommodation or modification? Classifying support correctly
Classify supports as accommodations or modifications using one test, avoid the common traps, and choose the least change that removes a child's barrier.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on support for children with learning difficulties often list arrangements and ask which is an accommodation, which is a modification, or which is the most suitable first. The foundation course gave the definitions. Here you will learn a single test that settles almost every case quickly, and practise on items designed to confuse.
The one-question test
Ask: Is the child still expected to learn and show the same thing, to the same standard, as the class? If yes, the change is an accommodation: it alters presentation, response, setting or timing. If no, because the content, amount or level of what must be learned or shown has been reduced or changed, it is a modification.
| Kind of change | Example | Classification |
|---|---|---|
| Presentation | Large print, audio version, questions read aloud (in a non-reading test) | Accommodation |
| Response | Answering orally, typing, pointing to choices | Accommodation |
| Setting | Quiet room, seat near the teacher, fewer distractions | Accommodation |
| Timing | Extra time, short breaks, test in two sittings | Accommodation |
| Content or level | Easier questions, fewer topics, simpler book | Modification |
| Standard | Lower passing level or different marking criteria | Modification |
Trap 1: what is being tested?
Reading questions aloud is an accommodation in a science or maths test, because reading is not what is being tested. In a test of reading comprehension, reading the passage aloud changes the skill measured into listening, so it becomes a modification of that assessment. Always ask what the task is meant to measure.
Trap 2: fewer questions
Fewer questions of the same kind and level that still cover the same skill can be an accommodation for a child who tires easily. Fewer questions that drop harder topics, or easier questions, change what is learned and so are modifications. Look for words such as easier, simpler, only, basic, which usually signal a modification.
The least change rule
When choosing support, start with the smallest change that removes the barrier. Try accommodations before modifications, because accommodations keep the child on the same learning goals as classmates and keep expectations high. Use modifications only when the child cannot reach the goal even with accommodations, and record them in the individualised plan.
Why does the distinction matter so much? A modification, once made, can mean the child slowly falls further behind the class curriculum, and the record of achievement must show the changed goal honestly. An accommodation, by contrast, lets the child's real ability show through. A child with dyslexia who knows her science well deserves a science mark that measures science, not her reading speed.
Worked example 1
Classify each for Neeraj, who has dysgraphia: (a) typing his social science answers; (b) 15 extra minutes in the science test; (c) answering 5 easy questions while the class answers 10 harder ones. (a) Same content and standard, changed response: accommodation. (b) Changed timing only: accommodation. (c) Fewer and easier questions: content and level changed, so modification. Two accommodations and one modification.
Worked example 2
Simran has dyslexia. Her English teacher must test reading comprehension. Which support keeps the test valid? Options: (i) teacher reads the passage aloud; (ii) extra time to read the passage herself; (iii) only two questions instead of six on easier lines. Working: (i) turns a reading test into a listening test, which changes what is measured. (iii) reduces content and level, which is a modification. (ii) keeps the same reading task and standard and only changes timing. Answer: (ii), extra time, is the accommodation that keeps the test measuring reading.
Same goal and standard, different route: accommodation. Changed content, amount, level or standard: modification. Ask what the task measures, and use the least change that works.
Key takeaways
- Accommodations change presentation, response, setting or timing.
- Modifications change content, level or standard.
- Reading aloud is an accommodation unless reading is the skill being tested.
- Words like easier, simpler and basic usually signal a modification.
- Try accommodations first; record any modifications in the individualised plan.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these supports for a child with dyscalculia in a maths test is a MODIFICATION?
- Letting him sit in a quieter corner while he writes the test
- Giving him ten extra minutes to finish the same test paper
- Printing his paper in larger type with more space between lines
- Giving him only one-step problems while the class does two-step problems
Show answer
Answer: D. Replacing two-step problems with one-step ones lowers the level, which changes the goal. The others change only setting, timing or presentation.
-
2. In a test of reading comprehension, the teacher reads the passage aloud to a child with dyslexia. This changes the test into one of:
- Listening comprehension, so it is a modification of that test
- Reading speed, so it is an accommodation of that test
- Writing skill, so it is an accommodation of that test
- Nothing at all; the test is unchanged in what it measures
Show answer
Answer: A. If reading is the skill measured, reading the passage aloud changes what is assessed, making it a modification.
-
3. Which arrangement is an ACCOMMODATION?
- Removing the map questions from her paper
- Allowing a child to answer a geography test orally
- Lowering the pass mark for her
- Setting her a simpler chapter to study
Show answer
Answer: B. Answering orally changes only the response mode; the others change content or standard.
-
4. Following the least change rule, which support should a teacher try first for a child who writes slowly?
- A simpler syllabus
- Exemption from all written tests
- Extra time for written work
- Lower marks needed to pass
Show answer
Answer: C. Extra time is an accommodation and the smallest change; the others change goals or standards.
-
5. Which word in a description most often signals a modification?
- 'Quieter'
- 'Larger print'
- 'Extra time'
- 'Easier'
Show answer
Answer: D. 'Easier' indicates the level of content has been reduced; the others describe setting, presentation or timing.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.