- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Assessment and children's misconceptions in EVS
Assess EVS learning through observation, records and portfolios, and recognise and respond to common misconceptions children hold.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The last teaching lesson asks how a teacher knows what children are learning in EVS, and what to do when their ideas are not yet correct. Because EVS is taught through activities, observation and talk, a written test alone gives a poor picture. And because children build their own explanations of the world, they often hold ideas that are reasonable to them but not scientifically correct. Both topics complete the foundation of EVS pedagogy.
Assessing EVS learning
Assessment in EVS looks at more than remembered facts. It looks at how well children observe, record, ask questions, explain, classify, work with others, and show care for their surroundings. Much of this can only be seen while children work, so continuous assessment during activities is central.
| Tool | What it is | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Observation | Watching children during activities, discussions and field trips | Skills such as observing, cooperating and questioning |
| Anecdotal record | A short dated note of something significant a child said or did | Growth in thinking over time |
| Checklist | A list of skills ticked when seen | Which skills each child shows |
| Portfolio | A collection of a child's work over time: drawings, survey sheets, project pages, notes | Progress and the range of the child's work |
| Oral and written tasks | Questions asking children to explain, not only recall | Understanding |
A portfolio is especially useful in EVS. It shows progress from the beginning of the year, lets the child look back at earlier work, and gives parents a real picture of learning. Children can help choose what goes into it, which makes them think about their own learning.
Children's misconceptions
A misconception is an idea a child firmly holds that differs from the accepted explanation. Children build such ideas from everyday experience, so they make sense to them. Examples include believing that plants take their food from the soil, that a whale is a fish because it lives in water and swims, or that the sun moves round the earth because it seems to cross the sky. Simply telling the child the right answer often fails, because the old idea stays.
A better approach has three parts. First, find out what children think, by asking them to explain or draw. Second, give an experience or evidence that the old idea cannot explain. Third, help children build the new idea and talk about how it fits what they saw.
Worked example 1
Situation: in a lesson on plants, several children say that plants eat soil. Question: how should the teacher respond? Working: the idea comes from seeing roots in soil. The teacher first asks children to explain and draw what they think. Then she shows that a plant kept in the dark grows weak and pale even with good soil and water, while one in sunlight stays green. Discussion follows: plants need sunlight, water and air to make their own food in their leaves; soil gives water and some minerals. Answer: elicit the idea, provide evidence, then build the correct idea through discussion, rather than just stating it.
Worked example 2
Situation: a teacher wants to assess how well children observe during a pond visit. Question: which tool fits best? Working: a written test after the trip would mainly show memory. Observing skills are seen while children work. Answer: a checklist used during the visit, noting for each child whether they observed closely, recorded findings and asked questions, with anecdotal notes for anything special, and the children's pond drawings added to their portfolios.
Assess EVS while children work: observe, note, collect work in portfolios. Treat misconceptions as children's own theories: find them out, challenge them with evidence, then build the new idea together.
Key takeaways
EVS assessment is continuous and looks at skills and attitudes as well as knowledge. Observation, anecdotal records, checklists and portfolios capture what tests miss. Misconceptions come from everyday experience; draw them out, give evidence that challenges them, and help children build the correct idea through discussion.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which tool collects a child's drawings, survey sheets and project pages over the year to show progress?
- Anecdotal record
- Single end-of-year test
- Portfolio
- Attendance register
Show answer
Answer: C. A portfolio is a collection of a child's work over time.
-
2. A short dated note of something important a child said or did during an activity is called:
- a portfolio
- a report card
- a rating of handwriting
- an anecdotal record
Show answer
Answer: D. Anecdotal records are brief notes of significant incidents or remarks.
-
3. A child insists that plants get their food from the soil. What is the best first step for the teacher?
- Ask the child to explain or draw the idea, to understand the child's thinking
- Tell the child that the idea is foolish, and give the correct explanation at once
- Ignore the idea and continue the lesson, since it is not in the textbook
- Give the child extra homework on the topic of how plants take their food
Show answer
Answer: A. Finding out the child's thinking comes first; then evidence and discussion can challenge it.
-
4. Why is written testing alone not enough in EVS?
- Skills such as observing, questioning and cooperating are best seen while children work
- Children in primary classes cannot write, and so a written test is not possible
- Written tests are not allowed in EVS under the rules of the board of education
- EVS has no knowledge to test, because it is only a subject of activities
Show answer
Answer: A. Many EVS learning goals are skills and attitudes that show up during activities.
-
5. A child says a whale is a fish because it lives in water. This is best described as:
- a misconception built from everyday experience
- a careless spelling mistake
- a sign the child cannot learn science
- a correct scientific idea
Show answer
Answer: A. The idea is reasonable from what the child has seen, but it differs from the accepted classification of whales as mammals.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.