- Advanced
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Methods under pressure: beliefs, goals and multi-statement items
Link each language-teaching method to its view of language and learning, choose methods for a goal, and solve multi-statement and assertion-reason items on methods.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The foundation course described six methods and the practice course taught you to identify them from lesson descriptions. Advanced items go a step further: they ask which belief lies behind a practice, which method suits a stated goal, or which of several statements about methods are true. This lesson prepares you for those judgements.
The belief behind each method
| Method | View of language | View of learning |
|---|---|---|
| Grammar-translation | A system of rules and words | Conscious study and translation |
| Direct | Spoken language met directly | Association of words with meaning, as in a first language |
| Audio-lingual | A set of spoken patterns | Habit formation through repetition and reinforcement |
| Communicative | A tool for communication | Using language for real meaning |
| Task-based | A tool for getting things done | Doing meaningful tasks, then attending to form |
| Bilingual | A new system linked to the known one | Meaning through the mother tongue, practice in the target language |
The table lets you answer 'belief' questions quickly, and the treatment of errors follows from the belief. A practice of immediate correction of every error to avoid wrong habits points to the audio-lingual view. A practice of accepting errors so that talk continues points to the communicative view. Note that 'direct method' does not mean 'no grammar'; grammar is there, but learned from examples rather than stated rules.
Choosing a method for a goal
Settled pedagogy does not crown one method. The better question is which features suit the goal and the learners. If the goal is fluent conversation, communicative and task-based features suit. If a few learners keep mispronouncing a sound, a short, focused repetition activity can help, even within a communicative lesson. If beginners cannot follow an abstract explanation in the new language, a brief explanation in the mother tongue, as in the bilingual method, saves time. Combining features thoughtfully for the learners is often called an eclectic approach.
Worked example 1: a multi-statement item
Statements: I. The audio-lingual method treats language learning as habit formation. II. The direct method encourages translation into the mother tongue. III. In communicative teaching, fluency is valued and errors are seen as part of learning. IV. Task-based learning usually attends to language form only before the task, never after. Working: I is true. II is false; the direct method avoids translation. III is true. IV is false; in task-based learning, attention to form usually comes after the task, and 'never' is a sign of a trap. Answer: I and III only.
Worked example 2: an assertion-reason item
A: In the audio-lingual method, learners' errors are corrected immediately. R: The method sees language learning as the formation of habits, and errors could become wrong habits. Working: A is true; R is true; joined with 'because', R gives the reason the method insists on immediate correction. Answer: both true and R explains A. If R were instead 'Communicative teaching uses information-gap activities', it would still be true, but it would say nothing about the audio-lingual method, so R would not explain A.
Speed method
For multi-statement items, decide each statement by mapping it onto the belief table, and watch for 'only', 'never' and 'always'. For assertion-reason items, check A, check R, then apply the 'because' test. For goal-matching items, choose the option whose features serve the goal for these learners, not the method that sounds most modern.
Each method follows from a belief: rules (grammar-translation), habits (audio-lingual), direct association (direct), communication (communicative), tasks (task-based), mother tongue as bridge (bilingual). Match features to the goal; no single method is always best.
Key takeaways
Know the view of language and learning behind each method, and the treatment of errors that follows from it. Choose methods by goal and learners. In mixed items, evaluate statements independently, eliminate fast, and use the 'because' test for assertion and reason.
Check your understanding
-
1. A teacher corrects every pronunciation error the moment it occurs so that 'wrong habits do not form'. This belief is closest to which method?
- Communicative approach
- Audio-lingual method
- Task-based learning
- Whole language approach
Show answer
Answer: B. Seeing errors as potential bad habits to be prevented is the audio-lingual view.
-
2. Which statements are correct? I. Grammar-translation gives most attention to reading and writing. II. The direct method relies on drills of memorised dialogues as its main technique. III. Communicative teaching uses pair and group work for real exchange of meaning.
- I and II only
- II and III only
- I and III only
- I, II and III
Show answer
Answer: C. II describes the audio-lingual method, not the direct method; I and III are correct.
-
3. A: In communicative teaching, a teacher may let minor errors pass during a role play. R: The aim of the activity is fluent communication of meaning. Which is correct?
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. Letting minor errors pass follows from the fluency aim of the activity.
-
4. Goal: Class 7 pupils should be able to ask for and give directions in the town. Which plan fits best?
- Pairs use a local map; one has places to find and the other gives directions, then they swap; useful phrases are reviewed afterwards
- Pupils translate a passage about directions into their mother tongue and then answer comprehension questions on it in writing
- Pupils memorise a list of direction words and their meanings for a test, and write each word five times
- Pupils copy the rules for giving directions from the board into their notebooks and learn them for a test
Show answer
Answer: A. A communicative, task-based activity with real exchange suits a goal about using directions.
-
5. Which statement is a trap?
- The bilingual method uses the mother tongue to make meanings clear
- The direct method means that no grammar is learnt at all
- Task-based learning focuses on a meaningful outcome
- An eclectic approach combines features of several methods
Show answer
Answer: B. In the direct method grammar is learnt from examples rather than stated rules; it is not absent.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.