• Advanced
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

A decision method for hard pedagogy scenarios

Use a four-step method to answer difficult mathematics pedagogy scenarios: find what is asked, read the evidence, predict the answer, then eliminate options by clear tests.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By this stage you know the theory: concrete-pictorial-abstract, van Hiele levels, the classic methods, Polya's steps, error analysis, remedial teaching and assessment. Hard questions do not test whether you know these ideas; they test whether you can apply the right one to a messy situation in which two or three options sound reasonable. This lesson gives a decision method you can use on every scenario in the rest of the course.

Step 1: find what is really asked

Scenario questions ask one of four things: name something (a level, stage, method, type of assessment), diagnose something (what the error reveals), choose the next action (what the teacher should do), or judge a practice (which is most or least appropriate). Underline the question word. Many wrong answers are true statements that answer a different question, for example a correct description of the error when the question asks for the next teaching step.

Step 2: read only the evidence

Decide from what the scenario shows, not from labels. If a pupil gives the same wrong answer on several items, that is evidence of a misconception. If the scenario mentions age or class, remember that van Hiele level and CPA stage are judged from the pupil's reasoning and materials, not from age. If the scenario describes feelings (freezing, avoiding, fear), anxiety is part of the problem even when the pupil knows the content.

Step 3: predict before reading the options

Say your own answer first. For a 'next action' question, a good prediction usually has three parts: it targets the diagnosed idea, it uses an approach different from the one that failed (often a step back in CPA), and it includes a check. Predicting first protects you from attractive wording in the options.

Step 4: eliminate with clear tests

Elimination tests
TestReject an option that...
Evidencelabels the pupil ('weak', 'careless', 'not intelligent') without evidence
Meaningrelies on memorising, copying or drilling a rule the pupil does not understand
Sequenceskips a stage or level, or teaches above the pupil's present thinking
Climateuses fear, public comparison or punishment
Targetanswers a different question from the one asked

After elimination, if two options remain, prefer the one that involves the pupil's own thinking and talk (explaining, representing, checking) over the one in which the teacher does the thinking.

Worked example 1

Scenario: 'A Class 4 pupil writes 4/5 + 3/5 = 7/10 on several items. The teacher has already explained the rule twice.' Question: what should the teacher do next? Step 1: next action. Step 2: the error repeats, so it is a misconception: the pupil adds denominators. Step 3, prediction: use fraction strips or drawings of fifths so the pupil sees that fifths added to fifths stay fifths, then ask the pupil to explain. Step 4: reject 'explain the rule a third time' (meaning test: same failed approach), 'tell the parents the child is weak' (evidence and climate tests), and 'move on to multiplication of fractions' (sequence test). Correct working: 4/5 + 3/5 = 7/5 = 1 2/5.

Worked example 2

Scenario: 'A Class 7 pupil gets most geometry homework right but in class tests leaves many questions blank and says her mind goes empty.' Question: what does this mainly suggest? Step 1: diagnose. Step 2: the pupil can do the work at home but not under test conditions, and she describes a mental block. That is evidence of maths anxiety, not missing knowledge. Step 3, prediction: anxiety; respond with low-stakes practice under gentle time conditions, and discussion of strategies. Step 4: reject 'she copies homework' (no evidence), 'she is at the visualisation level' (her homework shows she can do the work), and 'she needs harder homework' (target test).

Ask: what is asked, what is the evidence, what would I do? Then strike out options that label, rely on rote, skip stages, use fear, or answer a different question.

Key takeaways

Classify the question first, decide from evidence, predict before reading options, and eliminate with five tests: evidence, meaning, sequence, climate and target. When two options remain, choose the one in which the pupil does the thinking. The following lessons apply this method to harder error analysis, remedial design, geometry and assessment.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A pupil writes 2/7 + 3/7 = 5/14 on several items. What does the repeated error mainly show?

    1. A slip caused by hurrying
    2. That the pupil is not intelligent enough for fractions
    3. That the pupil does not know the 7 times table
    4. A misconception: the pupil adds the denominators as well as the numerators
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The same wrong rule appears on several items, which is a misconception. The correct sum is 5/7.

  2. 2. In a 'next action' question, which option should be eliminated first by the meaning test?

    1. Use fraction strips and ask the pupil to explain what happens
    2. Ask the pupil to draw the problem and talk through it
    3. Make the pupil copy the rule ten times without discussing it
    4. Give a new item and ask for a reason
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Copying a rule without understanding relies on rote, which fails the meaning test.

  3. 3. A question asks for the teacher's next step. One option correctly describes the pupil's misconception but suggests no action. Why is it wrong?

    1. Because describing misconceptions is never useful
    2. Because it labels the pupil without evidence
    3. Because it skips a van Hiele level
    4. It answers a different question (diagnosis) from the one asked (next action)
    Show answer

    Answer: D. This is the target test: a true statement that does not answer the question asked is still the wrong option.

  4. 4. A pupil does geometry well at home but freezes in class tests and says her mind goes blank. What is the most likely explanation?

    1. Maths anxiety under test conditions
    2. She is still at the visualisation level
    3. She has a misconception about angles
    4. She has not been taught the topic
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Her homework shows the knowledge exists; the problem appears only under test pressure, which points to anxiety.

  5. 5. After elimination, two options remain: 'The teacher demonstrates the method again' and 'Pupils explain their own method to a partner and check each other's answers'. Which is generally better, and why?

    1. The second, because the pupils do the thinking and talking
    2. The first, because the teacher's method is always correct
    3. The first, because pupil talk wastes time
    4. Neither, because both use concrete material
    Show answer

    Answer: A. When options are otherwise acceptable, prefer the one that engages pupils' own reasoning and explanation.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery